UK TAKES A FIRST STAB AT "TECHNICAL EFFECT": One of the big sticking points in the EU software patent debacle is that, under one proposal (the "UK model"), software would be provided patent protection, if it has a "technical effect." The problem is, no one has provided a clear definition of what this actually means.
Accordingly, The UK Patent Office is to hold a series of workshops that will discuss the definition of what constitutes a technical effect; a major point of conflict in the debate about software patenting in Europe.
The Patent Office says: "Participants will be shown a variety of definitions for 'technical contribution' and invited to work in groups to test these against a range of innovations. They will also be welcome to propose definitions of their own."
Participants must register by 18 February.
The workshops will be held on the following dates:
15 March - Coventry
17 March - Bolton
18 March - Bristol
4 April - Belfast
5 April - Glasgow
7 April - London
8 April - Cardiff
Friday, February 04, 2005
Thursday, February 03, 2005
ACADEMIC IP - PATENT OR PERISH? Universities' ability to augment their revenues by licensing patents from faculty research has sparked new discussion about the tension between teaching and research responsibilities.
The recent surge in research disclosures in American universities over the last 20 years or so has turned into a whole new enterprise. Particularly in the sciences, patents are gaining new prominence - and ideas that are successfully patented have become an important source of revenue for universities.
For example, at Tufts University, if a professor submits a research disclosure of patent potential, the worth of the disclosure is determined in a three-person dialogue including the professor who made the disclosure, an administrator and a patent attorney.
If a professor's patent is licensed by a business, any income received is divvied up. 40 percent goes to the investigating professor who originally made the disclosure, 20 percent is given to the professor's department, while 20 percent goes to the professor's school and 20 percent to Tufts' general fund.
Since 1999, Tufts has earned $10,557,822 from the licensing of patents to private businesses, according to a survey by the Association of University Technology Managers. The year-to-year income, however, is unsteady. In 2003, the most recent year that numbers are available, Tufts only earned $738,331 from licensing. In contrast New York University reaped the most of the universities surveyed, earning more than $85 million.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:33 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
REVIEWING INDEMNIFICATION CLAUSES: More proprietary vendors will be offering indemnification protection to their customers in the coming year; however, not all indemnification offers will be equally valuable.
Karen Copenhaver, general counsel and executive vice president for Black Duck Software, offers advice in this article about indemnifications, getting support from open source projects and protecting internal software developed on open source code.
One interseting point brought up was the collaborative effect that results from a single infringement lawsuit. If one company is using an open source project that many, many other people are using, then you know that if anyone in that user group is sued, others will be concerned as well. In the end, you could get a very powerful reaction to that claim. In patent claims there will be an entire community that will be providing prior art for the validity challenge. They will be looking at how to provide an instantaneous workaround, and they will be testing that workaround. Companies can be in a much better position if they face an infringement claim under these circumstances because there will be a large open source community actually addressing the infringement issue.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:17 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
EU SOFTWARE PATENTS - BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD: The battle to prevent software patents being introduced in Europe received a major boost on Wednesday afternoon when the Legal Affairs Committee (JURI) of the European Parliament (EP) demanded that the Computer Implemented Inventions Directive (CIID) be rewritten.
A EP spokesman confirmed on Thursday that the president will be asked by the European Commission (EC) to take the patent directive back to the drawing board.
Piia-Noora Kauppi, a Finnish MEP who was present at the JURI meeting, said this decision had considerable support from the members of the Legal Affairs Committee.
The EP spokesman said the EC is not obliged to agree to the EP's request for a restart, but is likely to adhere to the will of the parliament. But an EC spokesman said that the Commission has not yet decided anything and will "keep its options open" and "see what happens with the EU Council".
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:13 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, February 01, 2005
OPEN-SOURCE NON-PROFIT LEGAL CENTER OPENS: Eben Moglen, a Columbia University law professor who has represented the Free Software Foundation in legal cases, has set up the Software Freedom Law Center to provide free legal advice to those in the open source movement, and it should have four full-time lawyers by the end of the year.
The center said in a statement that it will employ two full-time intellectual-property attorneys, who will help provide consulting services to non-profit open source organizations. The staff count is expected to expand to four later in 2005. The help they provide could include training lawyers, supporting litigation, dealing with licensing problems and keeping managing contributions to open source projects.
Overseeing the Software Freedom Law Center will be Moglen; Diane Peters, OSDL's general counsel; Daniel Weitzner, the principal research scientist at Massachusetts Institute of Technology's Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory; and Lawrence Lessig, a Stanford law professor and author.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:59 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
INDIA HO! While people decry the outsourcing of legal work, India seems ripe for the "patent-pickings" so to speak. However, this recent article, which calls for greater recruiting of patent attorneys, seems to indicate that India is experiencing a gross understaffing of registered patent attorneys within India itself.
In a country of more than one billion, the number of actual patent attorney practitioners does not even cross the 100-mark.
Says Ramesh B Vishwanath, advocate and registered patent and trademarks attorney from Hyderabad, "There may be several registered patent attorneys in the country today but the number of actual patent attorney practitioners is just around 50."
According to the official website on patents, the number of registered patent agents (attorneys) as on May 31, 2004, was 607.
"Till now there were only about 2,000 patents filed by Indian companies and 25,000 by foreign companies in India, on a yearly basis. Within a couple of years, we expect these numbers to grow to 10,000 from India and 1 lakh (Rs 100,000) from abroad," he adds.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:35 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
OPEN SOURCE - KEEPING THOSE LICENSES STRAIGHT: (From CNET) The latest tactic in the software-patenting battle is the granting of patent rights to open-source developers. Sun Microsystems recently made software patents available for use by open-source developers. But its patent grant came with strings attached: The 1,600-some patents may only be used under Sun's Common Development and Distribution License, which is incompatible with the General Public License used on Linux.
So while claiming to make the patents available to open-source developers, Sun can sue folks who work on Linux rather than Solaris. The irony here is that Sun's open-source license is derived from the same license used for Mozilla.
But Mozilla's developers have made most of their software available under the GPL, as well as under terms of their own license. If Sun wants to be a partner in the open-source community, then shutting out the Linux developers isn't a good start.
Philip Albert of Linux Insider writes that while IBM's patent release was generally well-received by the open source community, Sun's move has so far been viewed with suspicion by some, including its competitors, IBM, Red Hat and Novell.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:29 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, January 28, 2005
PATENTCAFE CREATES OPEN-SOURCE SEARCH TOOLS: PatentCafe has set up a database of the 500 patents that IBM has pledged to open up to open source developers claiming its natural language-based search engine will accelerate developers' use of the patents.
However, PatentCafe warns that developers "still need to remain vigilant even if using the information in a pledged IBM patent" since their software programs "could still be found to infringe a different company's patent." So, if you find what you need in your search, don't bet the farm that you will be clear of any infringement.
PatentCafe further intends to enlarge the project to search open source software patents worldwide. Developers are supposed to be able to create a hierarchical list of the most relevant patents and find the patents most related to their software projects.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 11:10 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, January 27, 2005
PATENTS, PUBLIC POLICY AND COCKFIGHTING - ALWAYS A WINNING COMBINATION: A state senator has a plan for saving Oklahoma's gamefowl industry now that cockfighters are legally prohibited from pitting birds fitted with razor-like spurs.
State Sen. Frank Shurden, a longtime defender of cockfighting, is suggesting that roosters be given little boxing gloves so they can fight without bloodshed. The proposal is in a bill the Henryetta Democrat has introduced for the legislative session that begins Feb. 7.
In his search for a new way to let gamecocks fight, Shurden learned about a California man who is an attorney for Gamecock Boxing Inc., which was formed to promote a nonlethal form of cockfighting.
"The company has a patent now pending on this game and the equipment designed to score the 'hits' of these sparring live gamefowl," Californian John R. Cogorno wrote in a letter to Shurden.
Shurden said electronic sensors can record the number of hits by each gamefowl to determine which rooster won the boxing match.
Gamecocks would wear sparring muffs, which are padded gloves placed over their natural spurs.
"To me it answers everything. It saves the industry, takes blood sport out and generates revenue for Oklahoma," Shurden said.
Oh, the power of patents!
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:10 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
I'LL SEE YOUR 500, AND RAISE YOU 1,170: SUN HAS open sourced OpenSolaris and 1,670 of its patents and promised that more will follow in the second quarter of the year.
In a conference call to hacks, Sun Chairman and CEO Scott McNealy declared Sun to be the largest donor of open source code anywhere on planet earth.
The release follows IBM's open sourcing of 500 patents last week. McNealy said that unlike "a lot of companies" Sun was not using open source to dispose of end-of-life code.
The initial piece of Solaris being made available now is DTrace performance analysis technology. Other Solaris source code, such as file system and security technologies, will be offered in the second quarter of this year.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:05 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
NOT A GOOD TIME TO BE HYNIX: Rambus Inc., which is based in Los Altos, Calif., said Tuesday that it has sued Hynix and three other companies, alleging infringements of up to 18 of Rambus' patents relating to memory chips. The suit comes five days after Canadian firm Mosaid sued Hynix, alleging that Hynix was infringing on six of Mosaid's patents.
Rambus previously had filed suit against Hynix, claiming that Hynix was infringing on 15 of Rambus' patents. Last week, a federal judge found that Hynix was infringing on parts of four Rambus patents, Rambus said in a news release. The judge also granted Hynix' motion that nine claims relating to four patents be removed from the case. The first phase of the trial focusing on issues still in dispute is scheduled to begin March 21, Rambus said.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:00 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
OVER? DID YOU SAY OVER? Nothing is over until we decide it is! The Canadian creators of the BlackBerry, the wildly successful wireless e-mail device embraced by so many Americans, say they will take their patent dispute with a Virginia company all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court if necessary.
And the Canadian government has also stepped into the patent infringement case, determined to protect the nation's greatest high-tech success story.
Canada claims a recent U.S. federal court ruling against Research in Motion Ltd., the Ontario-based makers of the BlackBerry, threatens to have a "troubling effect of chilling innovation by Canadian companies."
Henry Bunsow, an attorney representing Research in Motion, said the company would not settle out of court and is prepared to argue before the U.S. high court.
Research in Motion claims its BlackBerry relay server - through which all e-mails pass - is based in Waterloo, Ontario, so U.S. patent laws have no jurisdiction, even though most of its 2 million subscribers are below the 49th parallel.
Dennis Crouch from Patently Obvious gives a nice demonstration on his blog.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:54 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, January 25, 2005
CHINESE DVD MANUFACTURERS SUE 3C PATENT GROUP: Two Chinese-based DVD manufacturers, Wuxi Multimedia Ltd. and Orient Power (Wuxi) Technology Ltd., have filed a lawsuit against the 3C Patent Group in the United States, alleging that it violated US laws, leading to unfair competition.
The 3C group is a consortium owned by Sony, Philips and Pioneer that manages DVD patent rights. Patent fees of around US$20 per unit are currently levied on manufacturers of Chinese DVD players, accounting for some 20 to 30 per cent of their production costs. However, US manufacturers' patent fees are much lower, only 3 to 5 per cent of their production costs.
The plaintiffs claim that the International Trade Commission ruled in March last year that the patent pool arrangement of Philips and Sony violated several provisions of the Sherman Act. The arrangement is virtually identical to the 3C patent pool.
The high patent fees have hit Chinese DVD manufacturers hard, with exports of Chinese DVD players falling sharply last year.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:57 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, January 21, 2005
RAMBUS SAVORS THE WIN (AND SO DO THEIR ATTORNEYS): Last Wednesday, the Los Altos company's stock fell 16 percent Wednesday after it reported disappointing earnings. Then Thursday, Rambus' shares soared 13 percent after the designer of memory-chip technology won a ruling in a San Jose patent-litigation case.
The legal ruling issued Thursday came in a patent dispute with South Korean memory-chip manufacturer Hynix Semiconductor, the second-largest maker of dynamic random access memory chips, or DRAMs. The chips are used in everything from video-game machines to computers.
U.S. District Judge Ronald Whyte ruled that no trial was necessary on 29 of 59 of Rambus' patent claims because it was clear Hynix violated them.
If upheld, the judgment would mean Hynix could owe damages and royalty payments on a big chunk of its annual $4 billion revenue in DRAM chips. The ruling is good news for Rambus, but it's just one of many legal cases involving its technology.
The litigation cost Rambus about $23 million last year. At stake is whether Rambus can collect royalties on revenue for the $26 billion DRAM industry.
-- I just did some math - assuming that $20 million of the $23 million figure reflects the legal services charged by the firms representing them (yeah, I know that's wrong, but it's convenient), it would take 20 attorneys billing 2000 hours at $500/hr apiece to reach that amount in a year . . . not bad for a year's work.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:12 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
HEWLETT-PACKARD AND INTERGRAPH SETTLE A WHOPPER: HP has decided to pay $141 million to Intergraph to settle a patent dispute that stretches back two years.
The settlement marks the end of all Intergraph litigation against computer manufacturers related to its Clipper patents, which cover memory management within computer systems. Intergraph filed suit against Dell, Gateway and HP in late 2002 and subsequently reached a settlement with Dell and Gateway last year. Intergraph also settled a related case with Intel last year that resulted in the chipmaker's payment of $225 million to Intergraph.
The HP settlement was announced Friday morning. Both companies will dismiss all pending litigation, and HP will pay Intergraph $141 million during the first quarter. The two companies will also enter into a cross-licensing agreement.
During the past two years, Intergraph has extracted $860 million (!!!) in pretax income from the protection and enforcement of its intellectual property. The Huntsville, Ala.-based company used to make computer workstations based on its own chip and graphics technologies. It now specializes in software and related services in industrial and government applications.
Intergraph will log $11 million in legal expenses in the first quarter.
-- Now, I'm not sure if that $11 million number is the cumulative total that was reached in the first quarter, or if the number was the amount spent in ONE quarter. If the latter is the case, there are some law firms out there laughing all the way to the bank . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:02 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, January 19, 2005
JURORS AVAILABLE FOR LITIGATION IN TENNESSEE: a little off-topic but very funny : Defense attorney Leslie Ballin called it the "jury pool from hell." The group of prospective jurors was summoned to listen to a case of Tennessee trailer park violence. Right after jury selection began last week, one man got up and left, announcing, "I'm on morphine and I'm higher than a kite."
When the prosecutor asked if anyone had been convicted of a crime, a prospective juror said that he had been arrested and taken to a mental hospital after he almost shot his nephew. He said he was provoked because his nephew just would not come out from under the bed.
Another would-be juror said he had had alcohol problems and was arrested for soliciting sex from an undercover officer. "I should have known something was up," he said. "She had all her teeth."
Another prospect volunteered he probably should not be on the jury: "In my neighborhood, everyone knows that if you get Mr. Ballin (as your lawyer), you're probably guilty." He was not chosen.The case involved a woman accused of hitting her brother's girlfriend in the face with a brick.
Ballin's client was found not guilty.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:16 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
HOLD YOUR PATENT OR JOIN A WORKING GROUP? Jose Cortina has an interseting article about companies working in industry standard groups and potential conflicts that may arise when patent portfolios clash with the interests of the group.
Standards organizations such as ANSI, IEEE, NISO and others have traditionally encouraged members of “working groups” who are active in developing industry standards to provide early disclosure to the technology community of those patents that may be essential for the use of the standards being developed. Industry giants that invest large sums in protecting their research and development must strike a balance between the benefits to be gained by enforcing their patent rights, and the benefits to be gained from being a participant in working groups that are setting standards.
If a patent appears to be of great value, and a company wants to maximize its return from that patent, the company may have to reevaluate its participation in working groups to avoid jeopardizing its ability to fully exploit the patent. As development of standards continues, companies must strike a balance in deciding whether or not to participate in such development if maximizing returns from patents is a significant goal.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:38 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
COMPUTER SCIENCES CORP. LANDS USPTO CONTRACT: Information technology company Computer Sciences Corp. received a systems development and integration contract from the federal Patent and Trademark Office for up to $280 million - one of the largest IT agreements awarded by the office, the company said Tuesday.
Under the contract, which has one base year and seven one-year options, CSC will provide systems design, development, implementation, integration, maintenance, testing and training and assess performance effectiveness and provide feedback to the patent office to help improve processes and enterprise architecture.
- Lets see where this leads us one year from now . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:32 AM 3 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, January 14, 2005
BEATING A DEAD ONE-CLICK PATENT: I wonder when practitioners will stop using Amazon's "one-click patent" as the default whipping post when dumping on the USPTO. It seems any article that criticizes the US patent system can't be written with at least ONE reference to the aforementioned patent. And enough with the "silly patent" stuff - sure it may be silly, but silliness is never a bar to patentability. In fact, it appears that the patent is still alive and kicking. Since it's been almost 5 years since the patent started making the rounds, you'd figure someone would have invalidated it by now, assuming that the patent is as obvious as everyone says it is.
Anyways, the patent is being dragged around again by people in the US who appear to have a sympathetic eye towards the nonsense going on in the EU with regard to software patents. Enough already.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 3:22 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
THE FUTURE OF LICENSING: Electronic News sat down to discuss the future of licensing intellectual property with various experts, and have published excerpts of the conversation. Among the questions answered were:
What’s different about licensing IP versus other types of licensing?
Where are the hot spots in the intellectual property world?
What happens with a system on a chip, where the intellectual property is coming from a variety of vendors and being built by subcontractors of subcontractors?
and
Is there a way to write contracts to minimize problems surrounding an extended supply chain?
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 3:12 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
CONGRATULATIONS! YOU'RE THE ONE MILLIONth CUSTOMER! Since the PCT system started in 1978, Companies around the world have filed applications for 1 million international patents, the U.N. agency for intellectual property said Friday.
The United States currently dominates the applications, filing 205,286 applications since 2000, said Samar Shamoon, spokeswoman for the World Intellectual Property Organization.
Japan is in second place with 72,891, followed by Germany with 70,513, Britain 25,916 and France 24,278.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 3:07 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
TESTA HURWITZ VOTES TO DISBAND: The law firm of Testa, Hurwitz & Thibeault , located in Boston, has voted to disband it's practice. The firm had over 300 attorneys and over 60 people working in its IP department. Very sad day indeed. Best of luck to all of the people affected by the dissolution.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:53 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, January 13, 2005
AND IF YOU THOUGHT THE RIAA WAS A BIG THREAT TO P-2-P: A US peer-to-peer tech company called Altnet Inc. is hawking its patent portfolio around the file-sharing community looking for licensing deals. The company has mailed numerous companies claiming their services infringe patents around the use of hashing.
The technology appends a hash code to files on these distributed networks. When a file is downloaded and made available elsewhere on such a system, the hash goes with it. Thus, when the software searches for copies of a given file, it only has to check for the hash rather than scan the entire file, to verify its identity, which greatly speeds up searches.
Altnet says it has already reached a preliminary agreement with Sharman Networks, owners of the massive KaZaA network. It is now approaching the smaller players and nascent commercial industry, who are not so forthcoming.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:41 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
FEEDBACK ON THE IBM DONATIONS: People have been chiming in on the IBM patent "freebie" and - as you would suspect - cynicism abounds. I have not personally looked through these patents (has anyone really done this?), but my experience taught me that such acts are rarely rooted in altruism, but merely serve as some sort of PR booster (remember the DuPont patent donations of unused patents that also happened to result in a $64 million tax write-off?). One theory is that the move was done to curry favor with the open source community. Others say it's no big deal anyways, since IBM has given previous assurances that the portfolio wouldn't be enforced against the Open-Source people.
Any way you slice it, no one can really know for sure what is going on, or the motivation behind this gift. Someone needs to sit down and sift through the documents (and I'm sure someone at IBM has done this) before a clearer picture can be formed.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:15 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, January 11, 2005
IBM OFFERS 500 PATENTS TO OPEN SOURCE: IBM says it is providing free access to the information in 500 company patents to individuals and groups working on open source software.
The company said it believes this is the largest pledge of patents of any kind and represents a major shift in how it manages and deploys its intellectual property.
Open source software is a spectrum of programs, the best known of them the Linux operating system, that are not under the lock and key of a single company but are developed by the communal efforts of volunteers who often start with little more than a common interest.
The philosophy behind open source: Grant a free license to users, include the software blueprints and let anyone make improvements with as few restrictions as possible.
IBM is trying to sell its business clients on using open source software instead of software from Microsoft Corp., with the understanding that a business using open source will require outside professional help, perhaps from IBM, to manage its systems.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:18 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
USPTO Releases Top 10 Patent Filers for 2004: The Department of Commerce's United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) announced today the 2004 top 10 private sector patent recipients. Listed below are the 10 corporations receiving the most patents for inventions in 2004, along with their 2003 ranking. For the twelfth consecutive year, IBM received more patents than any other private sector organization.
Top 10 Private Sector Patent Recipients for the 2004 Calendar Year
Preliminary Rank in 2004 / Preliminary # Patents in 2004 / Organization / (Final Rank in 2003) (Final Number of Patents in 2003)
1 3,248 International Business Machines Corporation (1) (3,415)
2 1,934 Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. ** (4) (1,774 ) **
3 1,805 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha (2) (1,992)
4 1,775 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. *** (5) (1,759) ***
5 1,760 Micron Technology, Inc. (6) (1,707)
6 1,604 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (9) (1,313)
7 1,601 Intel Corporation (7) (1,592)
8 1,514 Hitachi, Ltd (3) (1,893)
9 1,310 Toshiba Corporation (13) (1,184)
10 1,305 Sony Corporation (10) (1,311)
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:42 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, January 10, 2005
BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD: Members of the European Parliament from countries including Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland and Sweden have asked for the software patent directive to be redone from scratch, according to a report on Monday.
A motion for restarting the legislative process on the Computer Implemented Inventions Directive has been signed by 61 MEPs from 13 countries, according to anti-patent Web site NoSoftwarePatents.com. The signatories include a former Polish prime minister, a former European Commissioner and three vice-presidents of the European Parliament. The motion has also been published on the FFII Web site.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:34 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
NEW DEPUTY PATENT COMMISSIONERS ANNOUNCED: Jon Dudas, Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office, announced three new Deputy Commissioners for Patents, effective January 21, 2005.
Joseph Rolla, currently a director in Technology Center 2600 (telecommunications), has been named Deputy Commissioner for Patent Examination Policy. In his new position, Mr. Rolla will be in charge of patent policy operations.
Margaret “Peggy” Focarino will head USPTO's patent operations as Deputy Commissioner for Patent Operations. She is currently a director in Technology Center 2100 (computer architecture and software).
John Doll, a special assistant to Under Secretary Dudas, will be Deputy Commissioner for Patent Resources and Planning. In his new position, he will oversee patent information-technology and processing operations.
Joe Rolla joined the United States Patent and Trademark Office in 1972 following his graduation from the University of Maryland with a degree in Physics. He was promoted to Primary Examiner in 1978 and to Supervisory Patent Examiner in 1982. He earned his Juris Doctor degree in 1983. Joe was named a Group Director in 1990 and has served in a number of electrical cluster technology centers.
During his years at the USPTO, Joe has been actively involved in many projects of operational and legal significance to the office. He has received a Department of Commerce Bronze Medal, two Silver Medals and a Gold Medal in 1996 for his work with respect to the implementation of the USPTO examination guidelines for computer-related inventions.
Peggy Focarino graduated with a degree in physics from the State University of New York and became a patent examiner at the USPTO in 1977. She was promoted to a Supervisory Patent Examiner in 1989 and to the Senior Executive Service in 1997. She has been a Director in the computer related technology centers 2100 and 2800 since 2000.
Peggy has served as Patents' chief negotiator in several negotiations with the National Treasury Employees' Union (NTEU). She has also developed and negotiated numerous award programs for the technical support staff and managers within all of the business units of the patent organization. Peggy has been heavily involved in the training of patent managers on issues dealing with employee and labor relations for the last several years.
For the past year, John Doll has been on detail as a Special Assistant to Under Secretary Jon Dudas. Prior to that he was a Group Director in Technology Center 1600, responsible for those art units that examine organic chemistry, pharmaceuticals and biotechnology patent applications.
John holds a Bachelor of Science degree from Bowling Green State University in chemistry and physics and a Master of Science degree in physical chemistry from Penn State.
John joined the USPTO in 1974 and became a Group Director in 1995. Over the course of his career, John has received two Department of Commerce Bronze Medals, a Silver Medal and a Gold Medal last year for his work on the team that implemented the Image File Wrapper (IFW) electronic system.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:32 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, January 06, 2005
WAITING FOR EBAY: Any day now, the Federal Circuit is expected to post a decision on whether to uphold the May 2003 jury verdict thateBay should pay Woolston, who hold the MercExchange patents, $35 million for infringing on his patents. If the verdict, which was later reduced by a judge to $29.5 million, is upheld, Woolston may finally see a check from eBay, the San Jose company that has become synonymous with online auctions. If it's not, there could be another trial.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:17 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, January 05, 2005
TOP IP ISSUES FOR 2005: The law firm of Wolf, Greenfield & Sacks, P.C. weighs in on the top IP issues coming for 2005:
- Supreme Court to rule Grokster music file-sharing case. The high court will reconsider the 9th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals' ruling that Grokster, a file-sharing network, is not responsible for copyright infringement by its users.
- More conflict between intellectual property law and antitrust law. Antitrust law promotes open competition while IP law restricts it by giving owners of IP exclusive rights. Has the pendulum swung too far toward the IP side?
- Fewer but higher-quality patents because of higher filing fees.
- Phillips v. AWH case on standards for patent claim interpretation. The 1st Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals (CAFC), the nation's top patent court, will decide on Phillips v. AWH, which will clarify the interpretation of patent claims -- and possibly lead to more restrictive interpretations.
- Fallout from Knorr-Bremse decision on willful patent infringement.
- Decision on Tiffany's trademark-infringement lawsuit against eBay. Tiffany & Company last year sued eBay, claiming the Internet site infringes on its trademarks by allowing users to sell fake Tiffany jewelry and "actively encourages the sale of counterfeit merchandise."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:16 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
EPO LAUNCHES NEW SERVICE FOR PATENT INFORMATION: The European Patent Office has launched a 'one-stop-shop' for access to information on patents. Register Plus provides bibliographical, procedural, legal and file information on patents, and thus puts patent details in the public domain. The service is free of charge and open to anyone. Users are able, for example, to follow the patent application process for a particular submission, and to find information on other patent applications belonging to the same patent family.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:11 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, January 04, 2005
TIPS FOR CORPORATE COUNSEL (AND FOR FIRMS THAT SERVICE THEM): The Legal Technology section of Law.com has some useful tips for counselors to improve work product and efficiency for the upcoming year. The corporate landscape is littered with the remnants of companies (including law firms) that failed to see the future and seize opportunities. And unless one wants to join the other fossils, it's may be time to change how things get done. The tips include:
1. Commoditize routine legal transactions. Companies are now using assembly tools to help staff create standard nondisclosure agreements, employment offer letters, leases, etc. Couple that with an electronic signature to make the transaction paperless, add a contract management system that properly stores documents for recordkeeping -- and you've eliminated 90 percent of a legal professional's time to create the document.
2. Create consortia to share needed work. Acting alone, many companies' legal departments have built reputations for driving change. What if companies combined their experience and creativity? Only imagination limits the new technologies that would evolve, delivering best practices better, faster, cheaper and deeper than ever before.
3. Move your legal work to low cost firms located in the Midwest, South or other regions away from high cost centers.
4. Bundle work for leverage. A solid request for proposal (RFP) process can achieve incredible results. If you combine your buying power by bundling all of your legal work into one bid, i.e., all real estate work in the U.S., or all legal work in all practice areas for a particular country, legal departments can improve the quality of work they get from outside counsel, and decrease costs.
5. Use technology, not lawyers, to perform legal work. Like e-learning and self-service document creation, technology can process routine, commodity legal work for which firms charge clients on a time basis.
6. Create competition by always bidding your legal work. Competition improves product quality and reduces prices. General counsel issuing RFPs should require briefings on available law firm technology before awarding bids. Some firms and companies now use online "reverse auctions" as one way to leverage technology in the RFP process.
7. Set milestones for law firms and give rewards for exceeding goals (or penalties for missing the mark).
8. Move 80 percent of your fees to a non-billable hour basis. Hourly rates hinder progress -- there's no incentive for firms to improve productivity if they make more money by billing more hours. In-house counsel must demand fixed prices for work; firms must learn that a fixed price is not based solely on time.
9. Mercilessly measure the success of the technology and process changes based on productivity and efficiency.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:30 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, January 03, 2005
ONE TO WATCH: DATATREASURY CORP. - This holding company has decided to go strong with their patent portfolio, and has started suing big names in the finance industry.
These lawsuits are becoming more common, with the targets being banks or others in financial services (for example, see Trading Technologies and the turmoil their patent are causing). The company, the DataTreasury Corp. of Melville, N.Y., has sued companies that it says have infringed on its two patents, which describe a way to store and retrieve transaction records electronically. Generally speaking, this is already the way that credit card transactions are processed and, increasingly, the way that paper checks are handled, too.
Among the dozen or so companies that DataTreasury has sued are JP Morgan Chase & Co., one of the biggest banks; the First Data Corp., the biggest credit card processor; and the Electronic Data Systems Corp., another big processor.
The suits are wending their ways through courts in Texas that lawyers say are well known for upholding the rights of patent holders (Marshall Texas, perhaps?). They seek unspecified damages, and to ban the companies from using the processing architecture that the patents describe.
This type of litigation is unusual for financial services, which have taken for granted that there are certain basic ways to process payments. Although banks did not bother to patent these systems, others did, especially after a 1998 court ruling broadened the definition of a patent to include business methods and processes. At the time, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office was swamped with technology-related applications, and knew very little about the processing of payments.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:09 AM 2 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
LG TO MATSUSHITA: HAPPY NEW YEAR! LG Electronics Inc, South Korea's second-largest consumer electronics manufacturer, filed another patent infringement suit against the South Korea unit of Japan's Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. over plasma screen technologies, LG said.
The second lawsuit against Panasonic Korea, filed with a Seoul district court, accuses the Japanese company of infringing four plasma display panel (PDP) patents related to the structure of electrodes and panel-operating technologies.
"Panasonic Korea should scrap finished and semi-finished PDPs that infringe on LG Electronics' patent rights," the Korean company said in a court statement.
The suit is the latest development in an escalating dispute between LG Electronics and Matsushita over PDP technologies.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:03 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, December 30, 2004
HAPPY NEW YEAR TO ALL! I hope everyone has a safe and happy new year. Personally, I have no idea what i'll be doing yet, and frankly, I've been extremely lazy in planning for anything this holiday season. Maybe a good, lazy weekend will be just what the doctor ordered . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:53 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
IF YOU THOUGHT FEE DIVERSION WAS ONLY A USPTO PROBLEM . . . On Dec. 20, a letter was sent to the Director General of the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) by thirteen companies that are significant users of the Patent Cooperation Treaty. The companies expressed concern about a proposal made in September to increase PCT fees and noted that up to 80 percent of PCT fees are being used to subsidize programs at the World Intellectual Property Organization that "may not be in the interests of patent owners."
They are, of course, absolutely correct. What I found most troubling is that, unlike the United States USPTO and GAO, WIPO doesn't even have a mission statement with regard to the fees, and also has virtually no transparency for users to determine where these fees are going. I'd be very interested to learn what some of these WIPO side projects are. Unbelievable.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:42 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
PATENT ATTORNEYS - TOUGHER THAN YOU THINK: (Chicago Tribune) Greg Raymer, the 2004 World Series of Poker champion, apparently knows how to wield more than a stack of chips when everything is riding on it.
The soft-spoken patent attorney from Stonington, Conn., fought off a pair of attackers Dec. 20 at the Bellagio hotel-casino after he had finished playing a cash game of poker, according to a Las Vegas police report.
Raymer was returning to his room about 2 a.m. when two men approached, the report said. As he opened the door to the room, they tried to push him in. But the heavyset Raymer resisted and began struggling with the men, the report said.
As he was fighting, one of the men pulled out a gun and said: "We just want the money." But Raymer didn't give up, and yelled for security, causing the men to flee. A security officer said one of the suspects was a poker player and also recognized him from a previous incident.
Police made an arrest in the case but the report didn't identify the person. Raymer, known as the "Fossilman" in poker circles, won the WSOP Texas Hold'Em title and $5 million in cash. He beat out a field of 2,576 in May to win the prestigious event.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:31 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, December 28, 2004
THE NEXT ROCKET DOCKET: MARSHALL, TEXAS? (National Law Journal) When the Eastern District of Virginia, which once had the reputation as an IP "rocket docket," became overwhelmed with patent lawsuits several years ago, the judges advised lawyers to go somewhere else.
That "somewhere else" turned out to be the U.S. district court in a place called Marshall, Texas, about 100 miles east of Dallas.
But now Marshall may be approaching the Virginia district's experience. In the last several years, patent lawyers have flocked to Marshall, a small northeastern Texas town of 25,000, because of its speedy court process, patent-enthusiastic judges and juries considered ideal for hearing intellectual property cases. This year alone, the court has seen 59 patent cases, more than triple the total in 2003, which saw just 14 patent suits.
So what's the big legal attraction in a town whose claim to fame is an annual fire ant festival?
The judges, lawyers say. Specifically, District Judge T. John Ward, who joined the bench in 1999 and helped create what is known in legal circles as a rocket docket for patent cases. He did this by adopting rules that encourage the setting of quick trial dates and firm discovery deadlines. And where there have been discovery disputes, he has made himself available.
But more than all that, lawyers say, what may perhaps be Ward's strongest trait is that he actually likes patent cases.
"That to me is the big deal. You could have a rocket docket in Minnesota or New Jersey, but if the judges don't like patent cases, it doesn't make sense. These [Marshall] judges say they like them and they act like they like them," said attorney Daniel F. Perez of Winstead Sechrest & Minick in Dallas.
"They don't put up with any discovery disputes or any shenanigans," said Charles Baker, an intellectual property litigator with Porter & Hedges in Houston. "Some federal judges make it very well known that they don't like to hear these cases."
Baker noted that some defense attorneys are afraid to try cases there because of its pro-plaintiff reputation, which he disagrees with. He said that the rocket docket also turns off some defense lawyers who feel pressured to produce evidence quickly, leaving little time for preparation.
"People have portrayed [Marshall] as a fear factor: 'Oh, this is a terrible thing. These people are abusing the judicial system. It's unfair.' Well, I don't agree with that," Baker said. "The only advantage [for plaintiffs' lawyers] I see is that they can get them to trial quicker. But as a defense attorney, there are ways you can deal with that if you're a competent lawyer."
Baker said that Marshall's large elderly population also provides a good jury pool for intellectual property cases.
"There are a lot of old people who don't have a problem with sitting weeks at a time and listening to complicated issues," Baker said. "But in Houston, you have people who are fighting to get out of a trial."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:13 AM 1 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, December 27, 2004
WILL THEY TRASH "FIRST-TO-INVENT" IN THE U.S.? It seems that every 5 years or so, WIPO gets together to harmonize patent laws throughout the world. Not a bad idea, if you ask me, but one of the biggest sore points has been that the U.S. is the only country that uses the "first-to-invent" requirement for filing patent applications, while the rest of the world uses "first-to-file." Under a "first-to-file" system, Interference practive would vanish, and the USPTO/Courts would simply look at the filing dates to determine inventorship. Many small businesses have been resisting this change, and were primarily responsible for canning the last harmonization efforts in 1999. Well a new round of harmonization efforts are underway, and I would be shocked if WIPO doesn't revisit this topic again.
I'll keep you posted on any further details.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:40 PM 1 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
JAPAN, CHINA AND S. KOREA START TALKS ON PATENT HARMONIZATION: Not waiting for WIPO, South Korea, Japan and China are pushing to unify their industrial property rights systems by comprising industrial patents, designs and trade marks, the Nihon Keizai Shimbun said Sunday. The Japanese paper said the three countries will soon begin working-level talks to discuss unification of their patent systems, as well as ways to simplify their patent application procedures.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:38 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
PATENT FOCUS: COLORADO - Last year, at least 48,000 newly incorporated businesses were born in Colorado. But if Small Business Administration calculations are correct, only about half will survive long enough to blow out the candles on their fourth-birthday cakes.
Yet during the state's 128-year history, thousands of businesses, products and innovations have done more than just survive - they've flourished. Each day, people across the country encounter products invented or perfected in Colorado.
From hard candy to dog toys to revolutionary footwear, creative Coloradans have made imprints throughout the world. And, based on the number of new ideas sprouting up each year, there's no end in sight.
According to the U.S. Patent Office, Colorado residents - who make up 2 percent of the nation's population - filed for 7 percent of all patents in 2003; two-thirds were granted. Another recent study done by The Corporation for Enterprise Development ranks Colorado the ninth- most-innovative state in the union.
In the second installment of Colorado Originals (the first ran in June), The Denver Post showcases some of the notable products, businesses and inventions with Colorado roots.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:34 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, December 22, 2004
CHINA TAKES STEP IN CURBING IP THEFT: China promised to get tougher on copyright and patent violations, a long-awaited move that may ease U.S. concerns over rampant piracy, believed to cost foreign businesses billions of dollars every year. In a new interpretation of the law governing intellectual property rights, the country's top court lowered the bar for treating violations as crimes and laid out prison terms of up to 7 years for the worst offenders. However, Beijing's decision to release the new guidelines without giving Washington a chance to weigh in on the final package prompted a tart U.S. response.
"We received the text today. We would have liked to have looked at it before it was issued in its final state. As this is the first time that we've seen it, we need time to review it closely," said Neena Moorjani, spokeswoman for the U.S. Trade Representative's office. The interpretation, debated behind closed doors for much of the year, aims to address long-standing complaints by the United States and others that China has done little to stamp out piracy of everything from software to golf clubs.
"We should not only sentence such offenders in a determined manner, but also make it economically impossible for the criminals convicted and sentenced to commit the crime again," Cao Jianming, vice-president of the Supreme People's Court, told reporters.
Cao said the court had firmed up legal definitions of terms such as "without permission of the copyright owner" and "reproducing and distributing" to make it easier to prosecute offenders. The legal ruling also comes amid heightened awareness within China over the pitfalls of counterfeit products following a fake milk powder scandal that killed 13 babies and made nearly 200 others sick.
Moorjani said the U.S. government would soon have "a more complete reaction" to the new judicial guidelines.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:13 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
AH, THAT'S MORE LIKE IT: I was worried that the EU Parliment may actually come to its senses and push the software patent directive forward. Against all expectations, the final vote on the European software patents directive was postponed until further notice. The Polish Minister of Science and Information Technology, Wlodzimierz Marcinski, made a special journey to Brussels to demand that the directive be dropped from the agenda.
According to the FFII (Foundation for a Free Information Infrastructure), Mr Marcinski felt the trip to Brussels was neccessary because of the pressure Poland's permanent representatives were under to accept the draft as it was.
What the delay means for the directive now is uncertain. Poland's minister asked for time to prepare a "constructive declaration" on the directive. Several countries support this position, having changed their stance since the vote on the text in May. Germany has already issued a statement saying that the compromise text has "room for improvement."
It is possible that the Luxembourg presidency will take a different approach and allow more discussion of the content of the draft, but the draft could just as easily show up on the agenda of the next meeting of the Council of ministers.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:06 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Friday, December 17, 2004
ACACIA WATCH UPDATE: On Thursday, the company agreed to buy Global Patent Holdings, an umbrella company whose various divisions, including TechSearch, have sued or struck patent licenses with Intel, Sony, Samsung and a myriad of smaller technology companies.
The deal would create a patent powerhouse which would own small pieces of dozens of different technologies, many of which are fundamental components of everyday Internet and personal technology businesses. The company said more acquisitions are likely.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:01 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, December 16, 2004
TRADING TECHNOLOGIES DRAWS A LINE IN THE SAND: One of the most notorious holding companies in the Chicago area, Trading Technologies International Inc., recently demanded about $130 million a year from the four top exchanges in exchange for the company dropping its patent lawsuits.
The exchanges involved include the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and the Chicago Board of Trade. In a widely circulated "open letter to the futures industry" dated Tuesday, Trading Technologies argued that its software has encouraged the spread of futures trading, so the company should get 5 cents per contract dealt.
In return, the company would improve its products and agree to end all patent infringement suits against brokerages it believes have modified its software without paying for its continued use. The company in recent months settled suits against two trading firms -- Goldenberg, Hehmeyer & Co. and Kingstree Trading LLC -- that admitted patent infringement.
The goal of the letter was to get those firms to lobby the Merc, Board of Trade, Frankfurt-based Eurex and London-based Euronext.liffe, to agree to the payments as indemnity from the patent suits.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:08 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
WOT? Apparently the EU software directive is not as dead as recent press reports have indicated. European Union governments have recently approved rules governing the patentability of inventions implemented by computers, known as the software patents directive, standing by an agreement they reached in May.
A meeting of ambassadors to the EU yesterday evening agreed to formally endorse a deal reached by member state governments in May of this year. The decision will come as a blow to opponents of the new legislation, among them the open source software community, who argue that the rules would allow the patenting of software. For approval, the legislation must still be referred back to the European Parliament (EP), which includes many opponents of the legislation.
If members of the European Parliament (MEPs) reject the EU governments' agreement, the two sides have to find a compromise, which may end up being closer to the open source software lobby's position.
Poland recently declared that they were opposed to patenting software. But this time, Poland merely issued a declaration saying that it had some "concerns" with the compromise. The declaration fell short of saying that Warsaw would block the proposal at a later date, according to a Dutch Presidency spokesman. Poland is understood to have come under severe political pressure not to undermine the proposal at this stage.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 7:01 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
MICROSOFT AND AUTODESK COZY UP: As part of its plan to gain access to a broader portfolio of intellectual property, Microsoft has signed a patent swap deal with design software maker Autodesk.
Under the pact, the two companies will gain access to each other's patents in a variety of areas, including data management, collaboration, digital effects, digital rights management, project management, computer-aided design and location-based services.
Microsoft has been stepping up its activity on the patent front, ramping up its own filings and at the same time trying to ink cross-license deals with other tech companies. Microsoft has been using the combined power as a marketing vehicle against Linux, noting that it indemnifies its customers against potential patent infringement claims.
Neither company would discuss financial details of the cross-licensing arrangement, including whether any money changed hands. Kaefer has said that Microsoft currently spent about $1.4 billion last year on patent licensing, but noted the company has an opportunity to narrow those losses by more aggressively licensing its own portfolio.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 6:57 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, December 15, 2004
ALL ACACIA, ALL THE TIME: I'm not sure how long this has been out there (and it seems that it has been a while), but streamingmedia.com has a web page completely devoted to Acacia and all of it's activities over the years. After browsing through it, it seems that they have quite a bit of information, including court filings, press releases, etc. The page is good to link if you have received one of Acacia’s letters or are afraid you may receive one.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:53 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
THE DAY AFTER: After the Federal Circuit essentially upheld-in-part NTP's patent infringement suit against RIM, RIM's stock price dropped 5 per cent. Ah, the power of patents . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
COMMENTS ON OPEN-SOURCE IP: Microsoft recently made public statements that some say are an attempt to slow the rapid adoption ofOS software. For example, Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer recently commented that the Linux operating system violates 228 separate software patents, suggesting that Linux users are likely to get sued for patent infringement. No specific patents were identified.
This commentary states that it is no surprise that the company with the most to lose by the adoption of OS would try to slow its adoption. A 2004 Forester survey of 140 large North American companies revealed that 46% of these companies already are using OS software and another 14% plan to do so soon. With 60% of the large North American companies allegedly using OS software, the theory goes that Microsoft is keen on putting a hex on users and developers that are migrating to OS systems
"Between Microsoft's posturing and the latest guidance from the FFIEC, itis clear that companies migrating to Open Source need to tread carefully,"said JamesGatto, an intellectual property partner in the Northern Virginia office ofPillsbury Winthrop. "However, there are a number of strategies and tactics that can mitigate potential liability." Gatto noted that some unique legal issues arise with OS software but that there are unique benefits as well.
The suggestion that users of OS softwareare more likely to be sued for patent infringement than those that useproprietary software, like Microsoft's does not appear supported by actual experience. It is interesting to note that while Microsoft has had several dozen patent infringement lawsuits filed against it in the past few years, none have been reported against Linux, the most popular of all OS programs.
It is also not correct that OS software can not be patented. Many companies that are involved with OS have significant patent portfolios and have declared that they will use these patents defensively to protect against patent lawsuits. For example, in October, Novell vowed to use its patent portfolio to protect open source software products and voiced its oppositionto proposed changes to the European Union software directive that would ease restrictions on software patents. Jeremy Bevan, a Novell VP, added, "there have been various rumors about the possibility of patents in open source technology and what will happen," saying that the company wanted to reassure its customers that "there's no greater risk" with open source than with proprietary technology.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:34 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, December 14, 2004
HERE'S AN INTERESTING RUB: (Reuters) Computer software should not be protected by copyright laws designed for music, literature and other creative works, according to a lawsuit filed in a U.S. court in San Francisco.
Intellectual-property consultant Greg Aharonian hopes to convince the court that software makers can protect their products adequately through patents, which provide more comprehensive protection, but are difficult to obtain and expire in a shorter period of time.
The case seeks to clarify which laws the $100 billion U.S. software industry uses to protect its products. Currently, software makers like Microsoft Corp. use both copyright and patent laws to protect their creations, as well as "clickwrap" agreements that stipulate terms of use.
An official with a software-industry trade group said not every software product is protected by patents.
"If you eliminated the ability to sue somebody for copyright infringement, you would eviscerate our ability to go against pirates," said Emory Simon, counselor for the Business Software Alliance, which estimates that U.S. businesses lost $6.5 billion last year to piracy.
Aharonian argues in his complaint that software copyright laws violate the right to due process enshrined in the U.S. Constitution because they do not provide clear boundaries for appropriate use. That means industry players and courts do not have a clear idea of the rules.
"Until you're sued and a judge makes up his mind about what is the idea and expression (at stake), no one knows," Aharonian said in an interview.
- A longshot for sure, but it raises some valid points. And I bet this is going to get the EU "free software" crowd convulsing over the prospect of having a "patent-only" system in the U.S.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:15 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
GOOGLE FILES PATENT ON A PAY MODEL FOR SEARCHING CONTENT: This article summarizes the analysis from Susan Kuchinskas at InternetNews on a patent filing by Larry Page (co-founder of Google). The patent application , 20040122811, titled "Method for searching media" was originally filed in September 2003 and its core function is summarised by Susan,
to enable search of printed material, offer pay-per-view documents, scanned documents with clickable ads and even the ability for print publishers to swap out ads in digital copies of their printed pages. There are two key elements of the patent: a method for executing a permission protocol so that the publisher could authorize Google to display more text from the relevant publication; and storing scanned versions of printed documents along with data sets representing the ads that went with them.
It's not just online text that is covered. CDs, DVDs, audio books, hard copy magazines, newspapers and journals could all be included. Susan continues with the analysis:
The patent claims a method for updating advertisement information for the printed documents. For example, it would allow the publisher of a hot news story to resell the ad space to a rotating series of advertisers or let advertisers keep the ad but update prices and product information. One of the claims, covers storing information about products in the ads. This might allow the advertiser to create a special landing page associated with the ad, working like a Web banner ad.
Pretty interesting stuff indeed.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:06 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
OLIVE BRANCH BETWEEN JAPAN AND KOREA? Sony Corp. and Samsung Electronics announced that they had agreed to share patents on basic technology to speed up product development and avoid adding to a growing number of cross-border patent disputes.
The cross-licensing deal allows the Japanese and South Korean electronics giants to tap each other's vast patent portfolios on basic technologies. However, it will exclude key technologies that help differentiate their products, such as those related to Sony's hit PlayStation game consoles.
The move follows a string of legal actions between Japanese and South Korean electronics makers over alleged patent infringements.
"With this agreement with Samsung, we aim to keep clear of unnecessary conflicts and compete only in those areas where we really need to compete," Sony Executive Vice President Yoshihide Nakamura told reporters.
- This is pretty big - being that Japanese companies tend to act in concert regarding corporate and IP policies (emphasis on "tend"), it may be only a matter of time before Matsushita and Toshiba settle their disputes between them and LG Electronics . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:59 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, December 13, 2004
BACK FROM GERMANY: I just returned from Germany today, where I spoke to clients and law firms about the American experience with software patents. Unfortunately, I get the feeling that the EU Parliment is going to botch this one up, as the people there told me that Parliment is deathly afraid of crossing the small software company owners (who also happen to run Linux and other open-source products). As a result, it is going to be a while before the EU makes a decision on this, and in any case, they are likely to restrict the types of software that can be patented. I think this is bad policy for Europe and it will likely result in a larger gap between US and EU technological innovations.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:37 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
A GOOD LESSON: The Seattle Times does an article on Harry Rasmussen, who founded the company Crest Industries, which manufactured telephone products during the 1970'2-80's. The story is sad mostly because Rasmussen took what he thought was a good business idea, obtained patents on his technology, and started changing the telephone industry in the 1980's.
Unfortunately, Crest's patent portfolio turned out to be much weaker than he expected (apparently due to poor drafting), and a change in the business climate had his company falling prey to cheap Asian knock-offs. Because law firms were not open to alternate fee arrangements for litigation, his company could not afford to defend it's patent portfolio against these copies being flooded onto the US market. As a result, the company went under.
Undaunted, Rasmussen is now working on encryption technologies, and is hoping to make a comeback. However, I would bet that he is going to be a little more vigilant in obtaining patent protection on his inventions, and perhaps may think twice before abstaining from enforcing his patent rights. Best of luck.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:23 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
PRIMER ON PROTECTIVE ORDERS: One of the often-disputed topics that arise during patent litigation stem from protective orders and their proper scope. Michael Rader provides a concise breakdown of some of the considerations that in-house counsel need to make when considering a protective order. Some of these considerations include:
- Does the opposing party have in-house patent counsel? Many protective orders allow for access to confidential information by a single in-house attorney. If the opposing party's legal department does not include a patent attorney, this may mitigate patent-related risk in some cases.
- How extensive is the opposing party's portfolio of pending patent applications? If the opposing party does not have pending applications directly covering the relevant technology, the risk of patent claims being crafted to ensnare the company's new products is mitigated. Information about the opposing party's patent portfolio can be gleaned from publicly available sources or requested during negotiations over the protective order.
- How much of the company's confidential information would, in fact, aid the opposing party's patent prosecution efforts? For example, if the company's products are readily reverse-engineered, access to confidential technical specifications may do little for the opposing party's patent attorneys.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:09 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Sunday, December 05, 2004
OFF TO GERMANY: I'm taking a trip to Germany this week and will be spotty at best in posting blog entries. I may be able to slip in a post or two over the next week, but the best bet is to check next week for new posts.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:29 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, December 02, 2004
DEAR GOD . . . The software patent ambitions of Acacia Research are well-known to the streaming media industry. Acacia initially targeted Web pornographers, shutting down sites that neglected to pay its licensing fees, but since then has exacted license fees from a broad array of cable, satellite and Web content companies that now number 264 and include Walt Disney.
Acacia's latest target centers on its patent describing how wireless networks present unidentified computer users with Web pages that redirect them to log-in or subscription pages. Hotels, airports and other areas with Wi-Fi hot spots typically use such redirection schemes.
Acacia's patent, No. 6,226,677, was originally granted in May 2001 to LodgeNet Entertainment, a Sioux Falls, S.D., information technology company targeting hotels. Acacia purchased the patent in July.
Berman said Acacia launched its Wi-Fi licensing campaign in September and is in advanced licensing discussions with a number of potential licensees. No Wi-Fi licenses have been signed yet.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 11:49 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
ADVANTAGE: SCHICK - In a mega-litigation action between the #1 and #2 razor makers, a German court ruled today that Energizer Holdings Inc.'s four-bladed Quattro razor does not infringe Gillette Co.'s European patent on three-bladed progressive exposure.
Energizer, which purchased razor maker Schick Wilkinson Sword last year, said the German court ordered Gillette to reimburse Energizer's court costs, but it does not yet know what the reimbursement amount would be.
Gillette said it disagreed with the German Patent Trial Court's decision. The company plans to appeal and continue related litigation that includes additional claims.
The U.S. litigation is still ongoing, but Judge Patti Saris of the U.S. District Court of Massachusetts in January rejected a bid to halt Quattro sales on grounds the device infringes on the patent for Gillette's three-bladed Mach3 razor.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 11:44 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, December 01, 2004
PatnetCafe Introduces IPFront Line: PatentCafe, publisher of global patent data, enterprise patent research software and invention resources, has introduced IPFrontline™ Intellectual Property and Technology Magazine. IPFrontline is claimed as the first online publication to feature patent industry reports covering 14 key industry segments, as well as the 200 most active companies receiving patents.
The patent activity reports are designed to help venture capitalists, industry analysts, fund managers, business investment advisors and other technology investors keep current on the latest U.S patent trends. The IPFrontline focus is on news, trends, technologies, laws, policy and issues related to the discovery, commercial exploitation and protection of invention.
The real-time patent charts online track patent trends of 14 key industry segments, as well as patent performance of the Top 200 companies and patent law firms. Andy Gibbs, PatentCafe’s CEO notes that “intellectual property accounts for more than 70 percent of the market cap of the Fortune 500, and nearly 90% of NASDAQ-listed companies. Whether investing in a Fortnue 100 companies, or early stage technology start ups, the understanding of patent trends of companies and industries is vital to intelligent decision-making.”
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:52 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
ANOTHER GOOD REASON TO DO DUE DILLIGENCE: Once touted as revolutionary for its ability to compress and send DVD-quality video down a phone line at high speed, Adam Clark's technology is under dispute by the company he sold it to for $16 million.
Media World Communications was billed as "the next Microsoft" [editor's note: "Bwaa-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha!"] when it formed in 2002 mainly to develop and commercialise Adams Platform Technology (APT), with Mr Adams becoming a director. Since then the 29-year-old - who started his first audio-visual and events management business while still at school - has debuted on BRW Magazine's Young Rich list with a personal fortune said to be $25 million.
But after serious doubts about APT surfaced in September, Media World Communications went into administration.
Analysis by accountants PricewaterhouseCoopers found the compression technology was already available and the encoding performed by APT was actually from commercially available hardware and software disguised to make it appear as APT.
Video coding and compression expert Tim Ferguson found "many" technical flaws in the US patent filed relating to APT, and that APT would not perform as well as a modern compression method.
Mr Clark and his lawyers Baker & McKenzie did not return calls yesterday.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:35 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
PATENT SYSTEM AT RISK? Herb Wamsley from the IPO writes an article in CNET claiming that the budgetary problems at the USPTO (read: fee-diversion) is placing the patent system at risk:
The problem is that our current patent approval system is underfunded and overburdened. That means nothing but trouble for American technology-basedTo be honest, there is nothing new in this viewpoint, as practitioners have been screaming bloody murder over the last 10 years over fee diversion. But I am constantly baffled why groups like the IPO and AIPLA don't make political hay out of this. I mean, does anyone really know the names of representatives and/or senators that continuously retain the fee-diversion provisions? Have they been threatened politically in any way? It should come as no surprise that politicians respond best when a block of people unequivocally say "Do X, or we will do everything in our power to see that you don't get (re-) elected". The IPO and the AIPLA have been making nice for too long. I say they name names and start leaving some horse heads in the bedrooms of certain representatives.
companies, entrepreneurs and the American economy.
The lack of resources for the United States Patent and Trademark Office
is particularly troublesome for the nation's computing and advanced technology
industry. Absent the assurance and incentives provided by a strong patent, few
companies will invest in next-generation technologies. And absent investment,
there will be less innovation and job creation in the U.S. tech sector.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 1:09 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, November 30, 2004
UK PUTS THE KAIBOSH ON BUSINESS-METHOD PATENTS: The UK Patent Office is taking a new approach to dealing with the increasing number of applications for business method patents, which cannot be patented in the UK, to short-circuit the usual lengthy exchange of correspondence. European patent offices, including the UK Patent Office, tend to reject such applications. A “technical contribution” or “technical aspect” is required before patentability can be considered.
Notwithstanding, applications are flooding in. So in an effort to deal with them in an efficient and cost effective manner, the UK Patent Office has decided to make two changes in cases where the examiner thinks that the invention is “inherently unpatentable.”
Firstly, says the Patent Office, a hearing will be set as soon as the applicant has responded to the initial examination report issued by the Office. At this hearing the Hearing Officer will make a ruling on the patentability of the invention.
Secondly, the Hearing Officer will no longer be required to issue detailed reasons for his ruling but can issue an abbreviated decision, referring back to similar cases.
The practice paper can be viewed here.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:49 PM 1 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
AMAZON.COM LITIGATION BEGINS NEXT WEEK: In a "battle royale" from some local heavyweights, Pinpoint Incorporated's patent infringement suit against Amazon.com is set for trial next week beginning December 6th in Chicago. The Honorable Judge Richard A. Posner of the 7th Circuit, U.S. Court of Appeals will be sitting by designation as the district judge presiding over the jury trial. Pinpoint alleges Amazon.com's personalization technology and its product recommendations infringe Pinpoint's U.S. Patents Nos. 5,758,257 and 6,088,722. Pinpoint is represented by Phil Beck and Peter Bensinger, Jr. of Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP in Chicago. Mr. Beck represented President George W. Bush in the 2000 election contest litigation in Florida and also represented the U.S. Government in its antitrust case against Microsoft. Mr. Bensinger is nationally known for his use of legal technology and American Lawyer magazine has dubbed him "the most wired lawyer in America."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:58 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
(FINALLY!) - After Linus Torvald's diatribe against software patents, a UK law firm comes out in support of software patents and accuses Torvald of fear-mongering. Specifically, John Collins, a partner at UK firm Marks and Clerk said: "Torvalds and his supporters lack a fundamental understanding of intellectual property rights as they seem to be unaware that copyright can only protect software code and not software".
He claims that open source developers and the Polish government are misinforming the IT industry and "serving only to endanger genuine inventions".
He said: “Linus Torvalds (creator of Linux) has recently made a statement claiming that the Directive would broaden the area in which patents would be granted. This is simply a false assumption. The original proposal was solely designed to clarify and unify existing practice in the EU. However the current version – as a result of amendments made by the European Parliament – will result in patent holders in certain areas losing a significant element of protection meaning that some existing patents will become worthless.”
- While I agree with Mr. Collins, I think there should be more people in the EU speaking out against the anti-software crowd. When you read some of the garbage they write about software patents, you wonder what planet they are living on . . .
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:44 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, November 29, 2004
AND THE BEAT GOES ON: Acacia Research Corporation announced today that its Acacia Technologies group has entered into 64 new licensing agreements for its Digital Media Transmission (DMT(R)) technology since announcing its 200th license on November 8, 2004. Sixty of the new licenses are with cable TV companies. In addition to the cable TV licenses, Acacia has now entered into 175 licenses for online entertainment, movies, music, news and sports, as well as e-learning and corporate websites. Acacia has also licensed the leading companies that provide over 90% of video-on-demand TV entertainment for the hotel industry in the United States.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:31 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
SOUTH KOREA'S LG ELECTRONICS STRIKES BACK: South Korea on Monday slapped a temporary ban on the import and sale of plasma display panels made by Japan's Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. Ltd., officials said. The latest measure came after South Korea's LG Electronics Inc. asked authorities earlier this month to investigate Panasonic Korea Ltd., Matsushita's sales company in South Korea, for alleged patent violations. Matsushita, meanwhile, had earlier asked a Tokyo court to halt sales in Japan of the South Korean company's plasma display panels also because of alleged patent violations. The dispute underlines the growing competition in the electronics industry between older Japanese companies and up-and-coming South Korean makers.
- This has to be one of the ugliest patent disputes in recent years. Both companies have been involving their respective governments in tweaking the other side, and some of the comments made by politicos suggest that there are racial undertones to this matter. It will be interesting to see if either side backs off. If not, this is going to be a whopper.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:20 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
USPTO GETS READY TO SPEND-SPEND-SPEND! Buoyed by the promise of $200 million in new revenue, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office says it will hire 900 new patent examiners to speed up the processing of patent applications. The funding was included in the $388 billion Omnibus Spending Bill approved by Congress this week. The new funding isn't really new revenue. But since 1992, Congress has diverted much of the money raised by fees the Patent Office charges companies applying for patents to pay for unrelated programs. The budget bill allows the Patent Office to keep its fee revenue through the end of the fiscal year ending with the 2006 budget, a compromise with Congress. Next year, the Patent Office and its technology allies will press to end the diversion of funds permanently.
The Patent Office has already begun posted job openings on its Web site (www.uspto.gov). It is looking for college graduates with at least a four-year degree, preferably in engineering. Salaries range from $24,075 to $57,375.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:02 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
AMPEX SETTLES WITH SONY: Ampex Corporation, which is essentially a patent holding company, today announced that it has reached a settlement with Sony Corporation whereby Ampex will withdraw the patent litigation it initiated in July 2004 in the International Trade Commission (ITC) and in the Federal District Court for the District of Delaware relating to digital still cameras manufactured and sold by Sony.
Under the terms of the settlement, Sony will be licensed under several Ampex patents to manufacture and sell various products, including digital video tape recorders and digital still cameras. In return for a payment of $40.0 million, Sony will be permitted to use Ampex patents in any of its products for the period through April 2006. After that time, the licenses provide for running royalties based on sales of products including digital video tape recorders and digital still cameras to the extent that they utilize Ampex patents. The licenses provide that their terms are confidential.
- It looks like Ampex hit Sony where it hurt. With the dual district court/ITC lawsuit, Sony was looking at some potentially devastating losses from (a) not being able to import digital cameras if Ampex was successful in the ITC (where cases can have judgments rendered within 16 months of the the filing of the complaint); (b) facing potentially huge damages in the infringement action; and (c) at best, spending millions in legal fees defending both actions.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:48 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Wednesday, November 24, 2004
UPDATE: IRAQ - No, it's not what you think. However, it never occurred to me that part of reforming Iraq and Iraq's laws would include modifications to it's patent law regime. Recent orders from the provisional government has already started parblems with Iraqi farmers, claiming that plant variety protection will harm the local farmers.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 2:28 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
COMMERCE ONE AUCTION UPDATE: Seems that companies are starting to pool resources to buy out 39 patents held by Commerce One, a bankrupt software company in Santa Clara, Calif., that's in the process of shutting down and liquidating its assets. The patents cover technical protocols that underlie popular methods for exchanging business documents over the Internet.
The upcoming auction has some big Silicon Valley companies on edge. Among them are Google, Oracle and Sun Microsystems. Attorneys for those and more than a dozen other companies held a powwow this week to discuss the patent sale and the danger of becoming targets of infringement suits by whomever acquires them.
They also discussed pooling their funds and jointly bidding in the Dec. 6 auction. A nonprofit group called CommerceNet, which organized the meeting, offered to collect contributions and manage the bidding. If the joint bid won, CommerceNet would essentially retire the patents. If it lost, CommerceNet would refund each contributor.
"It's a little bit like paying the blackmailer before they have something to blackmail you about," said Craig Smith, CommerceNet's chief financial officer and chief operating officer.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 2:04 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Tuesday, November 23, 2004
WHAT'S IN *YOUR* DOCKET? IP Law & Business recently conducted a Technology Survey , where the 50 largest patent firms, ranked by number of registered patent attorneys, were asked what docketing software and annuity software they use.
Most firms use both: docketing software to manage prosecution of pending patents and trademarks, and annuity software to manage payments of maintenance fees and taxes on existing patents. Docketing and annuity software developed along separate lines, and historically firms used separate software programs to manage each task. Recently, however, most of the major vendors have started offering linked systems, and many firms are slowly starting to adopt them.
The survey also asked firms what kinds of tools--Web sites, databases, and the like--they use when conducting prior art searches for patent and trademark applications. 38 firms responded to the survey.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:30 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
DELAYS, DELAYS, NOTHING BUT DELAYS: European Union governments have delayed voting on a proposed law that would define which technological innovations can be patented, after Poland said it was considering withdrawing its support.
The proposed law was endorsed by government leaders this month as an important legislative priority for the sluggish European economy to make it more competitive with the American economy. But an agreement reached in May by the European Union's 25 members now appears to be unwinding because of Poland's possible switch.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 10:18 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Monday, November 22, 2004
OFFENSIVE INNOVATION - MAKING YOUR R&D MATTER: Carleen Hawn writes a great piece on how established companies may be disadvantaged in the market when it comes to producing innovative technologies. Carleen particularly takes Microsoft to task for arguably being too timid in its R&D:
The failure to consistently produce dramatic and successful innovations may be less a comment on Microsoft than it is on the nature of innovation. Innovation is capricious - a function of luck and good timing as much as brains. It's tough to score once, much less repeatedly. Harder still to feed and mine creativity in established organisations, where scale becomes the enemy. It's more difficult for a $US37 billion business to find and commercialise inventions that will sustain profitable growth at the same rate as in smaller rivals.
Microsoft may be the most striking example of the phenomenon that Harvard academic Clayton Christensen identified in his 1997 book, The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail. Good managers, Christensen wrote, tend to direct resources toward protecting established lines of business, usually by investing in incremental improvements that help pad profit margins.
Christensen called these "sustaining innovations"; defensive tactics. It's not that Microsoft lacks creative talent or that it simply has run out of ideas - it has an abundance of both. But for most of the past 25 years, it has overwhelmingly devoted these vast resources to the innovative defence of its existing franchises. That's why it has missed opportunities to launch important new businesses. And why it will miss many more.
And the investment world has a different take on "innovation" than the technical world has. While Microsoft may keep shareholders happy by entrenching existing technologies, establishing new innovative technologies may provide more risk than reward in terms of Microsoft's bottom line:
[I]nnovation experts argue Microsoft isn't investing enough in offensive innovation to define its future. And the research it does seems wildly inefficient. Over the past five years, Microsoft spent an average of $US9 million per patent, nearly twice its peer group.
Ultimately, observes Gary Hamel, innovation guru and chairman of Strategos, "really good ideas are just few and far between".
Venture capitalists typically pore over 50 to 100 deals to find a good $20-million software investment. By that logic, Microsoft, with its $6.8-billion annual R&D budget, must consider as many as 35,000 new ideas just to find a few hundred worth investing in every year. There just might not be enough opportunities out there for Microsoft to employ its vast resources effectively."Microsoft has to create the third- or fourth-largest software company in the world every year to be considered innovative," says Brian Skiba, managing director of the San Francisco-based hedge fund Viant Group. Even if Microsoft had been able to replicate Google's dominance in search technology, Google's $US1.5 billion in revenue would have lifted Microsoft's own top line by just 4 per cent.
But so long as Microsoft enjoys its dual annuities from Windows and Office, it needn't worry much about the revenue generated by its research.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:06 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
BAH! The long-running battle to reserve the money raised from patent fees exclusively for use by the Patent and Trademark Office is unlikely to be resolved in the 108th Congress.
Lawmakers refused to block the diversion of such fees as part of the omnibus appropriations bill for fiscal 2005 cleared over the weekend.
They did provide PTO a funding boost and specifically allocated funding to hire more patent and trademark examiners. But the technology lobbying community, which worked hard to stop fee diversions this year, is split on whether the larger budget will benefit technology companies as long as PTO still could lose money from patent fees to unrelated programs.
Under the omnibus appropriations bill, PTO would receive up to $1.6 billion, or $342 million more than in fiscal 2004. The measure also would let PTO raise its fees between 15 percent and 25 percent over the next two years to fund its operations.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 4:06 PM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
Thursday, November 18, 2004
"STAND AND DELIVER!": A broad coalition of intellectual property and business associations made a last-ditch attempt Wednesday to persuade appropriations negotiators to adopt language from a House bill concerning user fees for the Patent and Trademark Office (PTO).
If the lawmakers cannot agree to the language that would allow the PTO to keep all of the fees generated by its work, the coalition said in a letter to the leaders of the House Appropriations Committee, they should drop language that would increase user fees for patent applications.
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 9:01 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
MEET "MR. PATENT": Marvin Johnson can't seem to stop innovating. The plainspoken scientist from Phillips Petroleum has 212 patents to his name. Johnson, a 74-year-old research fellow with Phillips Petroleum, stopped keeping track of his patents a long time ago. That's because he has 212 of them to his name, with at least 8 more on the way.
Do the math: a 46-year career and 220 patents either issued or pending. That's more than one patent every three months for more than four decades. How does Johnson evaluate his remarkable performance? He starts with a wisecrack: "It's the same in patents as it is in having a baby. Conception is the best part of it."
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:51 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
EU SOFTWARE PATENT INITIATIVE LOOKS DEAD: The Polish government has said it will not support a controversial European directive, delivering a potential blow to attempts to make software patentable in Europe.
The Polish government said Tuesday that it could not support the proposed Patentability of Computer-Implemented Inventions that was agreed on by the EU Council earlier this year.
"Because of numerous ambiguity and contradictions respecting the current directive project, Poland cannot support the text which was accepted in the vote of the Council on May 18, 2004," the Polish government said in a statement.
It added that it would be prepared to back a directive that made it clear that "computer-implemented inventions" would be patentable, but that computer programs would not be.
Without the backing of the Polish government, it is likely that the directive no longer has enough support to be sent back from the Council to the EU Parliament. Crucially, the EU has just revised the number of votes that each member state can wield, and this move has given Poland enough influence to tip the balance.
(Thanks to James Goedken for the article)
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:46 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
GAMING INDUSTRY BECOMING LARGER TARGET: While computer game fans shell out tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars for the latest shoot-em-up release, a little-known patent holder is hoping to make a different kind of computer game killing.
American Video Graphics (AVG), a Marshall, Texas, limited partnership, has wielded its arsenal of seven patents related to the display of 3D computer graphics to sue a who's who of companies in the computer game industry.
Defendants in the three suits, filed Aug. 23 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern Division of Texas, Tyler Division, range from game makers (Nintendo, Sega, Atari and Activision) to entertainment companies (LucasArts and Vivendi) to hardware vendors (Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Dell and Gateway) to consumer electronics companies (Sony, Fujitsu, JVC, Sharp, Matsushita and Toshiba).
Many of the complaints stem from those companies' distribution of Microsoft's 3D software with the Windows operating system. Microsoft also is named in the complaint, specifically for its Xbox computer game system.
(J. Goedken)
Posted by Two-Seventy-One Patent Blog at 8:39 AM 0 comments
Artigos Relacionados:
