Wednesday, February 17, 2010

The Companies Most Pursued by NPEs

PatentFreedom has identified and profiled over 315 distinct NPEs and claims that, since 1985, these NPEs have been involved in litigation with nearly 4,500 different operating companies in over 3,100 distinct actions. Furthermore, nearly 75% of the suits between these NPEs and operating companies were filed since 2003.

PatentFreedom has tabulated the lawsuits between 2004-09 to determine the "most pursued" companies by NPEs:

(1)  Apple - 56 NPE Lawsuits
(2)  Sony - 55 NPE Lawsuits
(3)  Dell - 50 NPE Lawsuits
(4)  Microsoft - 49 NPE Lawsuits
(5)  HP - 48 NPE Lawsuits
(6)  Samsung - 48 NPE Lawsuits
(7)  Motorola - 46 NPE Lawsuits
(8)  AT&T - 44 NPE Lawsuits
(9)  Nokia - 42 NPE Lawsuits
(10)  Panasonic - 40 NPE Lawsuits
(11)  LG - 39 NPE Lawsuits
(12)  Verizon - 37 NPE Lawsuits
(13)  Toshiba - 36 NPE Lawsuits
(14)  Sprint Nextel - 34 NPE Lawsuits
(15)  Google - 33 NPE Lawsuits
(16)  Acer - 31 NPE Lawsuits
(17)  Time Warner - 31 NPE Lawsuits
(18)  Deutsche Telekom - 29 NPE Lawsuits
(19)  Kyocera - 28 NPE Lawsuits
(20)  Palm - 28 NPE Lawsuits
(21)  Cisco - 27 NPE Lawsuits
(22)  Fujitsu - 25 NPE Lawsuits
(23)  IBM - 25 NPE Lawsuits
(24)  Intel - 24 NPE Lawsuits
(25)  RIM - 24 NPE Lawsuits
(26)  HTC - 24 NPE Lawsuits

Interestingly, a number of these companies actually experied a decline in lawsuits compared to 2008:
Microsoft - 23% decline (10 cases in 2009, vs. 13 cases in 2008)
Samsung - 45% decline (6 cases in 2009, vs. 11 cases in 2008)
Motorola - 64% decline (9 cases in 2009, vs. 14 cases in 2008)
AT&T - 30% decline (7 cases in 2009, vs. 10 cases in 2008)
Palm - 40% decline (6 cases in 2009, vs. 10 cases in 2008)
RIM - 55% decline (5 cases in 2009, vs. 11 cases in 2008)
HTC -  40% decline (6 cases in 2009, vs. 10 cases in 2008)
According to PatentFreedom, NPE lawsuits dropped from 500 cases, to just over 450 cases in the last year.
 
Nevertheless, others companies experienced a significant increase in lawsuits over the previous year:
Apple - 62% increase (21 cases in 2009, vs. 13 cases in 2008)
Sony - 42% increase (17 cases in 2009, vs. 12 cases in 2008)
Dell - 113% increase (17 cases in 2009, vs. 8 cases in 2008)
Panasonic - 120% increase (11 cases in 2009, vs. 5 cases in 2008)
Toshiba - 60% increase (8 cases in 2009, vs. 5 cases in 2008)
IBM - 350% increase (9 cases in 2009, vs. 2 cases in 2008)
Regarding the most litigious NPE's (since 2003), Patent Freedom ranks them this way:
Acacia Technologies - 337 cases
Rates Technology Inc - 139 cases
Ronald A Katz Technology Licensing - 129 cases
Millennium LP - 110 cases
Plutus IP - 77 cases
Sorensen Research and Development Trust - 73 cases
General Patent Corp International - 72 cases
Cygnus Telecommunications Technology LLC - 69 cases
Papst Licensing GmbH - 62 cases
F&G Research Inc - 56 cases
To read more information on this topic, see PatentFreedom:'s website:

"Most Pursued Companies" (link)
"Litigations Over Time" (link)
"Most Litigious" NPE's (link)
"Largest Patent Holdings" (NPE) (link)
"Product Categorization" (link)

See also Joff Wild's take at the IAM blog: "Apple is the number one target for NPEs in the US" (link)

1 Comentário:

Gena777 said...

Though the companies being sued may find NPEs, or "patent trolls," annoying, most of the "trolls" are merely doing their jobs by enforcing patents that these major corporations should not have infringed.

Powered By Blogger

DISCLAIMER

This Blog/Web Site ("Blog") is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Use of the Blog does not create any attorney-client relationship between you and Peter Zura or his firm. Persons requiring legal advice should contact a licensed attorney in your state. Any comment posted on the Blog can be read by any Blog visitor; do not post confidential or sensitive information. Any links from another site to the Blog are beyond the control of Peter Zura and does not convey his, or his past or present employer(s) approval, support, endorsement or any relationship to any site or organization.

The 271 Patent Blog © 2008. Template by Dicas Blogger.

TOPO