Tuesday, September 28, 2004

HOLD ON TO YOUR HATS: After a month of deliberations, a jury in Tennessee federal court has reached a verdict in a complex patent case involving Fridley-based Medtronic Inc. and the inventor of some of its spinal fusion technologies. But the decision won't be known until later this morning. Michelson, a Los Angeles-based spinal surgeon, alleged in a countersuit that Medtronic shorted him in royalty payments and failed to properly market his inventions. He is seeking $1.7 billion in compensatory damages in addition to punitive damages.

I'll keep you posted . . .

Monday, September 27, 2004

MY KIND OF THINKING: Physicists at Imperial College London are developing a new optical disk with so much storage capacity that every episode of The Simpsons made could fit on just one disk. Speaking at the Asia-Pacific Data Storage Conference 2004 in Taiwan today, Dr Peter Török, Lecturer in Photonics in the Department of Physics, will describe a new method for potentially encoding and storing up to one Terabyte (1,000 Gigabytes) of data, or 472 hours of film, on one optical disk the size of a CD or DVD. All 350 scheduled episodes of The Simpsons, totalling 8,080 minutes of film, could be easily stored on the new disk, dubbed MODS - for Multiplexed Optical Data Storage - by the Imperial College team.

Now who could argue with that kind of progress?

UK ANNOUNCES ONLINE PATENT APPLICATION SERVICES: The UK Patent Office's customers can now apply for their patents over the Internet - thanks to a new system which came into service in August 2004. The new service, known as epoline, provides a common approach to electronically filing each type of patent application which helps to keep the costs and complexity for applicants to a minimum. Developed and tested over several years, the new service was a joint collaboration between the UK Patent Office, and the European Patent Office. The application service also applies to international patent applications under the Patent Co-operation Treaty made to WIPO in Geneva.

NYT THROWS ITS HAT INTO THE "PATENT REFORM" MOVEMENT - The NYT reprinted portions of Josh Lerner and Adam B. Jaffe's pending book entitled "Innovation and Its Discontents: How Our Broken Patent System is Endangering Innovation and Progress, and What To Do About It," to be published in November by Princeton University Press. The article has some good points, but there are some generalizations made that are rather dubious. Two of these assertions are that the "breakdown" of the patent system has its roots based in the creation of the Federal Circuit (!) and the institution of fee-based funding for the USPTO:

Mr. Lerner, a professor of investment banking at the Harvard Business School, and Mr. Jaffe, a professor of economics at Brandeis University, trace this breakdown to the early 1980's, when a single federal appeals court was established to hear patent lawsuits, replacing 12 regional courts of appeal.


Then in the early 1990's, Congress changed the patent office's financing, so the agency could pay for itself with user fees.


From his home outside Boston, Mr. Lerner last week described the patent system, 20 years after the reforms, as mired in "the land of unintended consequences."


"Again and again in the patent system, we see people set out to do reforms with one thing in mind, but that have quite an unintended effect," he said. "The easier it became to get patents, the more people wanted to apply for them, and that led to a situation where examiners grappled with more patents to review, which led to them being pressed to do quicker reviews and a degradation in quality of patents
issued."


The patent agency has often struggled to keep up with the times. In recent years, the agency has confronted entirely new areas like biotechnology, software-related inventions, financial and business methods, Internet-based inventions and other information-technology innovations.


Some of the changes designed to deal with these occurred amid extensive public debate. Others got little attention because they seemed like innocuous administrative reforms - like the ones that made patents easier to get, Mr. Lerner said. But many of those patents caused a secondary reaction, he added.

"The ability to litigate and expect to get substantial award from litigation increased," Mr. Lerner said. "So as a result we've got somewhat of a vicious cycle. Once you get one firm in an industry beginning a strategy of aggressive patent enforcement, it creates an almost inevitable response - an almost arms-race dynamic - where everyone else in the industry says, 'We better be doing the same thing.' "

He suggested that these changes for the worse occurred because "there's a relatively small group of people in the D.C. patent bar, and they have a very powerful influence on how patent policy gets decided. There is a powerful incentive for them to keep a patent system that is complicated, and one that involves protracted, costly litigation."


Also, Mr. Lerner said, businesses often fail to understand the importance of subtle changes in patent law. "It is perhaps because of the complexity of patent issues, and because there is no long tradition of work by economists in this area, because a lot of corporations see it as second order relative to tax policy changes, for example, which directly affect their bottom line," he explained. "Patent policy has an indirect affect."


So patent practitioners are colluding to keep patent laws "complicated"? If anything, most of the changes enacted over the last few years were made to simplify the patenting process, and I think that there has been some measure of success in that regard. But these comments don't make sense on their face - you can't argue on one hand that patent practice is needlessly complicated, and then complain on the other hand that getting patents has become too easy.

Friday, September 24, 2004

Great site for Strange Judicial Opinions

DESPITE BEING NICKED, EBAY DECIDES TO KEEP HALF.COM: EBay Inc. announced Thursday that it will keep its Half.com subsidiary open indefinitely, scrapping previous plans to shutter the e-commerce site in mid-October.

EBay spokesman Hani Durzy said executives decided to keep Half.com open because it still generates revenue and brings customers to eBay. EBay does not break out traffic or revenue data specific to Half.com, but Durzy said that nearly half of all eBay listings for books, music, video and games come from Half.com sellers.

Half.com is also the subject of a festering lawsuit.

Earlier this year, jurors ruled that the eBay division violated patents filed by Thomas G. Woolston, an entrepreneur who founded an e-commerce company called MercExchange in Great Falls, Va. In May, a federal jury awarded Woolston $35 million, and patent experts said the ruling could force eBay to close Half.com. EBay appealed, and the case is still in the courts.

-- An interesting note here - while the Washington Post describes Mr. Woolston as an "entrepreneur", he also happens to be a registered patent attorney as well. MercExchange has been pretty active in obtaining licenses from many of the players in online auctions. Let's see what the Federal Circuit has to say when the EBay case goes on appeal . . .

Thursday, September 23, 2004

PriceWaterhouseCoopers tells the EU that software patents are a "threat" to ICT efforts - the EU is currently trying to establish a set of rules and protocols to facilitate the transition towards e-business in the EU and to enhance the competitiveness of the ICT and publishing sectors in particular. The ICT group engages particularly in economic analysis, policy co-ordination with EU Member States, public-private partnerships with non-profit organizations and co-operation with European Standardization Organizations.

Anyways, PriceWaterhouseCoopers issued a report to the ICT group, and in that report, they bad-mouthed the practice of patenting software. More specifically, they said that

there are particular threats to the European ICT industry such as the current discussion on the patent on software. The mild regime of IP protection in the past has led to a very innovative and competitive software industry with low entry barriers. A software patent, which serves to protect inventions of a non-technical nature, could kill the high innovation rate.
The full report may be viewed here. I think they are wrong in principle, but there will likely be "growing pains" if the EU adopts algorithmic patenting (prior art databases and all that). But I find it hard to believe that the EU can resist patenting software indefinitely, especially since the US has become such a haven for software entrepreneurs and business . . .

More Universities See the Light: Wake Forest University reported a 77 percent increase in its licensing revenue for its 2004 fiscal year, largely because of interest in a medical device that can heal wounds faster than traditional methods, Michael Batalia, the acting director for the Office of Technology Asset Management, said yesterday.

Wake Forest reported about $34.3 million in licensing revenue for its fiscal year ending June 30, nearly double the $19 million it reported during its 2003 fiscal year.

Most of the revenue was generated by patents from Wake Forest University Health Sciences, particularly the university's Vacuum Assisted Closure wound-therapy device.

Hilarious: (AP - Pittsburgh) The state Supreme Court ruled that Pennsylvania's drunken driving law can't be enforced against people on horseback, a decision that inspired the dissenting justice to wax poetic.

The court ruled Wednesday in a case against two men in Mercer County in 2002. Riders Keith Travis, 41, and Richard Noel, 49, were charged with drunken driving along with a man driving a pickup who allegedly rear-ended the horse Travis was riding away from a bar on a dark country road.

All three men failed field sobriety tests, police said, but a judge threw out the charges against Noel and Travis after they argued that the word "vehicles" in the state's drunken-driving law doesn't apply to horses.

Prosecutors said the code specifically includes people riding animals. But the majority justices cited a similar case in Utah, where judges said such a statute is confusing and too vague about which regulations would apply to animals as well as vehicles.

Justice Michael Eakin, who is fond of writing rhyming opinions, summed up the lone dissent with two stanzas mimicking the theme song of "Mister Ed" — a 1960s TV sitcom about a talking horse:

"A horse is a horse, of course, of course,

but the Vehicle Code does not divorce

its application from, perforce,

a steed as my colleagues said.

"'It's not vague,' I'll say until I'm hoarse,

and whether a car, a truck or horse

this law applies with equal force,

and I'd reverse instead."

Wednesday, September 22, 2004

Munich Ho! A very interesting article from IP Law & Business on Jones Day and the firm's decision to run its' own EU patent practice out of Munich (home to the German and European patent offices), in lieu of hiring local counsel. One of the criticisms of German practitioners was that they weren't "American" (read: aggressive) enough:


Kahrl, who works in the firm's Cleveland office, says that clients pushed Jones Day into Munich. They were disappointed with the German firms that represented them in patent-related matters. "The kind of hard-driven advocacy we're so accustomed to in the U.S.--and in Britain--is not present in Germany, where appearances before a judge tend to be more of an academic discussion as opposed to a presentation of the client's interests."


Clients found EPO opposition proceedings particularly nettlesome, Kahrl says. In an opposition, one party tries to block another's patent from issuing, or to cancel a patent after it's issued. In a number of EPO opposition proceedings, Kahrl says, German lawyers didn't press their case with a detailed presentation the way American lawyers would before the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. This is critical because patent disputes in Europe are generally resolved in opposition hearings, says Paul Kimball, a patent partner in the Washington, D.C., office of Womble Carlyle
Sandridge & Rice. In the United States, patent disputes typically are resolved with litigation.

Others are saying it's a bad idea, because such moves risk alienating foreign counsel that often send work to U.S. firms. However you view it, it's an interesting strategy for Jones Day, and time will tell how this all plays out.


HELP WANTED:

Job Description:

The Chief Information Officer (CIO) for the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) serves as the principal information technology advisor to the Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office. The CIO helps lead the USPTO as a performance based, e government agency. The CIO oversees the evaluation of information technology, the architectural design of automation initiatives, and the development of strategic information technology plans, including the development and implementation of automated systems for the USPTO using a matrix management structure.

Requirements:

Demonstrated experience in exercising an extremely high degree of leadership, project management skill, initiative, judgment, and ability in managing a major IT program. Must have managed a minimum of 75 staff. Breadth of IT experience, to include knowledge of logical and physical data architectures, network communications, data base/application/web servers, middleware, and telecommunications. • Knowledge of IT security design, operations, encryption, information access, and authentication processes. • Ability to develop performance measures and enterprise wide performance management practices such as service level agreements, customer surveys, internal assessments, and other appropriate performance evaluation techniques. • B.A./B.S. degree highly preferred, plus 12 20 years experience.

Benefits/Salary:

Compensation $104,927 $145,600 (SES)

Any takers?

(ouch) - Immersion Corporation, a developer and licensor of touch feedback technology, today announced that a jury returned a verdict favorable to Immersion in its patent infringement suit against Sony Computer Entertainment, Inc. and Sony Computer Entertainment of America, Inc. (Sony). The jury found that Sony infringed all the asserted claims of U.S. Patent Nos. 6,275,213 and 6,424,333 and that those claims were valid. The verdict also awarded Immersion damages in the amount of $82.0 million. A judgment has not yet been entered, and Immersion expects that post-trial motions and other actions by Sony will be filed with the Court with respect to the jury's decision and other matters. Immersion intends to ask the court to issue a permanent injunction to enjoin Sony's continued infringement.

Patent attorneys, voting machines, and profit-making - what better combination could there be for a feature article? Since this is in my home town, I couldn't help but notice this article in Crain's Business about two patent attorneys that developed a new voting machine and are looking to roll it out for the next election. Naturally, they are predicting pennies from heaven from the venture . . . best of luck.

A two-part article describing the new public electronic access to the details of the negotiations that lead to issuing or denying a patent. The first part of the article explains why the PTO recently celebrated milestones for implementing programs called IFW and Public PAIR. The second part (to be published tomorrtow) describes why people outside the PTO have reason to celebrate these milestones.

A Dark Side To Public PAIR? Recently, the USPTO has been touting the public PAIR system as a way for applicants (or other interested parties) to access the file wrappers of issued patents and public applications. Many people weren't aware however, that under 37 C.F.R. 1.14, once an application is published, ALL of the file wrapper becomes publicly available. That means any 37 C.F.R. 1.131 declarations ("swear-behinds") or 1.132 statements (oaths or declarations traversing rejections) will become public knowledge once your application publishes.

An interesting note here is that statements under 37 C.F.R. 1.627 (preliminary statements made pursuant to an interference), which are supposed to be under "seal" are now trumped by 1.14 - so everything now becomes available.

EU Patent Litigation De-Harmonization - The European Union's highest court may rule that member states can't impose orders blocking the use of a patent across the EU, a decision that would force companies to fight intellectual property suits separately in each country.

Europe-wide patent injunctions may be illegal under EU law, Leendert Geelhoed, an advocate general at the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg, wrote last week on a case involving two German makers of car parts. Such opinions are adopted by the court in about 85 percent of rulings.

The case highlights Europe's fragmented patent enforcement system. Without an EU-wide tribunal, companies such as Boston Scientific Corp. and Baxter International Inc. have used courts in the Netherlands or Belgium to block alleged infringers from marketing their products anywhere in the 25-nation bloc. A ruling in this dispute, expected next year, may put an end to that ad- hoc system and raise costs, lawyers said.

Monday, September 20, 2004

FOR SHAME: Senate agrees to hike USPTO fees and decides to continue fee diversion within the USPTO. The AIPLA reports it this way:


A Periodic Notification of AIPLA Activities and Current Developments
in Intellectual Property Law

September 16, 2004

Senate Bill Would Fund PTO for One Year Without Stopping Fee Diversion

The Senate Appropriations Committee on September 15, 2004, approved the fiscal year 2005 Commerce, Justice, State, the Judiciary, and Related Agencies Appropriations bill (S. 2809). The Senate bill includes a version of the PTO fee increase legislation that passed the House, amended to apply for only one year and to drop the anti-diversion compromise that was struck in the House.

Last March, the House passed fee legislation (H.R. 1561) with fee increases to provide the PTO with the revenues needed for its 21st Century Strategic Plan. The fee increases were tied to the processing complexity of the application filed. Although the bill was reported by the House Judiciary Committee with a provision to take the PTO "off budget," it was passed with a compromise provision to end diversion by establishing a system for rebating user fees when PTO fee revenues exceed appropriations for a given year. Last April, the Senate Judiciary Committee approved H.R. 1561 exactly as it was passed by the House.

The Senate appropriators did not buy into the House compromise. The fee provisions incorporated into S. 2809 call for most of the fee increases in H.R. 1561 (although each relevant provision includes language to limit the increases to FY 2005). However, the Senate bill drops the rebate system that would have deposited fee revenues in excess of the appropriation into a trust fund from which the PTO would rebate fees at the end of the fiscal year.

Besides the elimination of the fee rebate system, other differences between the Senate and House fee provisions include the following:

  • The Senate bill drops a House provision to permit the Director to refund part of the application fee if a declaration of express abandonment was filed before examination.
  • Both bills designate separate filing, search and examination fees that are payable upon filing, and both would permit outsourcing of searches by "a qualified search authority". However, the Senate bill drops the House provisions requiring the PTO to conduct a pilot project on the reliability of outsourced searches.
  • The Senate bill drops the requirement that the PTO and the Small Business Administration study and report on the effect of patent fees on the ability of small entity inventors to file patent applications.

As for the appropriation provisions themselves, the differences are as
follows:
S. 2809 H.R. 4754
Appropriates $1,336,000,000 $1,314,000,000
Fee incr. rev. 208,754,000 218,754,000
Total $1,564,754,000 $1,533,407,000


In addition, the Senate bill places great emphasis on the protection of U.S. intellectual property overseas. S. 2809 earmarks $20,000,000 of the total PTO appropriation for "initiatives" to protect U.S. intellectual property overseas, presumably in support of the PTO Office of External
Affairs. The report on the legislation includes language no doubt endorsed by Senator Judd Gregg (R-N.H.): "Within the amount made available for the USPTO, $990,000 is for a grant to the Whittemore School of Business [of the University of New Hampshire] for an intellectual property rights pilot project."

The legislation also provides for the first time an appropriation ($20,000,000) for the National Intellectual Property Law Enforcement Coordination Council (NIPLECC), an interagency body created in 1999 to coordinate domestic and international intellectual property law enforcement. To head up NIPLECC, it creates a new Coordinator for International Intellectual Property Enforcement, a presidential appointee to whom the co-chairs of would NIPLECC report. Of the funds appropriated to NIPLECC, $5,000,000 must be transferred to the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative to establish a position of Chief Negotiator of Intellectual Property Enforcement, and $1,000,000 must be transferred to the State Department to support a new Office of International Intellectual Property Protection and Enforcement.


The House appropriations bill includes no direct references to overseas IP enforcement, but includes several explicit provisions on PTO manpower, setting floor levels for hiring patent and trademark examiners and ceiling levels for staffing the Office of General Counsel. Also included in the House bill and missing from the Senate bill are prohibitions against: (1) PTO employees accepting payment or reimbursement for attending conferences or meetings from an entity representing persons subject to regulation by the PTO unless the entity; and (2) the use of funds "to issue patents on claims directed to or encompassing a human organism."


AIPLA and the Intellectual Property Owners Assoc. addressed a letter to the Senate appropriators about S. 2809 prior to the markup of the bill: "Let us be very clear: we absolutely oppose any fee increase without legislation to ensure that all user fees will either be available to the U.S. Patent and Trademark office (PTO) or returned to PTO users." The ABA Governmental Affairs Office has written to Senators Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) and Patrick Leahy (D-Vt) urging their opposition to the fee provisions of S. 2809.


Senator Hatch and Senator Arlen Specter (R-Pa.) addressed a September 10, 2004, letter to the appropriators, seeking "language that achieves our goal of ending fee diversion but also preserves the jurisdiction and prerogatives of the Appropriation Committee and budget process to determine the PTO's annual appropriation."

-- This is, plainly put, garbage.

USPTO Funding Update: Senate appropriators have expressed skepticism over requests from the Patent and Trademark Office for more money to overhaul itself. Key senators in the debate, meanwhile, continue to urge members of the Appropriations Committee to craft language that would end the diversion of fees generated by PTO services.

In a committee report on the annual spending measure that funds PTO and other entities, Senate appropriators said the agency needs more funding to execute its five-year overhaul plan.
But the committee added that it still questions whether PTO's "past failure to attain these objectives was the result of inadequate funding" and whether the agency needs to hire "hundreds, if not thousands, of additional personnel" to achieve its objectives.

Turning a Corner in China? Swiss agrochemicals firm Syngenta has won a lawsuit against two Chinese companies that infringed patent laws by selling one of its insecticides without permission.

The ruling is seen in some circles as a sign that the Chinese authorities are making more efforts to protect intellectual property rights.

Syngenta is one of a number of foreign investors in China taking more aggressive legal steps to crack down on what they see as blatant copyright and patent infringements.

Well, it was worth a shot . . . : We know it’s hard to believe, but nobody was willing to pony up $850,000 in an eBay auction earlier this month for the U.S. provisional patent to build dual display laptops (apparently a crudely photoshopped mockup wasn’t enough to convince anyone to drop the cash on it). Set aside the reality that few PC makers are trolling eBay looking for patents, the thing is, despite the seller’s claims, you wouldn’t have first crack at a build a laptop with two screens anyway, even if you don’t count the 2-VU, the Xentex Flip-Pad Voyager has been out for awhile now.

(courtesy of engadget.com)

Friday, September 17, 2004

Yes, I know it's a Sham, But Just Think of the Potential Licensing Fees! Local researchers are claiming they may have found the cure for the common cold. The wonder drug is called Echinilin, and instead of masking cold symptoms like other over-the-counter products, it stimulates the immune system and attacks the invading virus, say officials with Factors R & D Technologies.

"The end result was an immediate and marked reduction in both severity of symptoms and duration of the infection," said Dr. Richard Barton, co-director of human clinical studies for the $5-million project. Developed and tested over the past eight years, the drug relies on Echinacea extract to kill the common cold. Researchers say it can also be taken for immune-system maintenance and provides immune-system support.

Press Picks Up on Fish-Ropes Merger Talks: Boston's Ropes & Gray has courted IP boutique Fish & Neave for years. And in mid-September, Fish & Neave spokesperson James Haggerty confirmed the two were again in "extremely preliminary merger talks." But this time, Ropes might land the catch.

Since 2003, 12 partners have left the 160-lawyer Fish & Neave to join expanding IP practices at Latham & Watkins, Kirkland & Ellis, Quinn Emanuel Urquhart Oliver & Hedges, King & Spalding, and Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati. At least 20 associates have left, too.

Several IP boutiques have closed in recent years, including New York's Pennie & Edmonds, Los Angeles's Lyon & Lyon, and San Jose's Skjerven Morrill. During the past year, a host of Fish lawyers have looked around, says Anna Tsirulik, managing director of Major, Hagen & Africa's New York office.

Is the 126-year-old firm (which counseled Thomas Edison) going the way of the phonograph? Reached before the merger talks became public, managing partner Jesse Jenner said no. "We are recognized in most quarters as being the leading IP firm, if not on everybody's list of the top three or five," he said. Jenner couldn't be reached for comment on the Ropes & Gray talks, but in earlier interviews he conceded the firm would consider a merger. "We would be crazy not to consider anything that would enhance our practice," he said.

A short and timely article on attorney-client privilege, in light of Knorr-Bremse . . .

West Releases Andrews' Patent Litigation Reporter: West and Andrews Publications recently announced the release of Andrews’ Patent Litigation Reporter, providing legal professionals with coverage of federal court rulings in patent cases.

Andrews’ Patent Litigation Reporter covers a wide range of topics, from filing patent requests to challenging the validity of a patent that has already been issued, as well as how to file patent infringement claims. Andrews’ Patent Litigation Reporter is published monthly and ensures that subscribers are aware of the latest developments and legal theories in this rapidly changing field.
Topics covered by the Patent Litigation Reporter include

Applications

Validity of patent

Patent infringement

Jury verdicts

Settlements

The print version of the Patent Litigation Reporter is now available at 12 issues for $525 a year. For more information or to subscribe, call (800) 344-5008 or visit west.thomson.com.

Knorr-Bremse Post Mortem - (courtesy of the Internet Patent News Service): Greg Aharonian provides his opinion on the Knorr-Bremse decision and brings up an interesting point: since claim construction is a matter of law, how can one ever claim to know the true meaning and scope of a claim? Here are some of Greg's comments:

Willful infringement of a patent requires that the infringer understand the exact scope of the patent claims, i.e., the infringer saw the boundary and crossed it. But unmentioned in its Knorr decision, is another CAFC decision, Markman, which says that only judges can draw the lines of the boundary. Until the Markman hearing, and especially without Jepson claims, there are no boundaries to be crossed, making willfulness impossible.

The CAFC can't have it both ways. It can't say the public can't scope claims if they are on a jury, but then say they can scope claims to willfully infringe. (I am ignoring the issue of exact copying, which for technologies like software where many opinions are sought, is rarely the case).

Since patent lawyers are not judges, Markman implies that their opinions are almost as useless as the analysis of the infringer. And given the rate of cases being overturned, Markman implies that the decisions/opinions of district court judges are as useless. So it doesn't matter if an infringer asks a lawyer for an opinion or not, and it doesn't matter if the infringement opinion says there is infringement or not, none of this matters in light of Markman. I mean, companies now have to deal with the problem of worrying if the district court judge is not as smart as their lawyers (imagine your lawyer, with an excellent argument, saying you don't infringe, only to later to have deal with the judge construing the claims another way).

Yet the CAFC in Knorr doesn't mention Markman. That defies logic. The implications of Markman are still a big legal mess, and at least one CAFC judge knows how very deep this legal mess is to be a lie.

Greg Aharonian


Thursday, September 16, 2004

Rumor Mill Alert: It has been reported by unsubstantiated sources that the NYC IP boutique Fish & Neave will be merging with Boston GP firm Ropes & Gray. If true, it is big news and another blow to the IP boutique community. Details will follow . . .

D'oh! Details of the momentous Sun-Microsoft deal signed in April have started to raise eyebrows in the open source world.

As part of its SEC filings, Sun revealed this week that under the deal, users of its Open Office software would be exempt from legal action from Microsoft. But from 1 April 2004, all non-Sun users of the open-source software suite will not be.

What this says about Sun's approach toward the open-source movement is already being hotly debated. It has however also demonstrated Microsoft's controversial approach to business.

Having reached agreement to leave the way open to sue users of Open Office, this week it was telling the Open Office community it wanted to work with it, prior to its exhibit at an Open Office conference.

The Sun-MIcrosoft agreement says Microsoft can seek damages from Open Office users or distributors for any copy of Open Office installed after 1 April 2004. However, users of Sun's commercial distribution of Open Office, called StarOffice are protected from legal liabilities.

Be Careful - Or Else: This article from ADTmag paints a rather bleak picture for the software patent community. It has the standard "sky-may-be-falling" lines, like:

Imagine a post-patent-apocalypse world where no new software can be written because even the most basic software patterns cannot be used without paying a massive fee. And even if you wanted to pay $1 million to incorporate a "For ... Next" loop in your program, you can't transfer the money -- the banks are closed because the software and business processes they rely on belong to someone else.
I think this is pretty over-the-top, and ignores many of the tenets of patent law. For example, I can build an engine comprising many patented sub-parts (spark-plugs, fuel-injections, etc.). However, unless I plan on manufacturing each of these parts myself, I simply approach the manufacturer of each part and purchase it. The patent rights are inherently bundled in my purchase (the "first-sale doctrine" allows a party to collect a royalty on the sale of a product only once), and once I legally possess the patented part, I can use it pretty much any way I want.

I recognize that software has some peculiarities that make it different from traditionally manufactured product, but these differences are not great enough to warrant such doomsday pronouncements.

Judicial Plagiarism? The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that federal judges must write their own opinions and cannot simply sign an opinion that was "ghostwritten" by lawyers.

In Bright v. Westmoreland County, a unanimous three-judge panel issued a stiff rebuke to U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Schwab of the Western District of Pennsylvania after concluding that defense lawyers had submitted a "proposed opinion" and that Schwab adopted it "nearly verbatim" as his own. "When a court adopts a party's proposed opinion as its own, the court vitiates the vital purposes served by judicial opinions. We, therefore, cannot condone the practice used by the district court in this case," U.S. Circuit Judge Richard L. Nygaard wrote in an opinion joined by 3rd Circuit Judges Theodore A. McKee and Michael Chertoff.

Nygaard found there was "no record evidence which would allow us to conclude that the district court conducted its own independent review, or that the opinion is the product of its own judgment. In fact, the procedure used by the district court casts doubt on the possibility of such a conclusion." As a result, Nygaard concluded that the 3rd Circuit was forced to remand the case to Schwab with an order requiring that he "engage in an independent judicial review."

Wednesday, September 15, 2004

Report Search: PricewaterhouseCoopers has highlighted software patenting as a threat to the growth of the Information Communications Technology (ICT) sector in Europe. According to the report, very few European companies have made any preparations for the introduction of a software patent regime.

- If anyone knows where this report can be found, please e-mail me

Tuesday, September 14, 2004

FEDERAL CIRCUIT EN BANC DECISION: In Knorr-Bremse v. Dana, the federal circuit ruled that no adverse inference that an opinion of counsel was or would have been unfavorable flows from an alleged infringer's failure to obtain or produce an exculpatory opinion of counsel. Precedent to the contrary is overruled.

Instead, the court determined that willful infringement should be examined under the totality of circumstances where numerous factors, such as evidence of direct copying, are brought into play. The three questions answered in the en banc decision are as follows:

(1) When the attorney-client privilege and/or work-product privilege is invoked by a defendant in an infringement suit, is it appropriate for the trier of fact to draw an adverse inference with respect to willful infringement?
  • The answer is "no." Although the duty to respect the law is undiminished, no adverse inference shall arise from invocation of the attorney-client and/or work product privilege.

(2) When the defendant had not obtained legal advice, is it appropriate to draw an adverse inference with respect to willful infringement?

  • The answer, again, is "no." The issue here is not of privilege, but whether there is a legal duty upon a potential infringer to consult with counsel, such that failure to do so will provide an inference or evidentiary presumption that such opinion would have been negative

(3) If the court concludes that the law should be changed, and the adverse inference withdrawn as applied to this case, what are the consequences for this case?

  • The district court based its willfulness determination on several factors in addition to the adverse inference arising from the assertion of attorney-client privilege by Haldex and the failure of Dana to obtain legal advice. This court has explained that "there are no hard and fast per se rules" with respect to willfulness of infringement. Precedent illustrates various factors, some weighing on the side of culpability and some that are mitigating or ameliorating. Because elimination of the adverse inference as drawn by the district court is a material change in the totality of the circumstances, a fresh weighing of the evidence is required to determine whether the defendants committed willful infringement.

(4) Should the existence of a substantial defense to infringement be sufficient to defeat liability for willful infringement even if no legal advice has been secured?

  • The answer is "no." Precedent includes this factor with others to be considered among the totality of circumstances, stressing the "theme of whether a prudent person would have sound reason to believe that the patent was not infringed or was invalid or unenforceable, and would be so held if litigated." However, precedent also authorizes the trier of fact to accord each factor the weight warranted by its strength in the particular case. We deem this approach preferable to abstracting any factor for per se treatment, for this greater flexibility enables the trier of fact to fit the decision to all of the circumstances. We thus decline to adopt a per se rule

Monday, September 13, 2004

Microsoft Patent Update: Microsoft has been granted a patent from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office on a process known as tabbing through a Web page in order to find links. The patent (number 6,785,865) is officially titled "Discoverability and navigation of hyperlinks via tabs."

Microsoft filed for the patent in March of 1997. It covers the process of shifting between links on a Web page using the computer's tab button. The patent specifies that a "user may discover and navigate among hyperlinks through the use of a keyboard. For example, a user may press a tab key to discover and navigate to a first hyperlink that is part of a hypertext document." The abstract also said a user may also tab to a link that is actually a placeholder for an image "in order to make a decision whether the image should be downloaded or not."

Not surprisingly, the open source community is not happy - but I am surprised that articles on software patents are including comments from people like the EFF and the Public Patent Foundation

Best Served Cold: The litigation-prone RIAA, a trade group that claims to represent the US recording industry, has itself been accused of patent infringement by Altnet Inc, a Californian P2P firm. Also in the firing line are several RIAA partners that make anti-piracy software products - Overpeer Inc., Loudeye Corp. and Media Sentry Inc.

Loudeye acquired Overpeer in March this year. Altnet filed the lawsuit in a Los Angeles district court last week. It alleges that RIAA and its partners infringed on Altnet's patented file-matching technology that identifies file requests sent over a P2P network. The suit claims that RIAA encouraged Loudeye and others to propagate popular P2P sites like Kazaa with bogus or damaged files that were disguised as user file requests. It also claims the methods used to match their files with users infringe its patented technology.

Altnet is a close partner of Sharman Networks Ltd., the company behind Kazaa. Woodland Hills-based Altnet is seeking an injunction to stop RIAA and its partners from further use of its patented technology. It is also seeking monetary damages, but did not specify a dollar amount at this stage of proceedings. In many ways the lawsuit is part of a concerted campaign waged by Altnet against a number of firms, including those in the current lawsuit, since last November when it issued a series of warning letters.

Wednesday, September 08, 2004

Historical predictions offered up in a new book, "In Praise of Slowness" by Carl Honore (courtesy of Worthwhilemag.com):

  • Benjamin Franklin predicted that the technological advances of the late 1700s would lead to four-hour work weeks.
  • In the late 1800s, George Bernard Shaw predicted that we would work two hours a day by the year 2000.
  • In 1956, Richard Nixon foresaw a four-day work week in the "not too distant future."
  • In the mid-1960s, a U.S. Senate subcommittee heard a prediction that by 2000, Americans would be working about 14 hours a week.

And you'd think people would stop listening to such hype after all these years. "Two hour workdays"? Please . . .

Forgent creates website to manage patent litigation: Forgent Networks announced today it has added an enhanced intellectual property area to the corporate web site. The site provides information on Forgent’s intellectual property program and the litigation recently initiated against 40 technology companies for infringement of United States Patent No. 4,698,672 (the '672 Patent) in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division as well as the complaints filed in the United States District Court for the District of Delaware.

According to Forget, the site was developed to enhance communication and improve the information flow with shareholders and interested parties about the complicated litigation process. Web site visitors can view selected court filings in a simple time line format according to the particular case. Over the last two years the intellectual property business has generated approximately $90 million from licensing the ‘672 Patent to over 30 different companies in Asia, Europe and the United States.

The company claims that the ‘672 Patent - which relates to digital image compression, and fields of use include digital still image device used to compress, store, manipulate, print or transmit digital still images such as digital cameras - extends beyond digital cameras and includes many digital still image devices such as personal digital assistants, cellular telephones, printers, scanners, and other devices used to compress, store, manipulate, print or transmit digital still images. Forgent claims the exclusive right to license and enforce all the claims under the ‘672 Patent in all fields of use involving digital still image compression.

Patent Battle Royale: Akamai v. Speedera: Speedera Networks spends almost as much money on lawyers as it does on payroll for its roughly 100 employees.

Most of those legal bills are from the Santa Clara start-up's bitter cross-country fight with its much larger rival, Akamai Technologies of Massachusetts. The two companies offer competing services for helping Web sites with heavy traffic speed content along the Internet.

Speedera's existence in recent years has been as much about litigation as innovation.

The conflict with Akamai has been festering ever since it erupted two years ago. It started when Akamai sued Speedera, resulting in a series of lawsuits and countersuits over patent disputes.

The FBI at one point even searched Speedera's offices after Akamai claimed that a Speedera executive had stolen trade secrets.

The spat is likely to heat up again next year, when the first of the four cases involved in the battle goes to trial in February.

Tuesday, September 07, 2004

Micron's Mounting Legal Bills: Micron Technology has seen a surge in legal actions in recent years — ones which also have become more complex and potentially serious.

Losing just one current lawsuit — a claim that the company is improperly using someone else's technology — could cost it hundreds of millions of dollars. The world's third-largest maker of electronic memory — and the Treasure Valley's largest employer — faces more than 25 class-action lawsuits, claims of fraud and a U.S. Department of Justice investigation.

And that's just for starters.

Micron's legal costs are escalating as it faces a tangle of lawsuits that have erupted in the past two years. The Justice Department in June 2002 began a continuing investigation on price-fixing, prompting two dozen civil lawsuits around the country that have been consolidated into one case in California.

-- There is a strange comment made by a corporate counsel in the above article: the counsel worries that patent infringement cases could drive American businesses offshore. "There are some real concerns because there's an ever-increasing number of (patent) cases and there's a trend toward going after major manufacturers, particularly in the U.S. It makes it difficult to be a manufacturer here. We could be an IP (intellectual property) company and have someone in China manufacture for us. These trends ultimately are making it more difficult for U.S. manufacturing companies."

My question is how legal ramifications are avoided by moving offshore? If you make, use, sell or import infringing technologies, you are liable just the same as everyone else. Granted, there are some tricks to skirt around certain damages by locating offshore, the economic impact can still be just as devastating . . .


Acacia Update: In an attempt to get more colleges and universities to pay royalties on revenue-generating distance-education programs that include the use of streaming video, Acacia Research Corp.--the company that claims to own the patent on streaming video technology--will issue a revised licensing proposal to schools. The letter, which schools should begin receiving this week, marks the latest salvo by Acacia in the fight for streaming video and audio technology ownership on the Internet.

The letter comes because schools have been slow to respond to Acacia's initial requests for royalty payments. Though a few academic institutions reportedly have acquiesced and entered into agreements with the company, the majority of schools thus far have resisted. Paying up to a 2-percent royalty for every audio and video clip streamed by students and professors is ridiculous, they assert, and threatens the very existence of distance-education programs in America's schools.

Amid the schools' concerns, Rob Berman, Acacia's general counsel, said the company reworked its original proposal, issued in July, to provide a more school-friendly licensing structure.

Under the original agreement, Acacia had demanded a minimum payment of $5,000 from any school that uses streaming video or audio for "educational purposes," including online and traditional courses, virtual campus tours, sporting events, and promotional spots for prospective students.

Wednesday, September 01, 2004

Guidant v. St. Jude Medical Inc. Gets a New Trial: Guidant Corp. won a new trial in its bid for as much as $140 million in damages from St. Jude Medical Inc. over implantable defibrillators.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit said two Guidant patents are valid, and a judge was incorrect to overturn a jury's finding of validity. The appeals court sent the case back for a new trial on whether Canada-based St. Jude infringes one of the Guidant's patents.

The Federal Circuit denied a Guidant request to simply reinstate the $140 million jury verdict that had been thrown out by the trial judge in Indianapolis.

The Washington-based appeals court said U.S. District Judge David Hamilton erred when he said the Guidant patents were obvious variations of earlier innovations. Guidant's inventions relate to defibrillators that are permanently installed under the skin and send electric shocks to the heart muscle when they sense abnormal activity.

"Recognition of the problem of treating complex heart arrhythmias does not render obvious the eventual solution," Circuit Judge Pauline Newman wrote for the three-judge panel.

Judge Hamilton ruled in February 2002 that the $140 million in damages was "grossly excessive," since it equaled more than 80 percent of St. Jude's 2001 net income. He also ruled that the jury verdict on damages was tainted by Guidant's chief expert witness, who, the judge said "deceived the jury, deceived the court and deceived St. Jude."

Guidant was ordered to pay some of St. Jude's legal fees as a sanction. Hamilton said if the appeals court reinstated the case, Guidant should accept $28 million in damages.

The Future of RFID Technology: A revolution is being predicted in so-called RFID "smart tags". RFID spending is set to explode in the next few years, growing from $1 billion this year to $4.6 billion in 2007, estimates Wall Street research firm Robert W. Baird & Co. Almost all of this will be in backroom warehouses and distribution centers -- not on grocery shelves or mall store racks. Consultants and analysts have been spinning tales about the virtues of RFID, such as digitally encoding receipts for paperless returns and warranty claims. But most of these sophisticated uses require tagging on the item level. That's happening in a few pilot tests of high-price or high-margin goods. But among North American manufacturers that expect to start using RFID in 2005, only 3% will do so at this level, according to Accenture (ACN).

A Good Idea From the UK Patent Office: New and small businesses in West Yorkshire will get advice on how to maximise profits from their new ideas at the Business Advice Open Day taking place at the Hanover International Hotel, Bradford, on Thursday, 30 September 2004.

Patent Office experts will be explaining how managing intellectual property can be key to business success. The team will be covering all aspects of patents, copyright, trade marks and designs.

SMEs will have the opportunity to sign up to the Patent Office’s ‘What is the key?’ campaign to receive a free information pack on how to benefit from their IP and the chance to win a free consultation with a legal expert. The campaign reinforces the increasing worth of intellectual assets in the knowledge economy as highlighted in Department of Trade & Industry Innovation Report.

The Patent Office is also inviting visitors to attend a free seminar, entitled ‘Intellectual Property – what’s that got to do with my business?’ where guests can gain an insight into the very real intellectual property issues that impact on the success of their business.

The event is part of a series of HM Customs & Excise Open Days programmed for 2004 where experts from over 30 organisations will offer free help and advice on practical issues and regulations affecting businesses.

The Federal Bar Association September Monthly Luncheon will be held on Wednesday, September 15 at 12:15 pm at the Chicago Bar Association, 321 S. Plymouth Court. The topic of this luncheon is "Does the patent system need fixing?" There will be a panel discussion on the Federal Trade Commission Report "To Promote Innovation: The Proper Balance of Competition and Patent Law and Policy". The moderator will be Alan Barry of Bell, Boyd & Lloyd and the panelists include Susan DeSanti, General Counsel of the FTC, Timothy Holbrook of the Chicago-Kent College of Law and Harry Roper of Jenner & Block.

Tuesday, August 31, 2004

Headline from The State newspaper from South Carolina: "No patent on ‘You’re Fired’ - Trump’s attempt to register words rejected because it’s too much like ‘You’re Hired!’"

- The article doesn't mention if Trump's term was rejected under 35 U.S.C. 102 or 103 . . .

Friday, August 27, 2004

India Breaches Arrythmia and Alappat: Innovators in IT can rejoice. Even as software per se would continue to be outside the purview of patenting, embedded software as well as software/hardware combinations would qualify for patents, if they fulfil specified novelty conditions. That is, certain applications of software that have hardware elements can be patented.

The clarification is among a host of changes the UPA government has made in the patent amendment bill, originally drafted by the previous NDA government. Another major amendment in the re-drafted bill relates to protection of biological resources from unfair patenting. Disclosure of the origin of materials like plants, animals and micro-organisms would now be a mandatory pre-requisite for patents of inventions using such material or associated knowledge.

In the patent application, the disclosure has to be made upfront. Absence of the disclosure can be held as reason for opposition to or rejection or revocation of a patent, it has been freshly clarified. India is the first country to make such disclosure mandatory, officials said. The aim is to avoid usurpation of traditional knowledge and unfair patenting by use of such usurped knowledge.

Medtronic Case Goes to Jury: After a month and a half of testimony presented by two high-powered legal teams, a jury of eight men and three women in Memphis will decide whether a company with a significant financial presence here owes an inventor more than $1 billion.

The players in the trial, of a suit instigated three years ago, include Medtronic, Inc., a Fridley, Minn.-based medical technology company that owns Medtronic Sofamor Danek. The subsidiary company is based in Memphis, where it employs about 1,200 people. It's Medtronic's spinal business, and accounts for about 12% of the company's overall revenue.

Dr. Gary Michelson invented important technology that contributes significantly to Medtronic's revenue stream. He claims the company is cheating him out of rights and royalties that belong to him. Attorneys for Medtronic implored jurors Thursday to keep intact agreements that protect much of Medtronic's spinal fusion technology, according to a report in Friday's Minneapolis Star Tribune. That technology is a cornerstone of Medtronic's highly profitable $1.8 billion-a-year spinal business, the business of Memphis-based Medtronic Sofamor Danek.

Michelson a spinal surgeon who lives and practices in Los Angeles, claims in the trial that Medtronic cheated him out of royalties in a $1.7 billion contract dispute playing out in U.S. District Court. Thursday's closing arguments wrapped up 46 days of testimony before a jury of eight men and three women. The jury is expected to begin deliberating Friday afternoon.

The twilight of the trial brought charges and counter charges between both sides' lawyers. Leo Bearman, who represents Medtronic, claims that Michelson "wants to destroy this company, which has 1,200 employees in Memphis," according to the Star Tribune.

Medtronic sued Michelson in 2001, claiming that he tried to peddle his spinal fusion technology to competitors -- even though his contracts had a noncompete clause prohibiting him from doing so. Michelson's attorneys say that the company doesn't own the doctor's "life's work," and that he was free to market his other inventions to Medtronic rivals.

Thursday, August 26, 2004

Not Accepted to Princeton? Apply to Trump! As reported in the "Smoking Gun":

Donald Trump is plotting the establishment of Trump University. The millionaire developer/reality TV star this month filed an application with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to secure a TM for the Trump University name in connection with planned "educational services in the nature of conducting on-line courses in the fields of business and real estate." A copy of the August 4 trademark application, filed on The Donald's behalf by a lawyer with the white-shoe Proskauer Rose law firm, can be found below. It is unclear what position Trump, a graduate of the Wharton School of Finance, will hold at Trump U.

Stupid Idea of the Day: No offense, but this made my mouth drop when I read it from the Hindu Times in an article titled "Alternatives to Patent System":

In his `Policy Forum,' in Science, Yochai Benkler describes how scientists can organize their research projects using a cooperative approach that gets around some of the limitations imposed by the patent system.

Production is "commons-based" when no one uses exclusive rights to organise effort or capture its value, and when cooperation is achieved through social mechanisms other than price signals or managerial directions.

-- And from each according to his abilities to each according to their needs . . .

China's Got the Litigation Bug: China is likely to see an increase in patent lawsuits after domestic drugmakers won victories against overseas competitors in cases against the Pfizer drug Viagra and the GlaxoSmithKline drug Avandia, legal experts have said. "I would not be surprised to see many more challenges such as these," said Janice Mueller, a professor at the University of Pittsburgh's School of Law.

Glaxo, Europe's largest drugmaker, last week gave up a fight to protect a key ingredient in Avandia, its top diabetes treatment, a month after China revoked the local patent for Viagra, the world's best-selling impotence drug.

Chinese drugmakers are becoming more willing to use legal means to secure competitive advantages, three years after the nation joined the World Trade Organization. The trend may hurt sales for foreign companies in China's $10 billion drug market and lead to more trade disputes.

"It isn't hard to find loopholes" in Chinese patents held by overseas drugmakers, said Xu Guowen, a Beijing-based lawyer who led the cases against Viagra and Avandia. "All I need is to find one weakness and I can break your patent."

-- Loopholes? Is that what he considers prior art?

Wednesday, August 25, 2004

Inequitable Conduct = Very Angry Licensees Invoking the False Claims Act: The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals will decide the right of the United States to recover losses on payments made to Hoffmann-La Roche and its partner Applera Corporation on a key patent in molecular biology. The claim filed in Virginia seeks recovery of what could be hundreds of millions of dollars in wrongful payments for Taq DNA Polymerase by theGovernment to Hoffmann-La Roche and Applera. This action arose out of other litigation in which the Roche Taq patent was ruled unenforceable. The FederalCourt for the Northern District of California ruled in 1999 and reaffirmedthis past May that the patent for Taq could not be enforced against anyone because it had been obtained with a series of false material statements thatwere intentionally made to the United States Patent Office, which even included the fabrication of experimental data. Promega damage claims on its own behalf remain pending in California.

"As the Federal Court in California held, people lied to the United States Patent Office in obtaining the Taq patent," stated Randall Dimond, PromegaVice President and Chief Technical Officer. "As many in the scientific community recognize, Roche's aggressive enforcement of this patent caused hundreds of millions to be paid to Roche through government grants and other government programs, and we believe the people who paid those monies, including the government, should be paid back. We believe the False Claims Actis one important way to ensure integrity in the patent process. Wrongfully obtained patents prevent free and open competition and thus lead, as they did here, to grossly excessive pricing caused by the payment of royalties and license fees on a patent that never should have been allowed. Open competition guarantees that precious federal dollars are not needlessly squandered."

The Virginia action is based on the False Claims Act, a federal statute allowing recovery of funds improperly paid by the Government. While the case was brought by Promega on behalf of the United States, the United StatesDepartment of Justice had, as well, previously filed a Statement of Interestin the Virginia case in support of Promega. At the insistence of Hoffmann-LaRoche, the media and public have been barred from seeing the substance of the latest False Claims Act allegations.

Paying Programmers on Contingency (Just Like Lawyers!): The "Ingres Million Dollar Challenge" recently announced by Computer Associates (CA) has a lot in common with a contingent legal matter. A million dollar pool is divided into six prizes, ranging from $400,000 to $50,000. The prizes award the best tools for migrating from competing database platforms to CA's Ingres platform. For example, the developer that creates the best migration tool for moving data from the IBM DB2 Universal platform to the Ingres platform gets $300,000.

Like a lawyer deciding whether to take on a contingent matter, programmers deciding whether to rise to the Ingres Challenge need to take a hard look at the project. Developing a migration tool for complex databases is not a three weekend job for four teenagers on home computers. It takes a considerable investment of time and money by skilled programmers.

Tuesday, August 24, 2004

CIO Leaves USPTO: At a time when intellectual-property issues promise to be a sensitive and hotly contested for years to come among software users and vendors, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office is losing its IT chief. Douglas Bourgeois, who has been CIO at the agency for more than three years, announced Monday that he has accepted an offer to become director of the Department of Interior's National Business Center. Bourgeois, whose last day with the Patent Office is Sept. 3, leaves an organization dealing with a business environment that increasingly places a high priority on defending intellectual property. Over the past few years Bourgeois has led the Patent E-Government initiative, which provides online access to the full-text database of more than 3 million patents and published applications using the Electronic Filing System or traditional paper filing.

Get Thee To a Biotech Firm! New York Lawyer is reporting that Biotech patent work has boomed to the point that there aren't enough attorneys to handle it. Biotech lawyers say the demand for their legal specialty has grown tremendously over the last five years -- a period during which science has recorded several watershed discoveries, including the sequencing of the human genetic code, cloning, gene-based therapies and genetically engineered crops. Now drug companies are suing each other over patent rights. Farmers are suing the makers of bio-engineered corn. Patients are suing doctors over genetic testing. Privacy rights are being raised in child-custody battles involving DNA. And the government is under pressure to approve genetically altered foods and gene-based drugs.

Nintendo Takes a Poke at Microsoft, Sony and Nokia: Another day, another patent. This time it's Nintendo in the news, as they have applied for and been granted a patent covering many aspects of online console gaming. The new patent looks to be an extension of this earlier patent filed for in April 1999 and awarded in July 2003, which is common under the current US patent system. Together, the two patents cover about everything you need for online gaming with your favorite console. Looking at the features described in the most recent patent, you will no doubt note similarities between this hypothetical device from Nintendo and other consoles currently on the market.

  • Communications circuitry, coupled in use to said game processing system and to a user's communications network, for linking said game processing system to the Internet and permitting communication from the player to another party over the Internet
  • A writeable mass storage device coupled in use to said game processing system for receiving information downloaded from the Internet

In addition, it covers keeping track of player performance data, multiplayer gaming, and an entire online gaming service.

At first glance, it is a curious move from a company that has limited support for online gaming in its flagship console and has publicly expressed a lack of interest in the whole online gaming scene. The Nintendo GameCube is the only one of the "big three" consoles that does not support online gaming, and the only plans they have made known for online gaming is via the new Nintendo DS handheld. It is unclear if their next-generation console will allow players to go online. However, it does give them a certain amount of leverage over competitors such as Sony and Microsoft, both of which have made online gaming a centerpiece of their user experience. Even Nokia could be in trouble with the N-Gage. Until Nintendo makes their Internet connectivity intentions known for their next-generation console, it is likely that they will use the patents as leverage over its rivals, even to extract licensing revenues.

Monday, August 23, 2004

Eolas Update: Chicago-based Eolas Inc. holds a license to the patent, No. 5,838,906, from the University of California at Berkeley. Last year, it won a $521 million jury verdict against Microsoft Corp. in its patent-infringement case. Microsoft has since appealed the verdict.
According to patent office spokeswoman Brigid Quinn, Eolas on Monday was mailed an "office action" on the re-examination of the disputed patent. A number of online reports said the patent office examiner decided to reject the 10 claims presented by Eolas.

But Eolas attorney Martin Lueck, of Minneapolis-based Robins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi LLP, said the examiner had accepted a number of Eolas' arguments and had withdrawn his previous finding from February.

Lueck said the patent office examiner had issued a new action—based on yet another piece of "prior art"—to reject the patent's claims. The prior-art piece was outside the examples offered by the W3C (World Wide Web Consortium), which brought the prior-art question to the attention of the patent office in November 2003.

Monday, August 16, 2004

"X-Files" - USPTO Style: The Patent and Trademark Office has issued nearly 7 million patents. The first 10,000 are known as the X-patents. They were issued from July 1790, when the U.S. patent system was created under an order signed by George Washington, to July 1836, when every one of them burned in a fire.

Virtually every patent is available to the public on paper, micro-fiche, CD-ROM and the Internet -- except the X-patents.

In the 168 years since the fire, copies and records of only about 2,800 have been recovered. Over time, the appearances of missing X-patents grew fewer and farther between. Now no one at the patent agency, which does not have an official historian, can remember the last time one surfaced.

Until this spring, that is. That's when two lawyers with a passion for patent history uncovered a clue to several important patents from the 1790s -- including one from 1826 for the first internal combustion engine. Following the trail to Dartmouth College, they discovered inventors' copies of 14 patents that had been written off as lost forever.

Karma-Karma-Karma-Karma Karma (Apple) Chameleon: Apple has filed a patent for an "active enclosure for computing device". The invention, attributed to Duncan Kerr and Steve Hotelling is described thus: "The computing device includes a housing having an illuminable portion. The computing device also includes a light device disposed inside the housing. The light device is configured to illuminate the illuminable portion." The patent, filed on February 6, 2004, describes how Macs can be modified so that they can alter their physical appearance through lights encased within. The device is described as "chameleonic" because it is able to alter its physical appearance, like a chameleon.

Nanotech Report 2004: Lux Research, an advisory firm focused on nanotechnology, today announced the release of keyfindings from The Nanotech Report 2004, a more than 600-page reference study.The findings are part of the report's 24-page introduction that can beaccessed at no charge from: http://www.luxresearchinc.com/tnr2004

Partial list of The Nanotech Report 2004's key findings:

* Governments, corporations and venture capitalists will spend more than $8.6 billion worldwide on nanotechnology research and development in 2004.

* National and local governments across the world will invest more than $4.6 billion in nanotechnology R&D in 2004. We expect 2004 will be the last year that governments outspend corporations on nanotechnology as activity shifts from basic research to applications development.

* The U.S. government will spend nearly twice as much on nanotechnology this year as it did on the Human Genome Project (HGP) in its peak year. In 2005, the National Nanotechnology Initiative will surpass the HGP on a cumulative basis. The U.S. has now appropriated more than $3.16 billion to fund nanotechnology R&D since 2000 and is proposing $982 million in new funding for FY 2005.

* Established corporations will spend more than $3.8 billion globally on nanotechnology R&D in 2004.

* There is no bubble in nanotech venture capital funding, despite widespread reports to the contrary. VC firms invested just $79 million into nanotechnology companies in the first half of 2004, down from annual totals of $325 million in 2003 and $386 million in 2002. Based upon current fundraising activity, we expect VC investment to total approximately $200 million in 2004.

* Approximately 1,500 total companies worldwide have announced nanotechnology R&D plans. Eighty percent of them -- approximately 1,200 -- are start-ups, 670 of which are in the U.S.

* Media coverage of nanotechnology -- both positive and negative -- is increasingly exponentially. Mentions of the word "nanotechnology" in the popular press rose from 190 in 1995 to 7,316 in 2003; we predict more than 12,000 mentions in 2004.

Thursday, August 12, 2004

2 Cents: Attorney's weigh in on the Linux patent threat.

RTIS wins $876 million patent services deal: Reed Technology and Information Services Inc. has won a 10-year, $876 million contract from the Patent and Trademark Office to process patents, the company announced today. RTIS of Horsham, Pa., will continue to capture, manage and prepare for publication patent applications submitted to the office.

To support these services, the company has developed a work flow management system designed to meet Patent and Trademark Office business rules, which require converting large volumes of complex and scientific and technical information into searchable Extensible Markup Language and image databases.

The XML and image-based patent products that RTIS delivers under the contract are used by agency examiners and staff and disseminated worldwide by the Patent and Trademark Office. RTIS has supported patent grant operations at the Patent and Trademark Office since 1970 and publication of patent applications since 2001.

RTIS is part of the LexisNexis Group of Miamisburg, Ohio. The parent company has 12,800 employees and annual sales of $2.3 billion, according to Hoover’s Online of Austin, Texas.


Tuesday, August 10, 2004

Acacia Hits the Universities (It Just Keeps Getting Better With These Guys): The Maryland attorney general's office is investigating claims by a California technology company that several of the state's colleges and universities have infringed upon its patents by using the Internet to transmit video and audio."We're trying to review the situation and make some strategic decisions," Assistant Attorney General Thomas Faulk said yesterday. "We are first trying to determine whether or not we think there's any viability to the claim."

But even if the allegations are false, college officials say they might have no choice but to pay a fee for the technology, fearing the alternative is to go to court, which could cost millions of dollars in legal fees.A division of Acacia Research Corp., based in Newport Beach, recently sent letters to dozens of higher education institutions across the country. Among them were Washington College in Chestertown, the University of Maryland, College Park and the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.

The company claimed that schools using a form of streaming video or audio for online lectures or to transmit course material over the Internet were violating Acacia's patents on the technology if they weren't paying the company for that privilege.

Un - - - - - believable . . .

Microsoft Fights Back in Japan: The head of Microsoft's Japan unit acknowledged Tuesday that the U.S. software giant's battle with Japanese anti-monopoly authorities over the company's licensing clause is hurting its corporate image here.

But Michael Rawding said the company will continue to oppose the Fair Trade Commission's decision last month. He said the legal wrangle could last as long as two years. Commission officials agree the battle could be a long one.

The Fair Trade Commission sent an official warning to Microsoft on July 13, demanding that it drop the clause in licensing agreements that the commission suspects help Microsoft unlawfully infringe patents.

The clause prevents companies from suing Microsoft or other licensees over suspected cases of patent and copyright infringement in which elements of manufacturers' own software technology may end up in the Windows system.

The contract clause, called the "non-assertion of patents provision," says companies that sign Windows licensing agreements will forgo the right to sue over suspected patent infringements linked to the licensing.

The commission said the clause is "restrictive" by making it difficult for Japanese electronics companies to obtain royalty fees even when rivals violate their patents. The commission did not levy a fine or issue other penalties.

Why Patent Interference Proceedings Are Worth It


We're In The Money: Forgent Networks Inc. has a modest software business, but lately it's been showing a swagger reminiscent of another line of work: trial lawyers.

While it tries to build its line of scheduling software, Austin-based Forgent has been hiring lawyers to extract revenue from the company's store of old patents. Already, Forgent has reaped nearly $50 million by claiming that one of its patents covers JPEG, the popular standard for digital images. Sony Corp. and Adobe Systems Inc. are among the tech giants that have settled with Forgent. More riches may be on the way: In April, Forgent sued 31 tech companies, most of them Fortune 500 members, in U.S. District Court in Marshall, Texas for allegedly infringing on the JPEG patent.

Two of Forgent's former lawyers say the company has only scratched the surface with the patent and that the potential payoff could be in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Now Forgent is escalating its strategy. The company is demanding payment for a patent it says underlies the digital-recorder technology behind TiVo Inc. It's also hired the 650-lawyer Baker Botts law firm to examine 40 additional patents.

Then there's Jenkens & Gilchrist, the Dallas-based law firm handling enforcement of the JPEG patent. Under a fee agreement, Jenkens receives 50 percent of the revenue from licensing the patent, plus some expenses. The law firm's take so far is an estimated $50 million.

Friday, August 06, 2004

Update on E-Data: After settling with Apple, E-Data Corporation is suing some of the most powerful and successful e-commerce players, demanding they pay a penalty for every time a customer downloaded digital content in the last six years. E-Data has its sights on Amazon.com, The New York Times Company and Hallmark Cards, American Greetings, suing them for damages based on past patent infringements by their downloading services.

Interesting article on the EPO's decision that the Harvard Oncomouse could be patented in Europe.

IBM Promises to Play Nice (Well, Kind Of): IBM announced that it will not use its patents against Linux, and it encouraged other software companies to make the same vow.
As the owner of 60 patents on which the Linux core might infringe, IBM could wreak havoc on Linux if it chose to do so. The new promise, delivered at LinuxWorld, emphasizes the company's commitment to open source . In a speech at the conference, however, IBM senior vice president Nick Donofrio said that in the future the company could be "forced to defend" itself through patent enforcement.

Wednesday, August 04, 2004

False Start For Nanosys - Nanosys Inc., a company that develops technology aimed at building new materials by manipulating atoms and molecules, withdrew its highly anticipated initial public offering Wednesday.

Palo Alto, Calif.-based Nanosys cited "adverse market conditions" as the reason it pulled the IPO. The company, which reported an $8.8 million loss for the first six months of 2004, had been hoping to raise about $100 million and use the proceeds to help meet its operating and capital requirements over the next year.

Proponents tout nanotechnology as a potential multibillion-dollar industry. But so far, nanotechnology has yielded only modest commercial products like stain-resistant fabrics, and some scientists say nanotech's profit-making future is still 10 to 20 years off.

Nanosys says it has more than 200 patents and patent applications covering its discoveries. The company's regulatory filings say it's in the early stages of research to develop products for industries, such as energy, defense, electronics and information technology.

Patent Holding Companies Everywhere - And Not a Drop To Drink: Apple Computer has become the latest in a line of companies licensing patents from the relatively obscure E-Data, a company that claims to hold property rights on the process of selling music online.

E-Data said Wednesday that it had reached a European agreement with Apple that gave the company worldwide rights for its iTunes Music Store. It has now launched a new round of patent infringement suits against 14 companies including Amazon.com and The New York Times.

Previously, E-Data sued and settled with Microsoft, as well as a handful of other companies, largely under European patent rules.

"This settlement with Apple marks another important milestone, as we aggressively pursue companies that are infringing upon our intellectual property," said E-Data Chairman Bert Brodsky. "We have identified additional companies that are infringing upon our intellectual property, both in the U.S. and abroad, and will seek the necessary legal actions to ensure that our rights are enforced worldwide."

E-Data has been one of the most successful of a generation of companies that has emerged claiming patent rights to what many view as basic Internet business or technology procedures, such as e-commerce, streaming media and Web browser elements.

Tuesday, August 03, 2004

Say Good-Bye to Jazz: A federal trade agency might impose $13 million in sanctions against a New Jersey company that rebuilds used disposable cameras made by the Fuji Photo Film Company and sells them without brand names at a discount.

Fuji said yesterday that the International Trade Commission found that the Jazz Photo Corporation infringed Fuji's patent rights by taking used Fuji cameras and refurbishing them for resale. The agency said Jazz sold more than 25 million cameras since August 2001 in violation of a 1999 order to stop and will consider sanctions.

Fuji, based in Tokyo, has been fighting makers of rebuilt cameras for seven years. Jazz takes used shells of disposable cameras, puts in new film and batteries and then sells them.

Storm Brewing Between Apple and RealNetworks? RealNetworks last week introduced Harmony, a technology that allows users of the Real Music Store to download their files onto an Apple iPod, a space Apple has strongly defended for its own music store files. Apple responded, saying that Real's efforts were the "tactics and ethics of a hacker."

Apple also cautioned Real that they were investigating the ramifications of the software under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), legislation enacted in 1998 that extended American copyright law to cover digital content. Real claims that they did not violate any laws under the DMCA and said, "consumers, and not Apple, should be the ones choosing what music goes on their iPod."

A good summary of the spat can be found here.

Monday, August 02, 2004

Japanese Universities Clean Up on Blue LED Technology: Some 96 percent of patent fees that national universities gained in fiscal 2003 came from inventions related to blue light-emitting diodes (LEDs) developed by Professor Emeritus Isamu Akasaki of Nagoya University, government officials said.

The demand for blue LEDs that have a lengthy lifespan and are bright has been rapidly growing as they are widely used for traffic lights and other similar purposes.

In fiscal 2003, 14 institutions, including those established jointly by multiple national universities and national colleges of technology gained a combined amount of roughly 427 million yen in patent fees, according to the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology.

Biggie Verdict in CA - An Orange County jury awarded $43.5 million in damages to a Rancho Santa Margarita-based company that claimed industry giant U.S. Surgical Corp. infringed on its patent for a device used in laparoscopic operations. The federal jury ruled Tuesday that U.S. Surgical, a division of Tyco International Ltd., willfully violated the patent of Applied Medical Services.

The finding allows Judge Cormac Carney to triple the damages and award attorney fees, actions which he is scheduled to consider at a Sept. 20 hearing. Applied argued that U.S. Surgical violated its patent on a sealing mechanism for a trocar, a tube that surgeons insert in patients to handle instruments during laparoscopic surgeries.

Linux's Patent Risk: Open Source Risk Management (OSRM) announced today that it had found 283 issued, but not yet court-validated, software patents in the Linux kernel.


The findings are the result of a thorough Linux patent review sponsored by OSRM, a firm that provides risk mitigation and insurance offerings to the open source community. The review however did not find a single patent infringement that had currently been court validated.
"By saying that these 283 patents could cover Linux means that [patent holders] have claims that could be infringed by practicing the Linux kernel," Dan Ravicher, founder and executive director of the Public Patent Foundation and senior counsel to the Free Software Foundation, told internetnews.com. "When patents get tested in court, the court finds them invalid about half of the time, so the court doesn't just accept the patent office's decision," Ravicher said.


"None of the 283 that I've identified are actually being litigated so far as I know, but the extent to which Microsoft is asserting its patents through means other than litigation is indeterminable," Ravicher said. "In many cases, there could be confidentiality agreements in place that prohibit us and the public from knowing exactly what Microsoft is doing and how they are trying to go out and assert their patents."


OSRM, however, is not going to reveal any hard specifics on the 283 patents. Ravicher explained that being aware of the particulars of a patent could potentially expose a developer to risk.


Thursday, July 29, 2004

Microsoft Antes Up:  Microsoft will continue to ramp up its patent filing and intellectual-property licensing efforts, chairman and chief software architect Bill Gates said today in a meeting with financial analysts at the company's Redmond, Wash., campus.
Microsoft plans to file more than 3,000 patents in fiscal 2005 compared to "something over" 2,000 patent filings the previous year, Gates said. The company's planned "cycle of innovation" includes securing intellectual-property rights on Microsoft products and licensing that technology to other companies, signing license agreement to use other companies' software within Microsoft own products, and providing indemnification protection to customers. Gates says Microsoft is still in the early stages of its licensing program.

Wednesday, July 28, 2004

Germany: New Developments in German Domain Name Case Law

Signs That You May Have a Problem Client (a.k.a. "Alternatives To Appeal in Patent Litigation"):   former Silicon Valley chief executive was indicted Tuesday for allegedly plotting to kill a San Francisco federal judge at the same time he was serving time in Santa Rita jail for trying to flee the country to evade perjury charges.

Amr Mohsen, the founder and former CEO of Sunnyvale-based Aptix, is accused of soliciting a hit man to murder U.S. District Judge William Alsup, whom he blames for his criminal troubles and the loss of his once-promising high-tech company.

Alsup had served as judge in a civil suit brought by Aptix against a rival valley firm three years ago, and took the unusual step of triggering a perjury probe by asking prosecutors to review whether Mohsen and Aptix falsified documents and lied in the nasty patent fight. 

Mohsen's problems stem from allegations that he fabricated critical evidence to support Aptix's long-running, high-stakes patent lawsuit against San Jose-based Cadence Design Systems over chip design technology. Alsup, in the midst of a civil trial between the two companies in 2001, dismissed Aptix's case after concluding that Mohsen and possibly other executives falsified documents.

Tuesday, July 27, 2004

Cars Have Feelings Too:  Yes, I know - this has been making the rounds in the last few days, but what the heck:

The expression "road rage" usually refers to infuriated drivers who lose control of their temper and lash out at other motorists. But what if a car could also express anger, crouching low on its wheel base and glowering with red headlights like a lion about to pounce?

Four inventors working for Toyota in Japan have won a patent for a car that they say can help drivers communicate better by glaring angrily at another car cutting through traffic as well as appear to cry, laugh, wink, or just look around.

The inventors explain in the patent that they want drivers to have more than a one-note horn and on-off headlights to signal other drivers. The horn sounds the same, they write, whether a driver is "asking for permission to cut in front and in showing gratitude for having been allowed to cut in front," so other people often do not know what the honking is about.

That was not good enough for the inventors - Kenji Mori, Naoto Kitagawa, Akihiro Inukai and Simon Humprhies - who work for Toyota Jidosha Kabushiki Kaisha of Japan, which owns the United States patent issued last month. In it they describe a car with an antenna that wags, an adjustable body height, headlights that vary in intensity, and hood slits and ornamentation designed to look like eyebrows, eyelids and tears, all of which could glow with colored lights to create moods and physical features.

-  I don't know about you, but I have found that semiautomatic firearms help drivers to communicate very well, thank you . . .



I Scoff At Thee!  A patent expert has scoffed at fears from the open source community that a recently exhumed memo from a high ranking HP exec foretells an imminent legal campaign against the software community based on patent claims.

In a two-year-old memo sent by Gary Campbell, then vice president of strategic architecture, to a number of other HP execs, he said he feared 'Microsoft could attack Open Source Software for patent infringements against OEMs, Linux distributors, and least likely open source developers.'

However Greg Aharonian, a patent expert who run the patnews service said: 'The memo was written two years ago, and not much has happened, not surprisingly. The memo does say that Microsoft will wait three years, and then strike, but I would not bet my money on that. Additionally... Microsoft is planning to return $75bn to stockholders over the next few years. When you have that much cash, tactical battles with patents are a pointless business.'

Powered By Blogger

DISCLAIMER

This Blog/Web Site ("Blog") is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Use of the Blog does not create any attorney-client relationship between you and Peter Zura or his firm. Persons requiring legal advice should contact a licensed attorney in your state. Any comment posted on the Blog can be read by any Blog visitor; do not post confidential or sensitive information. Any links from another site to the Blog are beyond the control of Peter Zura and does not convey his, or his past or present employer(s) approval, support, endorsement or any relationship to any site or organization.

The 271 Patent Blog © 2008. Template by Dicas Blogger.

TOPO