Patent Busting Statistic Update: EFF responds to Acacia's boast that the chances of busting their '992 patent was "remote". CNN initially reported that "only 614 of the nearly 7 million existing patents have been revoked, according to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Some 3,927 patents have been narrowed since the agency began conducting re-examinations in 1981. The hardest part for challengers is qualifying for a re-exam at all." However, statistics from the United States Patent and Trademark Office show that 90 percent of reexamination requests are granted. They also show that 72 percent of granted requests result in either revocation or narrowing of patent claims.
Thursday, July 22, 2004
Tired of Compulsory Web Registration? Here is a great website that allows users to bypass sites (such as online newspapers, magazines, etc.). Just cut and past the link and it produces a log-in script to allow registered viewing.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:20 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Let's Get Metaphysical: The Fed. Cir. granted a petition today to rehear en banc the appeal of Phillips v. AWH Corp., which addressed the use of dictionaries in claim interpretation. The questions to be answered are:
1. Is the public notice function of patent claims better served by referencing primarily to technical and general purpose dictionaries and similar sources to interpret a claim term or by looking primarily to the patentee’s use of the term in the specification? If both sources are to be consulted, in what order?
2. If dictionaries should serve as the primary source for claim interpretation, should the specification limit the full scope of claim language (as defined by the dictionaries) only when the patentee has acted as his own lexicographer or when the specification reflects a clear disclaimer of claim scope? If so, what language in the specification will satisfy those conditions? What use should be made of general as opposed to technical dictionaries? How does the concept of ordinary meaning apply if there are multiple dictionary definitions of the same term? If the dictionary provides multiple potentially applicable definitions for a term, is it appropriate to look to the specification to determine what definition or definitions should apply?
3. If the primary source for claim construction should be the specification, what use should be made of dictionaries? Should the range of the ordinary meaning of claim language be limited to the scope of the invention disclosed in the specification, for example, when only a single embodiment is disclosed and no other indications of breadth are disclosed?
4. Instead of viewing the claim construction methodologies in the majority and dissent of the now-vacated panel decision as alternative, conflicting approaches, should the two approaches be treated as complementary methodologies such that there is a dual restriction on claim scope, and a patentee must satisfy both limiting methodologies in order to establish the claim coverage it seeks?
5. When, if ever, should claim language be narrowly construed for the sole purpose of avoiding invalidity under, e.g., 35 U.S.C. §§ 102, 103 and 112?
6. What role should prosecution history and expert testimony by one of ordinary skill in the art play in determining the meaning of the disputed claim terms?Consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision in Markman v. Westview Instruments, Inc., 517 U.S. 370 (1996), and our en banc decision in Cybor Corp. v. FAS Technologies, Inc., 138 F.3d 1448 (Fed. Cir. 1998), is it appropriate for this court to accord any deference to any aspect of trial court claim construction rulings? If so, on what aspects, in what circumstances, and to what extent?
Let the good times roll . . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:13 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, July 20, 2004
Eolas hits back at Microsoft in patent battle: The University of California has hit back at Microsoft in its pitched patent battle over fundamental Web browsing technology.
UC and its one-man software spinoff Eolas on 16 July filed a brief with the US Court of Appeals for the federal circuit to counter Microsoft's request for an appeal in a patent infringement case that has rattled the Web, from site authors to browser vendors to standards groups.
Last year, Microsoft got socked with a $521m (£279m) judgment after a jury found it guilty of infringing on Eolas's system for running plug-ins, applications like Macromedia's Flash animation software and Adobe's Acrobat document reader that run inside the Web browser.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:28 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
The General Public License: Phil Albert does a good summary of of GPL's and their application in the marketplace. There is no question that the GPL is an important product. It enjoys a huge portion of the license market relative to other licenses. Out of all the distinct software packages available today, a large percentage are licensed using the GPL, and except for "licenses" that simply put the software into the public domain, it is probably the most commonly used.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:20 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
HP Readies For War: What appears to be a leaked internal memo from HP shows that the company expected Microsoft to launch a full legal assault on free open-source software (FOSS) using patent law. The document, dated two years ago, details concerns at the highest levels within HP that "basically Microsoft is going to use the legal system to shut down open-source software".
According to Newsforge, HP in the US has confirmed the memo's legitimacy. A spokeswoman for HP in the UK was not immediately able to comment.
The memo goes on to say that HP would seek ways to "reduce our exposure" to open source and "lower our profile" while still shipping products. Although HP was covered by cross-licensing deals up to 2001, the memo said, patents filed after June 2001 that year would not be included.
"Microsoft could attack open-source software for patent infringements against OEMs, Linux distributors, and least likely open-source developers. They are specifically upset about Samba, Apache and Sendmail. We believe Samba is first, and they will attempt to prove it isn't covered by prior patent cross as a so called "clone" product carve out in the previous agreement," the memo said. "OEMs that don't have a cross (like SUN), or OEMs like HP that they force a change in their cross licence to exclude open-source software are probably the first target. Intel, Red Hat, SuSE, UBL, Oracle are probably in the first wave as well."
Microsoft embarked on a campaign last year to increase its revenue from patents and enlarge its intellectual property portfolio. It has received patents on a wide variety of apparently elemental computing components such as to-do lists, double clicking and storing documents in XML format, and had another 5000 applications in the pipeline as of November 2003. Last year, Microsoft also hired IP guru Marshall Phelps -- previously architect of IBM's $2bn-a-year IP strategy. He is on record as saying that Microsoft intends to spend $7bn annually on IP issues.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:11 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, July 19, 2004
Some Sobering Facts About EFF's Patent-Busting Effort: A small company called Acacia Research Corp. went after some of the biggest names in broadcasting last month, suing nine companies for about $100 million for allegedly violating its patent on streaming video.
That earned Acacia a spot on what the Electronic Frontier Foundation considers a top-10 list of intellectual property ignominy: patents the online civil liberties group is seeking to strike down as unwarranted and harmful to innovation.
"Good luck," said Paul Ryan, Acacia's chief executive. "Their chances are pretty remote."
Part fighting words. Part truth.
Only 614 of the nearly 7 million existing patents have been revoked, according to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. A total of 3,927 patents have been narrowed since the agency began conducting re-examinations in 1981. The hardest part for challengers is qualifying for a re-exam at all.
A challenger must find written evidence, called "prior art" in patent parlance, showing others developed the technology before the patent application was filed -- a formidable task that consumes a cottage industry of patent researchers and lawyers.
One-time startup BountyQuest set out in 2000 on such a quest. It wanted to debunk questionable patents by letting interested parties offer rewards of $10,000 or more for hard-to-find prior art. But there were few takers and the business failed.
The EFF is similarly relying on volunteers -- but without offering rewards. That's a surefire recipe for limited success, said Bradley Wright, a patent lawyer with Banner & Witcoff Ltd. "There are not a lot of people willing to spend free time to research for prior art."
Even when prior art is presented, re-exams are rare. The patent office held only 6,136 between the time the agency was authorized to do so in July 1981 and the end of March 2004, said Brigid Quinn, a patent office spokeswoman.
The Acacia patent the EFF objects to is on "the transmission of digital content via the Internet, cable, satellite and other means."
Another on its list, owned by Clear Channel Communications Inc., covers the distribution of digital recordings right after concerts.
"These companies are trying to claim a monopoly on the tools of free expression," said Jason Schultz, staff attorney at the foundation.
The group's list, chosen from 200 suggestions solicited through its Web site, focuses on patents it contends are being unfairly used to demand licensing fees from rivals or individuals.
Acacia and Clear Channel defend their patents and their right to seek royalties for intellectual property they say they spent millions to develop or buy.
Clear Channel bought the so-called Instant Live patent two months ago. It plans to charge an "extremely small" licensing fee -- $1 per event in some cases -- to artists who want to distribute freshly minted CDs after their concerts.
Acacia's digital media patents, granted to the founders of Greenwich Information Technologies in the 1990s, weren't enforced until Acacia bought them in 2001. Acacia has since secured dozens of licensing deals with companies ranging from adult entertainment sites to The Walt Disney Co. It sued the large cable and satellite providers for patent infringement last month.
Schultz and other patent busters hope their crusade will raise awareness about concerns the patent office is issuing baseless patents, because it lacks the resources to thoroughly investigate patent claims.
Even when prior art is presented, re-exams are rare. The patent office held only 6,136 between the time the agency was authorized to do so in July 1981 and the end of March 2004, said Brigid Quinn, a patent office spokeswoman.
The Acacia patent the EFF objects to is on "the transmission of digital content via the Internet, cable, satellite and other means."
Another on its list, owned by Clear Channel Communications Inc., covers the distribution of digital recordings right after concerts.
"These companies are trying to claim a monopoly on the tools of free expression," said Jason Schultz, staff attorney at the foundation.
The group's list, chosen from 200 suggestions solicited through its Web site, focuses on patents it contends are being unfairly used to demand licensing fees from rivals or individuals.
Acacia and Clear Channel defend their patents and their right to seek royalties for intellectual property they say they spent millions to develop or buy.
Clear Channel bought the so-called Instant Live patent two months ago. It plans to charge an "extremely small" licensing fee -- $1 per event in some cases -- to artists who want to distribute freshly minted CDs after their concerts.
Acacia's digital media patents, granted to the founders of Greenwich Information Technologies in the 1990s, weren't enforced until Acacia bought them in 2001. Acacia has since secured dozens of licensing deals with companies ranging from adult entertainment sites to The Walt Disney Co. It sued the large cable and satellite providers for patent infringement last month.
Schultz and other patent busters hope their crusade will raise awareness about concerns the patent office is issuing baseless patents, because it lacks the resources to thoroughly investigate patent claims.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:02 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, July 15, 2004
A Funny Dig at Microsoft: (*SATIRE*) Redmond, WA - The US patent office awarded US patent 9,724,341 to Microsoft for its unique method in creating massive vulnerabilities in its software using Internet Explorer and ActiveX.
"The patent office recognized that Internet Explorer and ActiveX are a unique innovation in operating system insecurity," shouted Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer. "Once again our innovations are being recognized, and our competitors, mainly Linux, will not be able to copy our security holes. Yes!"
Ballmer also screamed that Microsoft would leverage this patent to "charge excessive license fees to our competitors who also want to create insecure software."
Microsoft has used the technology on a smaller scale in its Office productivity suite, but plans a wider scale rollout among its other product lines, including its game titles, and even to its popular hardware lines. Microsoft's Vice President of Hardware Products, Kevin Torgo said, "Our popular mice and keyboards will be riddled with vulnerabilities in their next versions. I can't wait to see what we can do with this on the Xbox and Xbox Live."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:50 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Is Your Trademark a Time Bomb? Picking the wrong name for a business or product could land you on the receiving end of a costly suit
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:41 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
When To File for Patent Protection Overseas - a brief primer on foreign filing and the considerations that businesses need to make before filing.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:33 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, July 14, 2004
Acacia Update: On July 12, U.S. district judge James Ware announced the first results of the Markman hearings in the Acacia Media Technologies v. New Destiny Internet Group, et al. patent infringement case. While the Markman Order does not invalidate Acacia’s Digital Media Transmission (DMT) patents, it shows weak spots in patents that some regarded as bulletproof.
In patent litigation, Markman hearings are used for claim construction. Typically, the plaintiff and defendant set out a list of claim terms whose definitions are in dispute. To clarify the meaning of these terms (and subsequently the scope and validity of the patents), a trial judge weighs evidence and definitions as presented by the plaintiff and defendant and makes a ruling in the form of a Markman Order.
According to experts, the news for both Acacia and the defendants, all part the adult entertainment industry, was mixed. "Acacia got the construction on remote locations that they wanted," says Marc Kaufman, a patent attorney from Washington, D.C. firm Nixon Peabody who sat on the the Acacia panel at this year’s Streaming Media East. "On the other hand, they did not get the construction they wanted on identification and sequence encoding. It doesn’t strike me as a huge victory for either side."
Out of the19 disputed terms, Robert Berman, executive VP of business development and general counsel for Acacia, says, "For seven of the terms, the court adopted Acacia’s proposed definition; for five they adopted the defendants’. For three, the court said that they needed more information from experts. For four they came up with their own definitions."
One of the most significant passages in the order addresses the definition of "identification encoding means." The order states, in part: "The Court invites the Defendants to file a motion for summary judgment that the term `identification encoding means’ is indefinite, rendering claims 1, 3, 4, 5, 9, 10, and 11 of U.S. Patent 5,132, 992 to be invalid, respectively, pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 112." Thus, if a motion were made to move to summary judgment, it would mean that the patentee (Acacia) would have to give a full and adequate disclosure of the patent and what it covers, which is something that is initially determined by the patent office. "If the patent office deems that the patent satisfies 35 USC 112—i.e., to contain an adequate disclosure of the invention—most courts will defer to that," says Kaufman.
Of course, Acacia has its own take on the Markman hearing . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:37 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, July 13, 2004
Jenkins & Gilchrist Broiling Over Patent Licensing Program: In a dispute arising out of a multimillion-dollar patent licensing program, Jenkens & Gilchrist is asking a state court to block two attorneys formerly with the firm from disclosing "trade secrets and confidential information" that Jenkens alleges belong to the firm and an unnamed client.
Jenkens and L. Steven Leshin, a shareholder in the firm, filed the suit on June 25 in Dallas' 162nd District Court. The firm and Leshin allege in their petition in Jenkens & Gilchrist and L. Steven Leshin v. Stuart D. Dwork and Roger Maxwell that Dwork and Maxwell "drafted and threatened to file legal papers" that would cause "substantial harm" to the firm and an unnamed client.
Dwork was formerly of counsel at the firm, and Maxwell was a shareholder unitl the firm severed ties with him after he suffered a disabling stroke.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:09 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Acacia Update: Acacia Research Corporation announced today that the United States District Court for the Central District of California has issued a Markman Order giving the Court's construction of some of the disputed patent terms and phrases, and inviting further briefing or motions with respect to other patent terms that are in dispute in Acacia's ongoing litigation involving Acacia's DMT(R) patents against adult entertainment companies. The Court set a telephonic case management conference for August 17, 2004 at which time the Court will set a schedule for additional motions and briefing on Markman related issues.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:07 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Here's an interesting article on technology licensing theory - worth a quick read.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:04 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Target: RFID - RFID's promise of low-cost tags for asset tracking seems set to sour thanks to a patent lawsuit that is casting a cloud over standards work in the previously harmonious RFID world. Barcode supremo Intermec Technologies has sued RFID tag and reader maker Matrics, basing its claim on four patents.
"This could open up a world where who has what IP is what counts," said Erik Miehielsen, director of ABI Research. "It is not a disaster, but it could put up the cost of RFID systems, and delay the standards."
Intermec's lawsuit is strange because the company has showed little sign of litigation before, despite a lot of high profile activity and plenty of products in the field, and a solid set of patents, which include one for the basic idea of a thin, cheap, flexible radio beacon. Also, the patents could equally apply to virtually all the other vendors in the emerging RFID market, including giants such as Texas Instruments and Royal Philips Electronics, and new startups such as Alien Technology, yet the company is suing just one competitor, Matrics.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:01 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, July 12, 2004
Adobe Blasts Back at Patent Holding Company: Information Technology Innovation (ITI) filed suit against Adobe (Nasdaq: ADBE) in U.S. District Court in Colorado on June 2, 2004, seeking unspecified damages and an injunction against one of the biggest names in imaging software. Adobe made this information public in its SEC 10-Q filing on Thursday. In the filing, ITI alleges Adobe has infringed upon U.S. Patent Number 5,892,908, entitled, "Method of Extracting Network Information." ITI also is claiming that Adobe is infringing on this patent by the production and sale of its Acrobat product line. Adobe's Acrobat products create documents in the Acrobat portable document format (PDF) that then may be edited within Acrobat Standard or Professional, and viewed with its free Acrobat Reader.
Michael Gartenberg, vice president and research director at Jupiter Research, said that ITI's suit provides another example of why patent reform is necessary in the technology sector, where vague and ambiguous patents have generated wasteful litigation.
For his part, Gartenberg believes that to some degree, people need to consider the source of the lawsuit. He pointed out that Adobe is an industry heavyweight reporting profitable earnings, while the plaintiff, in contrast, is an unknown.
"You don't sue poor people and poor companies. However, it is hard to imagine Adobe not prevailing in this case," Gartenberg said.
- Sounds pretty confident to me . . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:19 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Samsung Gets Slapped in Patent Dispute With Mosaid: Mosaid Technologies, which is in a patent dispute with Samsung, said Thursday that a U.S. court has imposed sanctions against Samsung for its failure to hand over certain documents and failure to destroy e-mail evidence related to the case. As a result of the decision, Mosaid said, when the case reaches trial the jury will be instructed that it should draw an adverse inference from Samsung's actions.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:17 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, July 09, 2004
Katz Patent Under Re-exam: For those "in the know", Katz is a counterpart to the illustrious Lemelson, and have caused quite a few sleepless nights for the telecoms. People have been trying to ding his portfolio for quite some time now, but there has been little success.
5,259,023, Reexam. C.N. 90/007,058, Requested Date: Jun.
02, 2004, Cl. 379/088.9, Title: TELEPHONIC-INTERFACE STATISTICAL
ANAYSIS SYSTEM, Inventor: Ronald A. Katz, Owners of Record:
Ronald A. Katz Technology Licensing, L. P., Beverly Hills, CA,
Attorney or Agent: Reena Kuyper, Esq. & Byard Nilsson, Esq., Los
Angeles, CA, Ex. Gp.: 2645, Requester: Donald E. Stout, Arlington, VA
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:53 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
China Rescinds Viagra Patent: China yesterday defended its decision to overturn Pfizer's patent for Viagra in a ruling seen as a setback to protection of intellectual property rights in the country. The US makers of the top selling erectile disfunction drug were in breach of China's intellectual property rights (IPR) law when they failed to accurately explain "technological" uses of Viagra's key ingredient, an official with the State Intellectual Property Office (SIPO) said.
What a joke - this is my favorite quote - when talking to an official at SIPO, the official said:
"We did grant the patent to Pfizer before, but that does not mean that we are really giving it to you"
Great.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
It doesn't get any dumber than this
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:45 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, July 07, 2004
Software Patents in the EU are in Trouble: the Dutch are starting to get cold feet, and now it looks like others may be backing out, where officials in a number of European countries say that votes cast by ministers during the meeting to hammer out political differences did not reflect the position of their governments. Messy, messy, messy . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:28 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Now Microsoft Has Ergonomic Keyboards to Worry About - Encinitas inventor William Louis has been fighting Microsoft Corp. since 1998 over patents for ergonomic keyboards – with very little success.
Yesterday, he finally had something to smile about.
A federal appeals court resurrected Louis' long-running federal lawsuit accusing the software company of patent infringement.
In the decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, the court said a U.S. District Court judge in San Diego made a mistake when she ruled that patents held by TypeRight Keyboard Corp. for V-shaped keyboards with wrist rests were invalid. Louis co-founded TypeRight in the early '90s.
Although the appeals court didn't take a stand on whether TypeRight's patents are valid, it did say evidence Microsoft presented to the San Diego court was less than ironclad.
"The federal circuit found that this issue should be decided by a jury, that juries are supposed to resolve factual disputes," said Matthew Herron, a San Diego patent lawyer who represents TypeRight.
The case is likely to be sent back to San Diego, although Microsoft still has time to ask the appeals court to reconsider. Microsoft and its lawyers did not return telephone calls.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:23 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Europe Upholds Patent on Altered Mouse - The European Patent Office on Tuesday upheld a Harvard University patent on a mouse genetically altered to develop cancer, but restricted its wording so that it applies only to mice and not to all species of rodents.
The pan-European patent, granted in 1992, protects the method of producing the animals. But the ruling, which closes a years-long legal battle with environmental groups, added further qualifications to a 2001 ruling that limited the patent to rodents, rather than mammals in general.
The patent office acknowledged concerns about ethical questions and animal rights, but also said the medical uses of the patent must be weighed.
A collection of church, environmental and animal protection groups, among them Greenpeace, had argued for the patent to be canceled, saying that it violated the dignity of living beings. After the 2001 ruling, six organizations filed an appeal.
Greenpeace spokesman Christopher Then welcomed the restriction as an "important partial success," but expressed regret that the European Patent Office hadn't backed off recognizing patents for mammals.
The development of the mouse was intended to ease research and treatment of tumors in humans.
The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office granted a patent to the Harvard mouse in 1988, the first "transgenic" animal patent to be granted.
The patent from the Munich-based European Patent Office is valid in 11 European countries.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:20 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, July 06, 2004
Timing Is Everything, Isn't It? The next time you wave a key card to unlock the door to your office building, think of Charles Walton. Walton's patents on radio frequency identification, or RFID, spawned those electronic door keys. Now the technology Walton — one of Silicon Valley's unsung inventors — pioneered in the 1970s and 1980s is poised to change the way billions of products are tracked.
Prodded by Wal-Mart and the Pentagon, manufacturers will soon be tagging everything from diapers to combat boots with RFID chips. The chips transmit information about products' location and use over radio waves to a central computer. Libraries are using RFID to keep tabs on books while hospitals embed radio chips on pharmaceutical bottles to make sure drugs are not misused. A Barcelona nightclub scans RFID chips implanted under patrons' skins when they want to pay for a drink wirelessly.
For Walton, industry's embrace of RFID is bittersweet. Back in the 1970s, the bar code was a 25-cent solution that beat out Walton's $1.75 RFID cards as the identification system for goods scanned over supermarket checkout scanners. Now RFID may well eliminate the ubiquitous bar code.
Walton, 83, made about $3 million from patenting RFID technology. But his last royalty-bearing RFID patent expired in the mid-1990s, meaning that he won't share in the potentially gigantic windfall that will be generated as Wal-Mart and the Defense Department begin to require their largest suppliers to put RFID tags on millions of warehoused goods.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:53 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Europe's patent office hears genetic rodent appeal
The European Patent Office began hearing Monday an appeal against a patent issued for a genetically modified rodent that its inventors claim can be useful in cancer research.
The appeal against Harvard University's so-called Oncomouse patent, the first ever granted for a transgenic animal, was launched by six organisations from Austria, Britain, Germany and Switzerland.
Using the Oncomouse technique, scientists can alter a gene in the rodents and make them more likely to develop tumours, which means they can be used to test whether a material might contain carcinogens.
The six groups claim that the patent is "contrary to public order and morality" and that it does not meet some of the requirements of patent law.
The environmentalist group Greenpeace, which is not involved in the appeal, also staged a protest as the first day of the oral hearings got underway at EPO headquarters in Munich, southern Germany.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:49 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Nintendo Gets Targeted by EFF: It has today been reported that Nintendo are amongst one of ten patents that the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) is looking to overturn because they claim the patent is “too sweeping” or generalised.
Claiming to be amongst the “biggest threats to the public domain”, the EEF claims Nintendo are amongst 10 of the worst software-related patents in the US, because they are threatening and filing suits against small businesses, individuals and non-profit organisations.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, July 02, 2004
European Patent Organization Forms an "Academy": With a view to fostering the development and harmonization of patent-related intellectual property law and practice within its member states, the European Patent Organization has adopted regulations setting up a European Patent Academy. The new institution will be managed by the European Patent Office (EPO) and will have its seat in Munich. In close co-operation with national, European and international institutions and organizations, its main task will be to develop a Europe-wide training and education scheme for the benefit of the European patent system. The Academy is expected to commence functioning in the course of 2005. The creation of the European Patent Academy reflects the need to improve intellectual property-related training and education structures in Europe.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:30 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Troubles on the Rising Sun Horizon? This case is the latest in a series of court disputes in Japan regarding the transfer of patent rights to companies by inventors on their payrolls. A former Sharp Corp employee has sued the consumer electronics maker for 500 mln yen over key technology he claims to have developed for use in flat screen products, while in January the Tokyo District Court ordered Japanese firm Nichia Corp to pay a record 20 bln yen to the inventor of the revolutionary blue light-emitting diode (LED).
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:24 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
10 MOST WANTED: Start forming your patent-busting posses! Today, the Electronic Frontier Foundation's Patent Busting Project announced which patents the organization will target first in its campaign to rid the world of frivolous patent infringement lawsuits.
After sifting through dozens of software and Internet-related patents submitted to its patent busting contest, EFF targeted ten whose crimes have made them enemies of the public domain. All the most-wanted patents are dangerously overbroad; many pose a threat to freedom of expression online. And every single one of the targeted patents is held by an entity that has threatened or brought lawsuits against small businesses, individuals, or nonprofits.
Target number one is Acacia, a company that has litigated relentlessly against small businesses to enforce patents that it claims cover a broad array of technologies used to send and receive streaming media online. Victims of Acacia's legal threats include websites that host home videos and several "mom-and-pop" adult media companies.
Other offenders include Acceris, which claims that its patents cover any technologies (such as Voice over Internet Protocol, or VoIP) that allow people to make phone calls over the Internet, and ClearChannel, which has been threatening artists and small CD companies that record live concerts and burn them to CDs for fans at the end of a show. Another target is Test.com, which has a patent on a method for taking and scoring tests online, and has been sending threatening letters to universities with distance learning programs.
"Patents are meant to protect companies against giant competitors, not to help them prey on folks who can barely afford a lawyer," said EFF Staff Attorney Jason Schultz, who leads the Patent Busting Project. "We hope our project will not only assist the victims of these abusive patents but also help make the case for global reform of the patent system."
With its targets in sight, EFF's team of lawyers, technologists, and experts will now begin to research and collect prior art. Prior art is hard evidence that a patent is "obvious" because it is based on a commonly known idea or because the claimed "invention" actually existed before the patent was filed. Once the team has gathered enough prior art on a given patent, EFF will submit a petition to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in a legal process known as "reexamination." If the USPTO finds the prior art compelling, it will formally revoke the patent and release the idea back into the public domain, where it belongs.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:23 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, June 29, 2004
Heading off VoIP Spam at the Pass: Qovia, Inc. today announced that it has filed a patent application for a method to identify and block VoIP Spam and prevent security problems such as Denial of Service (DoS) attacks that have the potential to overload voice servers and affect system reliability. The patent application, titled, “System and Method for Broadcasting VoIP Messages,” covers the use of VoIP for emergency broadcast as well as provides for methodologies to prevent inappropriate use of VoIP applications such as Spam over Internet Telephony, also known as SPIT or VoIP Spam.
VoIP Spam is a combination of telemarketing calls and e-mail spam in which a single “caller” uses Internet technology to send thousands of voice messages simultaneously into callers’ VoIP voice mailboxes. The United States Telecommunications Association recently described this capability as a top security challenge ahead for the telephony industry. In an attempt to prevent the spread of VoIP Spam, Qovia has created an application that can identify unsolicited and unwanted messages and differentiate these messages from those that recipients desire to receive. Qovia plans to incorporate this tool into a security module that will be available as part of the company’s VoIP Monitoring and Management System (VMMS) later this year.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 12:09 PM 1 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Intersting Take on Patent Office Services: London businesses can win a free consultation on protecting their innovations, brands and creative works in a new Patent Office initiative.
The businesses can register at the new website www.the-key.biz to secure a chance of receiving one of 200 consultations being offered by the Chartered Institute of Patent Agents (CIPA) and Institute of Trade Mark Attorneys (ITMA).
Their legal experts will advise businesses on how to exploit their intellectual property to grow their business and ways to protect them from unscrupulous competition.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 12:06 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Patent Wars Go Wireless: Canadian broadband wireless technology provider Wi-LAN is suing industry giant Cisco Systems for patent infringement, Wi-LAN officials announced Thursday. And if the lawsuit goes well, the company may keep on suing.
All of the patents in question relate to OFDM (orthogonal frequency division multiplexing), the modulation technique that enables high-speed data transfers for both the 802.11g and 802.11a IEEE WLAN (wireless LAN) standards.
Wi-LAN comes at Cisco hot off a win in a similar patent dispute with Toronto-based Redline Communications. Last month in an if-you-don't-want-to-fight-'em-join-'em move, Redline signed a royalty agreement with Wi-LAN, settling the 2-year-old case.
Given the wide reach of OFDM, it's fair to question the impact of the suit on the industry. But don't look for it to cripple development efforts. OFDM is already out there. No one's going to call it back. Certainly not Wi-LAN. It's using the courts to help it enlist partners who haven't exactly rushed to its doors to license the company's technology.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 12:02 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, June 28, 2004
Sharp Fires Another Shot Over LCD Patents: Tokyo Customs has accepted a request by Sharp Corp (6753.TK) to halt the importation of LCD (liquid crystal display) televisions sold by the Japanese unit of major Taiwanese electronics firm Teco Electric & Machinery Co, The Nihon Keizai Shimbun reported.
The Japanese consumer electronics maker made the request, citing patent infringement.
This decision effectively suspends customs clearance procedures for the TVs in question -- 20-inch Teco LCD TVs sold by Sankyo Co, Teco's Tokyo-based sales unit.
The TVs were being sold by major supermarket chain operator Aeon Co (8267.TK) and a Tokyo-based volume electronics retailer. They were also sold for less than 80,000 yen over the internet. But both firms have already stopped marketing them.
The TVs include LCD panels made by Taiwan's AU Optronics Corp (AUO), the third-largest producer of the parts. Sharp claimed that the Taiwanese company infringed on its patent rights in producing the panels.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:28 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Merger Updates: Wildman, Harrold Allen & Dixon, a 211-lawyer Chicago-based law firm, is actively looking to acquire or merge with another law firm, according to several legal sources. One said the search had become heated of late, with the firm hiring a consultant to sift options.
While declining to discuss specific plans, managing partner Robert Shuftan noted Wildman has added 25 to 30 partners in the last two years. "We're looking at further opportunities to expand, both in Chicago and elsewhere,'' he said.
Perkins Coie LLP, the largest law firm in the Puget Sound area with approximately 550 lawyers firmwide, is merging with Phoenix-based Brown & Bain, a firm known for its work in intellectual property and complex litigation.
The merger will close July 1 and make Phoenix the second-largest office for Perkins Coie. The firm's largest office is in downtown Seattle
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:22 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, June 25, 2004
The IEEE Takes on Acacia - This article is a must-read for anyone dealing with patent holding companies, and especially for those lucky ones who are dealing with Acacia. By its own account, Acacia is the only publicly traded company in the world that does nothing but acquire and license patents, and sue other companies over the patents it acquires and licenses.
The company had 2003 revenues of just $692 000, all from the streaming media patents. (Though the V-chip patent didn't expire until midyear, its license fees were all taken in 2001.) With more and more licensees signing up, Acacia couldn't say how much it would take in for 2004. But by February, its licenses in hand were worth $2 million per year. It was only in late 2002 that Acacia began sending out glossy folders to possible infringers, with polite letters asking them to take out licenses.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:41 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Interesting New Fuel Cells: A tiny prototype fuel cell the size of a thumb has been developed by Toshiba. The Japanese electronics giant said the methanol fuel cell could power gadgets such as a digital music player for 20 hours.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:38 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, June 24, 2004
China Makes a Push for Chemical Patents: Huayi Group Company, one of China's chemical giants, set up a technology research institute over the weekend as part of its technical creation system aiming to compete with overseas counterparts showing strong presence in China.
The institute, which merges all of the company's technical strengths, is aimed at creating more patent technologies, said Huayi Chairman Zhang Peizhang.
"We need our own high-tech patents to compete with overseas counterparts which have got a firm foothold on the Chinese market," Zhang said.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:54 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Another Business-Method Patent in Re-Exam: Affinity Technology Group, Inc. (OTCBB:AFFI) today announced that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (PTO) has granted a request for reexamination filed by Ameritrade Holding Corporation and Federated Department Stores related to the Company's patent covering the fully automated establishment of financial and credit accounts (U.S. Patent No. 6,105,007). As previously announced, the Company has filed a lawsuit against both Ameritrade and Federated alleging infringement of U.S. Patent No. 6,105,007. The Company has agreed to stay the lawsuits pending the conclusion of the PTO's reexamination.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:51 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Digital Holographic Technology: THe Next Big Thing? 3DIcon Corporation, a communications development company, today announced that there appear to be no significant intellectual property obstacles to its unique pursuit of the development and commercialization of digital holographic technology. In his first public account following 3DIcon's April launch of a collaborative relationship with the University of Oklahoma (OU), CEO Martin Keating said, "OU's findings that our three-part focus and planned development have little or no patent competition is most encouraging. This industry is indeed in its infancy. It's exciting to know that we're poised to acquire the necessary patent rights to participate in what we believe will become a multi-billion-dollar industry."
Over a two-month period, the University of Oklahoma has determined that fewer than fifty U.S. patents have been issued for inventions in the field of holographic technology related to the areas being pursued by 3DIcon. "We thought there might be hundreds of patents already granted," Mr. Keating commented. "But not even a dozen have been issued in the particular areas that our technology assessment is pointing to. The bottom line is, this field is wide open. That's most encouraging to us. We certainly hope that the University of Oklahoma will become the epicenter of this fascinating new
technology," he concluded.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:45 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, June 23, 2004
PatentCafe Intoduces Infringement Litigation Suite to Uncover Prior Art: In a move to provide a new weapon to curb skyrocketing costs and manpower hours in patent infringement litigation, PatentCafe has introduced its electronic patent prior art discovery solution called The Infringement Litigation Suite (ILS). Nearly three thousand lawsuits filed each year in the U.S. alleging patent infringement, and infringement awards have reached as high as $1/2 billion. Litigation teams can now turn to PatentCafe to help them deploy the same technology that allows robust data mining for quick discovery of prior art patent most relevant to the particular infringement suit.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:54 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
And Speaking of Prior Art . . . Harrah's Entertainment, Inc. (NYSE: HET) said it plans to appeal a recent decision by the United States District Court for the District of Nevada granting a Station Casinos, Inc. motion for summary judgment in patent litigation between the two companies. In granting Station's motion, the District Court last month ruled that Harrah's Customer Recognition Patents and a portion of the 013 Patent are invalid. The District Court denied other motions by Station seeking to invalidate and render unenforceable the patents. The District Court has additional motions pending with respect to the portion of Harrah's 013 Patent claims that are not affected by the invalidity ruling. Harrah's will dismiss the unaffected 013 Patent claims, and will not pursue those claims against Station.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:51 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Perhaps This Patent is the Next One to Fall? Washington Mutual, Inc. (NYSE:WM), one of the nation's leading retailers of financial services, today announced that the U.S. Patent Office has issued a patent for the company's retail banking approach and several more are pending. This is the first patent issued in the country to describe a full-service branch concept.
Specifically, U.S. patent No. 6,681,985 describes Washington Mutual's retail banking stores as places that "create a welcoming and inviting environment for a customer" and are "in sharp contrast to traditional bank branches." Instead, they have been "transformed into a more retail-like environment."
According to the patent's description, embodiments of the invention include the teller towers which remove the traditional barrier of a teller line and allow easier interaction between the customer service representative and the customer. Also described were the circular or oval layout of the retail banking stores, the concierge desk where customers are greeted and guided to the appropriate service area, and a kids' play area included in many of the company's stores. Further noted was the access to online banking through wamu.com and bank employees who are hired for their high sales aptitude in order to cross-sell the company's financial products.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:44 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, June 21, 2004
US standard of patent approval 'down sharply': An article highlighting two books coming out by US economists that submit that the US patent system is "broken". From 1983 until last year, the number of applications to protect inventions tripled to 355,418. The number of approvals rose at about the same rate from 59,715 to 189,597, according to the US Patent Office.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
EuroLinux Attacks EU's Software Patent: although software isn't patentable in Europe under the Munich Convention, the European Patent Office (EPO) has been granting patents which can be used to protect programming techniques, computer programs and software. This is happening because of a loophole in the Munich Convention which allows industrial inventions based on innovative programming techniques to be patented. The EU is currently considering removing computer programs from the exceptions list of the Munich Convention, and this would effectively open the floodgates. "It would be possible to use patents to get a monopoly on the use of a business method or an electronic commerce method by patenting as such its implementation in a program for computers," says the Alliance, which has assembled a group of ten industry luminaries, including Tim Berners-Lee, to lobby against the change.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:40 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Building That Mousetrap: In early 2000, when Julia Rhodes was an eighth-grade teacher, her high school son asked her to get his basketball coach a gift -- a whiteboard and markers for diagramming plays. "But he told me to get markers with erasers," she said, "because the coach was always using his hand or his shirt." Rhodes couldn't find markers with erasers. She was amazed. She was frustrated. And she was inspired.
Four years later, Rhodes isn't a teacher anymore.
Instead, she is a walking, talking, strutting testimony to the entrepreneurial golden rule of finding a need and filling it. She is the inventor, patent holder, outsourcer, marketer and distributor of KleenSlate -- a whiteboard eraser that comes in two sizes to fit various brands of whiteboard markers.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:37 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, June 18, 2004
USPTO Agrees to Reassess Microsoft's FAT Patent
The US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) recently agreed to reexamine Microsoft's controversial FAT patent, which covers an aging version of the technology behind the Windows file system. The reexamination is courtesy of a petition from the Public Patent Foundation (PUBPAT), which feared that Microsoft could use the patent to hobble Linux because Linux uses a free Windows operability tool called Samba, which needs access to FAT to read and write files to Windows systems. PUBPAT believes that Microsoft can use wrongly issued patents to harm the public by "making things more expensive, if not impossible to afford" and "by restraining civil liberties and individual freedoms." PUBPAT points to a Microsoft description of FAT that it says explains the reexamination: "FAT is the ubiquitous format used for interchange of media between computers, and, since the advent of inexpensive, removable flash memory, also between digital devices."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:32 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
WASHINGTON, June 18 /PRNewswire/ -- Continuing the expansion of its intellectual property practice, international law firm Crowell & Moring LLP has added two partners to its more than 40-lawyer roster of IP lawyers. Michael J. Songer, a former partner at Arnold & Porter LLP, and Mark M. Supko, a former partner at IP boutique Kenyon & Kenyon, have joined the firm in its Washington, DC office.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:12 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, June 17, 2004
When To Interview: A helpful article discussing the general process of Examiner Interviews before the USPTO
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:56 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
To Dream the Impossible Dream: EGOceutical, a New Jersey based supplement manufacturer, has launched a new hangover and carb blocking supplement that uses a proprietary patent-pending dual-action system to obliterate the two negative aspects of beer drinking, the weight gain from high amounts of carbohydrates and the morning-after dreaded hangover. This revolutionary product is called Beer Neutralizer™ and it has been taking the nation by storm since it’s inception in April 2004.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:54 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
$153.6 Million Whopper: Shell Oil, a unit of Royal Dutch-Shell Group of Companies, must pay Dow Chemical's Union Carbide $153.6 million in damages for infringing a patent for catalysts, a judge has ruled.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:52 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, June 16, 2004
Losing Your Lawyer? A good article posted on bordmember.com on "Moves To Make If You Lose Your Lawyer".
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:54 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Cooley Names New Chair of IP Litigation Practice: "Cooley Godward is pleased to announce that Steve Swinton has been named chair of the Firm's Intellectual Property Litigation practice. As chair, Mr. Swinton will work closely with colleagues Frank Pietrantonio, chair of the Patent Counseling & Prosecution practice, and Anne Peck, chair of the Trademark, Copyright & Advertising practice."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:51 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Nokia Takes License on RIM Patent to Spawn Blackberry-Enabled Products: Research in Motion (RIM), the maker of the BlackBerry e-mail service, hailed on Tuesday a licensing deal that will help Nokia launch a BlackBerry-enabled phone in the United States.
Finland's Nokia, the world's largest mobile phone maker, signed a deal with NTP Inc. on Monday for five patents at the center of a bitter legal dispute between RIM and NTP, a radio communications company based in Arlington, Virginia.
Nokia signed an agreement with Ontario-based RIM in 2002 to license its popular e-mail service, but it has not launched its BlackBerry-powered 6820 handset in the United States, citing concerns over litigation between RIM and NTP.
"We're thrilled beyond thrilled. There's a very big backlog of orders for the BlackBerry-enabled 6820," RIM Chairman and Co-CEO Jim Balsillie told reporters in Toronto.
"We're thrilled to have a partnership with Nokia, we've worked on it for two years. We've wanted this product in market as soon as possible."
Analysts said on Tuesday RIM stood to benefit from the "bittersweet" Nokia/NTP deal.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:47 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Acacia at at Again: For those "in the know", Acacia is considered one of the bigger "patent extortionists" (as it were) in the streaming video technologies. A previous attempt to sue porn sites has garnered a lot of attention, as the company underestimated the depth of the pockets of the people running these sites. Now, Acacia has started targeting smaller cable companies in order to rack up those ever-important licensing fees.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:42 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Apologies to everyone for not posting over the last week. A hectic schedule and unexpected happenings caused a major hiccup in my schedule. Posting will resume posthaste.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:41 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, June 07, 2004
BlackBerry Case: Is it really possible that Bill Gates, Pamela Anderson and phalanxes of stockbrokers, lawyers and congressional staff members will have to give up one of their most treasured possessions: their BlackBerries?
Today in Washington, judges at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit are scheduled to ponder whether Research in Motion, the Canadian maker of the much-coveted BlackBerry hand-held wireless e-mail device, should be barred from business in the United States. At issue is who has the patent for the BlackBerry's technology.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:44 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, June 04, 2004
Open Source v. Software Patents: a quick read from CNET on the impact software patents have been having on the open source movement. It appears that defense funds are becoming quite the rage . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:05 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Spam, spam, spam, spam : Few things can bring rivals together like a shared hatred of spam. Longtime foes Microsoft and Yahoo welcomed each others' proposals for fighting spam at the Inbox e-mail technology conference this week, saying that their seemingly competing tactics were in fact complementary and could be offered together in antispam tools as early as next year. Both companies have spent several months developing ways to harden the Internet's infrastructure against spammers.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:59 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
GOOGLE v. YAHOO - could this be the next dotcom mega-battle? Google is the darling of the Internet and seemingly at the top of its game as it charges toward a public stock offering sometime this summer.
But the Mountain View company could be paying hundreds of millions of dollars to its Sunnyvale archrival, Yahoo, if it loses a little-noticed patent lawsuit unfolding in a San Jose courtroom.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, June 03, 2004
One click, two click, three click, four : Microsoft has successfully patented using short, long or double clicks to launch different applications on "limited resource computing devices" - presumably PDAs and mobile phones. The US patent was granted on 27 April.
Now any US company using a variety of clicks to launch different software functions from the same button will have to change their product, pay licensing fees to Microsoft or give Microsoft access to its intellectual property in return.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:30 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Another partner leaves Frost Brown Todd
For the second time in a month, a partner with the Louisville office of law practice Frost Brown Todd has left the firm for another job.
Arthur S. Beeman, former co-chairman of Frost Brown Todd's intellectual property litigation practice group, has taken a job as director and head of the patent litigation practice at Howard Rice Nemerovski Canady Falk & Rabkin in San Francisco, according to a news release.
The release said Beeman has both defended clients against patent infringement allegations and represented clients in claims against their patents.
Howard Rice's intellectual property practice group consists of more than 30 attorneys. The firm's clients include PalmSource Inc., Ariba Inc., Hewlett-Packard Co. and the United States Olympic Committee.
According to a previous Business First report, Jay Tannon, a former Frost Brown Todd partner, left the firm in May for a position with the law firm of Pillsbury Winthrop LLP in Virginia.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:26 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Brits Dumping on the US Patent System: Mad cap patents ranging from protecting a method of painting by dipping a baby's bottom into paint or a system for keeping track of people queuing for the bathroom may soon be a thing of the past if the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has its way. Such patents, while humorous, clearly show both how broken the American patent system and how lax standards are hurting innovation when it comes to business, the Commission says.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:21 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, June 02, 2004
The United States Patent and Trademark Office (Office) is revising the rules of practice to allow for more efficient rocessing of powers of attorney and assignment documents within the Office. For example, the Office will require applicants to use the Office’s Customer Number practice if more than ten registered patent practitioners are to be made of record. In addition, the Office is eliminating some mail stops (i.e., CPA, Provisional Patent Application) that were found not be useful in routing correspondence within the Office, and creating a new mail stop (Licensing and Review) to assist the Office in the proper routing of national security classified and secrecy order papers. Finally, because the Office is discontinuing the current Office practice of returning patent and trademark assignment documents submitted by mail for recording in the assignment database, only copies of assignment documents may be submitted for recording in the Office’s
Assignment records.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, June 01, 2004
Good Things Come To Those Who Wait - In 1977 Andreas Pavel applied for a patent for a "portable small component for the hi-fidelity reproduction of recorded sound". The player, named "stereobelt", never saw the light of day. When Sony introduced its Walkman in 1979, it became the most successful portable music player on the market. Sony sold more than 200m units worldwide.
The German inventor has tried to sue Sony before, but Britain's Appeals Court confirmed in 1996 an earlier ruling that the portable player was a normal further technological development and could not be patented. According to German magazine Der Spiegel, Sony now has "silently parted with a few million euro" in an out-of-court settlement with the 59-year-old inventor.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:26 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
What the hell - everyone else is talking about it . . .Psychology and statistics best determine whether two people will have a happy marriage. At least that’s the claim made by an online dating service that’s patented its matchmaking formula. EHarmony.com Inc. this month received U.S. Patent No. 6,735,568, which describes a ‘‘method and system for identifying people who are likely to have a successful relationship.’’ Not surprisingly, critics and competitors trash eHarmony’s process as overly scientific — some dismissing the so-called ‘‘love patent’’ as gimmicky.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:22 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Network Associates is granted broad antispam patent - Network Associates Inc. (NAI) has been granted a broad U.S. patent for technology covering "various computer program products, systems and methods" for filtering unwanted e-mail messages, it said Tuesday. The antivirus software company said that U.S. patent no. 6,732,157 encompasses use of multiple spam-filtering techniques such as compound filters, paragraph hashing, and Bayes rules. These techniques have been proposed and used by a number of antispam technology proponents and it was not clear from the filing how the patent would affect competitors to NAI's McAfee antispam offerings.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:19 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, May 21, 2004
The EU Software Patent Saga Continues: The European Commission (EC) has passed a controversial directive that opponents claim will bolster the lot of big companies at the expense of small ones and will stifle innovation.
The so-called Computer-Implemented Inventions directive, which would harmonize how software patents are issued throughout the European Union, created a furor when it was proposed last year. Protestors took to the streets in Brussels, Belgium, and passive Web site demonstrations were held on the Internet.
Supporters of the measure are putting a benign face on it. "There are already plenty of software patents in Europe -- more than 30,000 of them," maintained Francisco Medeiros, public affairs director for the Business Software Alliance , which represents some of the largest software makers in the world.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:49 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
NOT AGAIN: A little-known Canadian computer company has sued Intel for alleged intellectual property violation. All Computers claims the Pentium II contained circuitry for which it owns the right. Furthermore, it says, Intel does not have permission to use said circuitry.
All currently has two patents filed with the US Patent and Trademark Office, both entitled 'Apparatus and method for enhancing the performance of personal computers' and both centering on adjusting the clock speed of "an accelerator board for use in replacing the microprocessor of a slow speed system board with a microprocessor operating at a higher clock speed".
All claims that the Pentium II uses techniques outlined in the patents - 5,450,574 and 5,506,981 - to synchronise a processor's clock with the chipset's system clock.
Crucially, the technique allows CPU clocks to operate at fractional multiples of the system clock rather than whole-number multiples.
The Pentium II is of course defunct as a desktop processor, and All's patents were filed in 1993. So why the wait? We only just found out about it, the company claims. It's also evaluating the Pentium III for possible infringements.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, May 18, 2004
Apple Seeks Patent for Translucent Windows
Apple is seeking a patent on a method for rendering translucent-appearing windows, technology that appears similar to features Microsoft has been previewing for its next major Windows release.
Apple Computer Inc.'s patent application, which dates back to November 2003, was published Thursday on the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office's Web site. By law, most patent applications become public record within 18 months of being filed, a patent office spokeswoman said.
According to the filing, the patent covers a method in which "information-bearing windows whose contents remain unchanged for a predetermined period of time become translucent."
The translucency would intensify the longer a window's content remains unchanged, the patent application states.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:29 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Freeman-Walter-Abele In Europe? Ja!: National governments of the European Union are not in agreement with the European parliament over the nature of a proposed law on software patentability
Unlike copyright, patents can block independent creations. Software patents can render software copyright useless. Advances in software are advances in abstraction. While traditional patents were for concrete and physical inventions, software patents cover ideas. In most countries, software has, like mathematics and other abstract subject matter, been explicitly considered to be outside the scope of patentable inventions.
Patents, unlike copyright, can give holders rights to charge for, or restrict, technology no matter who produces it, leaving open-source developers and users open to infringement claims for inadvertently distributing patented methods.
Germany has decided to vote against all changes to current European patent laws. It does not want American procedures in Europe. It is the largest EU member and it, being against software patents with the French IT leaders backing them by lobbying their government to vote against them too, Europe might be saved from the software patents.
A lack of uniform rules in the 25-nation bloc means that US companies such as Microsoft, are leading European firms in patenting software.
The chief technology officers of 10 European companies including Siemens, Nokia and Philips in a letter say that industry ministers must act to safeguard innovation in Europe.
To become a law, the legislation must be approved by the European Parliament, which voted last September to ban patents on software and business methods.
The European Patent Office has so far granted more than 30000 patents on rules of organization and calculation claimed in terms of general-purpose computing equipment, called "programs for computers" in the law of 1973 and "computer-implemented inventions" in EPO Newspeak since 2000.
The European Commission has proposed to override the current clear and uniform European patentability rules ("mathematical methods, schemes and rules for mental activity, methods of doing business and programs for computers are not patentable inventions") and replace them by a set of nationally implementable rules which make it very difficult for national courts to reject patents on algorithms and business methods such as Amazon One Click Shopping.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:17 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
JAPANESE-KOREAN CONFLICT: Share technical knowledge at your peril.
That's the lesson Japanese electronics manufacturers are drawing now that their South Korean rivals are giving them a run for their money in key component markets.
The sparks-and patent lawsuits-are flying in the red-hot sectors of sophisticated microchips and flat-panel displays: key components of digital cameras, flat-panel TVs and other big-selling appliances.
South Korean manufacturers are spending huge sums to get ahead in these markets. In some fields, they have already nosed ahead of their Japanese competitors.
While acknowledging the South Koreans' strategies, Japanese executives blame themselves for letting technology secrets slip out of their hands.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:06 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
TIME FOR A DIVISIONAL APPLICATION? CAMBRIDGE, Mass., May 18 /PRNewswire/ -- For less than the price of a New York City taxi ride, Zipcar members may actually improve their sex lives, according a survey conducted by a new magazine, Men's Car. Get up and go just took on a whole new meaning. The survey of 2,253 motorists found that men who drive BMW's had more sex than any other car user, on the average of 2.2 times a week. Volkswagen drivers ranked third in the survey, having sex an average of 1.9 times a week. Zipcar offers BMW's and Volkswagen Beetles, Jettas and Golfs by the hour or the day in Boston, New York City and Washington, D.C. Since 1999, Zipcar (http://www.zipcar.com) has provided urban residents and commuters with self-service, on-demand access to cool cars, including BMW's and VW's. Renting a Zipcar, which is quickly changing the car rental industry in the same way email changed the U.S. Mail system, is as easy as getting cash from an ATM because of patent-pending technology that allows members automated access to cool cars 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:59 AM 1 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, May 12, 2004
Legal Fees WHAT? WHAT WAS THAT? Lawyers who persuaded Microsoft Corp. to settle their class-action lawsuit accusing the company of price-fixing are asking for $258 million in legal fees, the largest amount ever in an antitrust case.
The bill comes as attorney fees are being examined critically by the American Bar Association and lawmakers across the country. It amounts to about $3,000 per hour for one lawyer, more than $2,000 an hour each for 34 other attorneys and $1,000 an hour for administrative work.
Microsoft agreed to the settlement -allocating $1.1 billion for California consumers -after a small San Francisco law firm sued in state court alleging the company inflated prices by monopolizing the pre-installed software market from 1995 to 2001.
But Microsoft could end up spending much less. The deal enables anyone who bought a computer in California to get vouchers worth $5 to $29 per Microsoft product, but only a small fraction of the millions eligible have applied for the money.
The lead attorney in the case, Eugene Crew, planned to ask the judge Wednesday for the fees. He told the judge in legal briefs that he deserves about $3,000 for each of his 6,189.6 billable hours, "considering the enormity of this undertaking against the most powerful corporation in America."
Lawyers from 35 firms joined the suit, which was filed in 1999 under California's unfair competition law and settled four years later. The requested fees represent about 25% of the settlement.
Normally, attorneys charge clients about a third of what's recovered, but in class-actions they negotiate fees with the losing party and the judge.
Crew told San Francisco County Superior Court Judge Paul Alvarado in briefs that they deserve about five times their normal rate because of the difficulty of maneuvering through the legal system to recover money for consumers.
"Extraordinary deeds warrant appropriate recompense," Crew wrote.
The lawyers spent $11.4 million while reviewing millions of pages of legal documents and taking dozens of depositions, and devoted "marathon days, all-nighters and the entire Thanksgiving holiday weekend" to the case in 2001, he added.
Microsoft opposes the fees.
"No client would pay any lawyer or paralegal at those rates, and this court should not order Microsoft to do so," Microsoft attorney Robert Rosenfeld said.
Rosenfeld said the case was simple because of the federal antitrust case against the software maker.
"Although class counsel would have had difficulty proving that plaintiffs were overcharged, their ability to piggyback on prior proceedings significantly increased the likelihood of a settlement," Rosenfeld said.
Caps on legal fees have been considered in at least 13 states.
A proposal from Common Good, a group committed to "reforming America's lawsuit culture," and the conservative Hudson Institute would cap fees at 10% of a $100,000 settlement and 5% of anything more, said Brent Tantillo, a deputy director at the institute.
"The problem is these cases where the attorneys get a whopping fee and the consumer gets next to nothing," Tantillo said.
The American Bar Association says lawyers can ethically charge whatever is "reasonable."
"That's a big question, what is reasonable," said Steven Lesser, head of an ABA task force investigating attorneys fees.
The California Supreme Court two years ago upheld a lower court decision reducing fees from $88.5 million to $18.2 million for lawyers who won a class action accusing California of illegally charging out-of-state residents $300 extra for auto registration. The court called that request, for $8,000 an hour, "a testament to the unreal world of greed in which some attorneys practice law."
At the same time, a three-member Tobacco Fee Arbitration Panel awarded $1.25 billion in fees to 60 law firms that helped California get $25.4 billion as part of a nationwide tobacco settlement with the industry.
Panelists John Calhoun Wells and Harry Huge said the lawyers' efforts were "an important contributor to a resolution of the tobacco war" in California.
Charles Renfrew, a former federal judge whom the tobacco industry nominated as arbitrator, dissented, saying the fee "truly shocks the conscience."
One benefactor of the Microsoft settlement, Gerry Kaplan of the San Francisco suburb of Hillsborough, figures his vouchers will add up to about $100.
"The attorneys are the ones that are benefiting from this, but so am I and I didn't have to do anything," Kaplan said. "I'm getting a hundred bucks for filling out a form online and took no risk. That's a lot of money for the lawyers, but it is a lot of money for consumers too."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:53 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
HP / GATEWAY BATTLE GETTING (more) UGLY: In separate patent-related announcements, Gateway on Monday said its first-quarter loss was about $6 million wider than it had reported, and that it has filed several counterclaims against HP in a patent lawsuit between the two companies.
The two patent matters are not related, said Bob Sherbin, a Gateway spokesman. The $6 million increase in Gateway's net loss is connected with an increase in a reserve account that was prompted by developments in settlement negotiations in a patent related matter, Sherbin said.
Gateway is not providing any additional details on that pending settlement, but the matter will become clear very soon, Sherbin said.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:40 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Eolas Responds on Explorer Patent Claim
The University of California and Eolas Technologies Inc have taken the latest step in their battle with Microsoft Corp, responding to an investigation of its claimed patent.
Eolas has reportedly filed a 10-page reply to the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), after the department instituted an investigation of Eolas' browser patent - the subject of Eolas' claim against Microsoft.
USPTO inaugurated a "director-ordered" review of Eolas' patent, claiming the existence of prior art. Earlier, World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) director Tim Berners-Lee made headlines saying the patent could cause "widespread and irreparable harm" to innocent users, when a US court awarded Eolas $520.6m in damages after finding Internet Explorer infringed on Eolas' plug-in technology.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:38 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, May 11, 2004
Eeeee-Yewwwww : The EU is looking (again) at allowing software patents. Predictably, European programmers are having fits. In this "Call To Action", the following demands are made:
- We urge members of national parliaments to formulate clear national policies on the limits of patentability and to make sure that their government's representatives in the European Council are faithfully implementing these policies.
- We demand that all legislative proposals, including those from the European Parliament and the member states, be rigorously tested against a test suite of sample patent applications to see whether they would beyond any doubt lead to the desired results and would not leave room for any more misinterpretations.
LOL. "Clear" national policies? "Beyond any doubt?" Well, when they finally figure those two out, maybe they should pass that information along to the rest of the world . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:47 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Marsha, Marsha, Marsha! Tired of hearing exclusively about Microsoft and their patenting spree? Well, Apple is touting some of their recently-issued patents as well. It seems that Apple is very much into protecting the user interfaces, which sounds like they are gunning for some gateway patents . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:38 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Having an Open-Source Corporate Policy: A good article for Linux and other open source users on setting corporate policies concerning patents and IP. What is the safest advice an intellectual property attorney can give clients concerned about potential litigation? "Do absolutely nothing."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:31 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, May 10, 2004
Patent holders and Linux on collision course
Monday, May 10, 2004 Washington (featureXpress) -- Open source and patents will collide in the courts predicts a new white paper released by the Alexis de Tocqueville Institution, or AdTI, a non-partisan research foundation in Washington, D.C.
The author, Kenneth Brown, president of AdTI, comments, "the open source community wants to develop software freely, irrespective of patents and patent-holders. Consequently, this will lead to an imminent fall-out between big business, patent-holders, and the Linux community."
It is not uncommon today for patent fights to erupt even between parties that have engaged in rigorous diligence. By contrast, open source developers and distributors do not engage in patent searches, thus, there is a real possibility we will see a major patent fight involving open source, sooner than later."
Brown argues that the actions of IBM, a Linux developer, and one of the largest patent holders in the world, will also impact the relationship between open source and patents. Brown writes, "IBM's approach will be interesting for two reasons. 1. Soon, IBM will be competing with large Linux-based developers and distributors themselves. As the deployment of Linux increases, it can be expected that IBM will be going head-to-head with its partners in the Linux community for new accounts. It is unquestionable that the biggest irony of all will be when Big Blue resorts to using its war chest of patents against fellow Linux advocates. 2. The open source community is actively lobbying governments here and abroad to end software patents. These efforts are not in IBM's interest, thus, we will soon observe even more conflict between IBM and the open source community over this issue as well."
The white paper is available online at www.adti.net
For further information, contact:
Gregory Fossedal
202-437-7431
emeritus@adti.net
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:02 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
GET READY 'CAUSE HERE THEY COME: Sticky Web, Inc. (Pink Sheets: "SIKY") today announces that it has retained the Intellectual Property law firm of Niro, Scavone, Haller & Niro to represent SIKY in connection with the licensing and enforcement of patent 6,631,400.
The first patent issued in the SIKY portfolio, US Patent number 6,631,400, "Method for Managing Bulk E-Mail Distribution" (Mail Wiz(R)), was issued on October 7, 2003
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:50 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
M&G&B&D&S&M&? - Minneapolis-based Merchant & Gould, aiming to triple its size and stake a claim as a national intellectual property powerhouse, is negotiating to merge with two out-of-state law firms.
"It's very important that we have not only sufficient competency but also sufficient numbers to handle large patent litigation matters," said Randy King, CEO and managing director of Merchant & Gould (M&G), which specializes in intellectual property (IP) law and has 110 attorneys. "We want to be up in the range of 200 to 300 [attorneys] reasonably quickly. The way to do that is to find an IP firm culturally similar to our own and bring them together."
King has been negotiating since last fall to merge with Burns, Doane, Swecker & Mathis, an Alexandria, Va.-based IP firm with more than 80 attorneys. A third, undisclosed IP firm began negotiating with M&G and Burns in the past month, King said. No timetable has been set for a deal.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:45 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, May 07, 2004
USPTO = JOB BOOSTER: Alexandria officials say the city's economy appears to be riding on the coattails of the new U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, which is moving to the area from nearby Crystal City.
A quarterly report from Alexandria's Economic Development Partnership finds that office vacancies are down, the unemployment rate is the lowest in three years and that property values are soaring.
On Monday, the Alexandria City Council voted to reduce the real estate tax rate by four cents to 99.5 cents - marking the first time in 54 years that the rate has dipped under one dollar.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:38 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
JAPAN'S FEDERAL CIRCUIT? Frustrated by a court system ill-equipped to handle intellectual-property cases, businesses are eagerly awaiting the April 2005 launch of a high court specializing in such disputes.
Japanese companies, which have been looking for ways to protect and turn to account their intellectual property, expect the new court will make the filing of infringement lawsuits easier.
``(The new court) will be a major step forward for the protection of intellectual property,'' an official of Nippon Keidanren (Japan Business Federation) said. ``We'll give it a rating of 80 (out of 100).''
Companies also hail forthcoming legal revisions aimed at making court proceedings confidential.
To prevent corporate secrets from being leaked, the Patent Law revisions will allow courts to put a gag order on everyone involved in the lawsuits if confidential information is submitted as evidence.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:36 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, May 06, 2004
Microsoft and Siemens Get (A Little More) Cozy: Siemens AG and Microsoft Corporation today announced a broad cross-licensing agreement to allow expanded access to the patent portfolios that each company holds. The agreement signifies an expanded cooperation between Siemens and Microsoft, enabling each company to expand its offerings to customers and deliver even more comprehensive and compelling solutions. Terms of the agreement were not disclosed.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 11:52 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
How Nice - Microsoft gets apple patent by mistake: At the rate companies file for patents you would think that patents grow on trees. One that was mistakenly credited to Microsoft apparently does ...
On Tuesday, Microsoft received its first botanical patent for a newly discovered apple tree dubbed the "Burchinal Red Delicious," whose fruit is sold commercially as the "Adam's Apple." The patent should have been awarded to Robert Burchinal of East Wenatchee, Washington. The Burchinal Red Delicious-producing apple tree is not completely foreign to some Microsoft employees, as it is commonly found in Wenatchee, just 90 miles from Redmond, Washington.
The patent was apparently misfiled with a group of other patent applications from Microsoft. Microsoft is working to have the patent, US Plant Patent # 14,757, appropriately reassigned to Burchinal by filing a certificate of correction with the U.S. Patent Office.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 11:48 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, May 05, 2004
TAKE 10 A DAY FOR LONGHORN: Once envisioned as a minor upgrade to Windows XP, Windows "Longhorn" took on all-new importance in early 2002 when Microsoft decided to make this Windows release an all-encompassing major upgrade with a new security architecture called Palladium, a hardware 3D-enabled user interface, a brand-new, database-backed storage engine, and many more new features. However, this major release has been delayed over and over. Microsoft execs have recently admitted that Longhorn will not ship until 2006. So why the delays? Aside from the obvious, there are rumors circulating (aren't there ALWAYS rumors circulating about MSFT?) that the software giant is quietly patenting everything they can think of to make sure that Longhorn, at the very least, provides an ample stream of licensing revenue. As one MSFT dissenter remarked: "You want to know one reason why Microsoft is taking so long to come out with Longhorn? It wants to make darn sure that it's as Linux and open-source unfriendly as humanly possible . . . You see, Microsoft is busy patenting everything it can lay its hands on . . . In fact, Microsoft is now building up its patent arsenal, applying for a rather amazing 10 patents a day. The idea isn't to ensure that Microsoft makes a fair profit from its patents; it's to make sure that no one else can write fully compatible software."
Here we go again . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:15 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
SIGH: you just knew this was going to happen sooner or later, didn't you?
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:51 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
BLING BLING: The $20bn Google flotation will net law firm Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati up to $20m, and partners at the West Coast firm are hoping their initial investment could eventually realise between $50m and $100m. Wilson Sonsini took an equity investment in the world’s leading search engine when it advised Google prior to its launch in 1999. This will now net Wilson Sonsini the biggest windfall a law firm has had from such an investment, often made in lieu of fees.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:10 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, May 04, 2004
DC Merger Rumors - Washington, D.C.'s Swidler Berlin Shereff Friedman and San Francisco-based Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe are in merger talks, according to lawyers close to the discussions.
Though they have not advanced beyond the firms' leaders, the negotiations are serious, say five sources with knowledge of the talks. When a partnership vote might occur, however, is still unclear.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:24 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Et Tu, Science and Technology? In another classic case of handwringing by the NYT, the paper implies that the US is becoming a shirtless-with-a-novelty-foam-cowboy-hat-and-airhorn citizen of the global science community. This is the type of commentary I can't stand reading - where the author substitutes a proxy for his/her own opinion in a veiled effort to make a point (i.e., "analysts say . . .", "experts agree that . . .", "analysts point to . . ."). Also, after running through a litany of areas where the U.S. is allegedly "lagging" in the sciences, the author can't help but to fall back on the NYT mantra "without government funding, there can be nothing."
Unfortunately, for many people, including people on the editorial board at the NYT, they refuse to understand that it not a matter of what you conceive - it's what you are able to do with that conception once you reduce it to a commercial form. And once you start making (gasp!) profits from that product, you are certainly going to look for greener pastures when you realize that over half of your money is being siphoned for taxes and labor costs ("labour" for you people in Millwall) . . .
Some comments from the article:
**** "For instance, scientific papers by Americans peaked in 1992 and then fell roughly 10 percent, the National Science Foundation reports. Why? Many analysts point to rising foreign competition, as does the European Commission, which also monitors global science trends. In a study last year, the commission said Europe surpassed the United States in the mid-1990's as the world's largest producer of scientific literature." (just what we need - more mountains of paper)
**** "Patents are a main way that companies and inventors reap commercial rewards from their ideas and stay competitive in the marketplace while improving the lives of millions. Foreigners outside the United States are playing an increasingly important role in these expressions of industrial creativity. In a recent study, CHI Research, a consulting firm in Haddon Heights, N.J., found that researchers in Japan, Taiwan and South Korea now account for more than a quarter of all United States industrial patents awarded each year, generating revenue for their own countries and limiting it in the United States." - since when is licensing a zero-sum game? If you license something, you do so presumably because you can make MORE money from your derivative product.
**** "Moreover, their growth rates are rapid. Between 1980 and 2003, South Korea went from 0 to 2 percent of the total, Taiwan from 0 to 3 percent and Japan from 12 to 21 percent." - Welcome to the party, chum. 23 years, and you finally notice that Pacific Rim companies are filing patents?
**** "More troubling to some experts is the likelihood of an accelerating loss of quality scientists. Applications from foreign graduate students to research universities are down by a quarter, experts say, partly because of the federal government's tightening of visas after the 2001 terrorist attacks." - (cough), well, that and the fact that PhD candidates are starting out in positions that pay less than what most bartenders make . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:30 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati Establishes San Diego Office; Expands Life Sciences, Intellectual Property, Corporate, and Litigation Practices - Adds Five Partners
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:05 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
G'DAY COMMISSIONER: a group of visiting US patent experts says Australian technology innovators need to improve their intellectual property protection if they are to take their products into the US. Apparently the problem is that Austrailian patent solicitors don't have the expertise to correctly advise software developers and other technologists in proper US patent procedures.
To redress the situation, the Institute of Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys of Australia invited a team of nine US patent specialists to give lectures and workshops on US patent drafting practice and procedures.
According to an attendee, the US attorneys on the course, particularly Judge Paul Michel (the head of the US Court of Appeals), were impressed with the drafting skills of the Australian lawyers. "It also became clear that their law is very similar to and moving towards ours in a number of areas, which allows us to export our drafting skills to overseas clients, as well as provide them to Australians." Well, I'm glad they flew over all those people just to find that out . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:57 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
GREAT GOOGLEY-MOOGLEY: Google's blockbuster IPO had all the tongues wagging last week, and the company did its best to keep things as mum as possible. Well, now that some of the dust has settled, people are starting to poke around and see what's underneath that Google hood. And it seems that there are a few skeletons hanging in the patent closet:
"In the section outlining risks to its business, Google described several lawsuits it faces, including a patent infringement suit by Yahoo Inc. unit Overture Services Inc. and a series of actions stemming from ads Google sells that are tied to searches on trademarked names.
But Google's filing omitted one high-profile case involving Digital Envoy Inc., which developed a way to target ads to Web surfers based on geography. The Norcross, Ga.-based company sued Google in March for misusing its technology and asked a federal judge in Atlanta to block Google from using it. Digital Envoy is also seeking a cut of Google's profits."
Yow.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:43 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, May 03, 2004
THIS EXPLAINS A LOT:
The results from the first round of employee certification testing indicate that the USPTO needs to provide significantly greater training to enable examiners to master the testing subjects.
Of the first 112 GS-12 examiners tested, 49 percent passed and 51 percent failed. The agency offered the 17 employees who were scheduled for promotion in the bi-week following the exam the option to retake the test immediately or to wait. Seven opted to wait. Of the 10 who retook the test, two passed.
All of the test questions were lifted from the patent bar exam and excluded any questions regarding attorney-client ethics and other questions pertinent exclusively to patent attorneys or agents.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:33 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
PRIOR ART ANYONE? Dave Eastburn, and Sandy Trevor are former Compuserve exectutives that use their collection of old hardware and software to help invalidate patent claims against clients facing infringement charges. The name of the company is Nuvocom Inc., and it sounds like they have done some good work defending smaller companies from Pan IP and their early attempts to beat smaller companies into submission with their patent portfolio.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:07 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
After Carefully Reviewing Your Qualifications, We Regret to Inform You . . .
With blockbuster merger announcements and even Internet initial public offerings once again making headlines, it's only a matter of time before the legal job market soars back to its late '90s heights. Right?
Don't hold your breath. Though a robust market for litigators and intellectual property specialists continues apace, opportunities for transactional lawyers, both at firms and in-house with corporations, remain elusive.
"Nobody's leaving," notes one frustrated headhunter. "Everyone's holding onto their job because they're still scared."
The lack of attrition within corporate legal staffs has driven many legal employers to curtail new hiring and is one major reason many job-seekers in the legal profession, like their counterparts in other industries, are experiencing something of a "jobless recovery."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:50 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
