Tuesday, March 22, 2005

WHEN GREAT IDEAS ARE SIMPLY NOT ENOUGH: The tech industry is famous for billion-dollar ideas. But the rewards don't always to go to the inventor. This article from ZDNet gives some examples why some of the most important technologies of the past 50 years -- the transistor, the relational database and the microprocessor -- weren't the slam dunks for their creators that many people might have thought.

Some inventors lost their lead through a lack of insight. Corporate politics sometimes plays a role. More often, the delay of payback is simply the result of poor timing--a reasonable strategy at the wrong time. Take the microdrive at the heart of many of today's MP3 players, for instance. It was invented long before the world was ready for something like the iPod.

Other notable examples of inventions gone wrong and opportunities missed:

  • The transistor - In 1947, scientists at AT&T's Bell Labs created the world's first silicon transistor. Three of its scientists would later win the Nobel Prize in physics for the invention. Bell Labs obtained a patent for the device, but the invention was licensed to, among others, IBM, Texas Instruments and the forerunner of Sony. The goal was to avoid antitrust problems with the U.S. government. (In a 1956 consent decree, AT&T agreed to license the transistor freely.)
  • Xerox PARC - Xerox has been flayed mercilessly for allowing concepts such as the desktop PC, Ethernet networking, the laser printer and the mouse--all invented at its famed Palo Alto Research Center, or PARC--to get exploited by others. The photocopier giant is now trying to stay afloat in a world going paperless. Still, PARC did help launch the careers of a number of people: James Clark, Alan Kay, Robert Metcalf and Lawrence Tesler, among others.
  • DOS - Microsoft got into operating systems by chance, but this story starts with IBM. For its first PC, IBM initially considered using the C/PM system from Digital Research. Because Digital Research wouldn't sign a nondisclosure agreeent, IBM asked Microsoft, then developing applications for IBM, for MS-DOS. MS-DOS, however, was actually based on QDOS, an operating system created by Tim Paterson of Seattle Computer Products. Microsoft bought QDOS from SCP (which didn't know about the IBM deal) for $50,000.
  • Relational Database Software - young IBM engineer named Edgar Codd defined the concept and structure of the relational database back in the '60s and '70s. Codd's revolutionary idea was to organize data into tables of rows and columns, and to relate that data to other tables. His work produced the blueprint for how to build a relational database, as well as the foundation for what would become SQL, or Structured Query Language, a standard way to access data. At the time, however, the technology didn't mesh with IBM's corporate strategy. The company was heavily invested in an older database model. The result: IBM didn't market a product based on Codd's ideas until 1978--one year after a young entrepreneur named Larry Ellison founded Oracle. Ellison's company went on to become the leader in relational database software, a $13.5 billion market that Oracle leads to this day.

Monday, March 21, 2005

NO-SOFTWARE-PATENTS.COM NEEDS YOUR MONEY: Showing that principles are nice, but cash is king, Florian Mueller, the guy who put together NoSoftwarePatents.com, has started a lobbying initiative, to get support from "closed source" companies in the $50 million-in-revenues and above class. For those "in the know," NoSoftwarePatents.com is Mr. Mueller's effort to stop all types of software patenting in the European Union (bet you couldn't guess from the title, eh?).

INFINEON AND RAMBUS SETTLE: Technology licensing company Rambus Inc. is announcing that it settled a patent dispute with Infineon Technologies AG and entered into a licensing deal with the German chipmaker.

Under the licensing deal, Infineon will pay Rambus $5.9 million each quarter starting in November and continuing through 2007. After 2007, Infineon may make additional payments up to $100 million, but only if Los Altos, Calif.-based Rambus enters into certain licensing agreements with other computer memory manufacturers. Infineon also has the option of acquiring other Rambus licenses under a "most-favored customer" status.

Munich-based Infineon granted to Rambus a fully paid perpetual license for memory interfaces. The companies said they agreed to dismiss all pending litigation and have released each other from all existing legal claims.

Friday, March 18, 2005

USPTO Spring 2005 Business Methods Partnership Meeting: As part of the March 2000 business method action plan, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) announces the Spring 2005 business methods customer partnership meeting to be hosted by the director and managers of the Business Methods workgroup. Members of the public are invited to attend the partnership meeting. The partnership meeting is an opportunity for an informal discussion on topics such as public pair, quality initiatives, determination of statutory subject matter, and other topics specific to business methods. While public attendees will have the opportunity to provide their individual input, group consensus advice will not be sought.

DATES AND LOCATION: The partnership meeting will be held on Wednesday May 4, 2005, from 1:00 P.M.-5:00 P.M. at the USPTO MADISON AUDITORIUM, Concourse Level, Madison Building, 600 Dulany Street, Alexandria, VA 22313.

Requests for Attendance at the Partnership MeetingRequests for attendance will be honored on a first-come, first-served basis according to the time and date of receipt of each request. In order to ensure a broad cross- section of attendees, the USPTO reserves the right to limit the number of attendees from any single organization or law firm. Therefore, organizations and law firms must designate their official representatives. Individuals will be notified of accepted requests for attendance by the USPTO no later than one week prior to the date of the meeting. Non-accepted requesters will also be notified by the USPTO. No one will be permitted to attend without an accepted request.

Requests for attendance at the partnership meeting should be submitted to the attention of Joe Thomas via facsimile at (703) 746-5897, or by electronic mail through the Internet to joseph.thomas@uspto.gov. Requests for attendance must include the attendee's name, affiliation, title, mailing address, and telephone number. Facsimile number and Internet mail address, if available, should also be provided. Requests must be received by April 20, 2005.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT: Joseph Thomas by telephone at (703) 305-9588 (in addition to the facsimile numbers and e-mail addresses given above).

USPTO Releases List of Top 10 Universities Receiving Most Patents in 2004: The Department of Commerce’s United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) today announced the top 10 U.S. universities receiving the most patents during calendar year 2004. Listed below are the 10 universities receiving the most patents for inventions in 2004, along with their 2003 ranking. The University of California tops the list for the 11th consecutive year.


Rank in 2004* N0. of Patents in 2004* U.S. University* (Rank in 2003)
1 424 University of California (1)
2 135 California Institute of Technology (2)
3 132 Massachusetts Institute of Technology (3)
4 101 University of Texas (4)
5 94 Johns Hopkins University (7)
6 75 Stanford University (5)
7 67 University of Michigan (8)
8 64 University of Wisconsin (6)
9 58 University of Illinois (20)
10 52 Columbia University (9)

*The listed patent counts are preliminary counts that are subject to correction. The final listing of patent counts for U.S. universities in 2004 should be available in late December of 2005.

IS THIS LACHES OR ESTOPPEL (OR BOTH)? I noticed an interesting fact in an article describing the current legal woes of FindWhat.com. The company is currently embroiled in a patent lawsuit filed by Overture, now a part of Yahoo Inc (they certainly seem more aggressive nowadays, don't they?). The case is expected to go to trial next month.

Overture filed suit against FindWhat.com in 2002 in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, contending FindWhat.com violated Overture's patent covering its pay-per-click bidding technology.

FindWhat.com, of course, is fighting back. It has filed its own suit, saying Overture's patent was obtained improperly and is invalid.

What was interesting is that the article mentioned that FindWhat.com first received a letter from Overture in 1989 about its patent. I wonder which patent they're referring to, since the information regarding the current suit lists only 1 patent that was filed in 1999 (typo perhaps?). Anyways, assuming there's another, earlier patent, that is over 15 years in delaying action according to my calculations. What was Overture doing during this time?

Under the doctrine of Laches (a French word meaning slackness or negligence - a "sin of omission"), a patent lawsuit may be seriously hampered if there is an unexcused failure of a patentee to take action in a timely manner against a patent infringer. The reason for this policy is that excessive delay may put the defendant at a disadvantage: key witnesses may be no longer available, documents disappear, and memories fade. When laches is found, the patentee is barred from collecting damages accruing prior to the filing of the suit, but is still able to obtain an injunction barring the defendant from further infringement of the patents-in-suit.

Once the laches defense has been raised by the defendant, the plaintiff may still offer evidence that the delay either was reasonable or not prejudicial to the defendant. Ultimately, the burden of proving laches rests with the defendant, who must prove that there was an unreasonable delay in bringing suit and that this delay prejudiced the defense. However, a rebuttable presumption of laches arises when the patentee waits more than six years from the time when he or she discovered (or reasonably should have discovered) the infringement to file a lawsuit.

Estoppel, on the other hand, arises when an action of a patentee causes an accused infringer to believe that the patentee has abandoned any claim against him or will not take action. It may result when the patentee threatens to take action and then fails to follow up.

Estoppel is based on the reasonable reliance of the accused on the patentee's action. For example, the infringer considers the case closed and makes further investments into the ongoing business.

Estoppel typically occurs when the patentee writes to the infringer, describing the alleged infringement and requesting that the infringer either "cease and desist" or take a license. The infringer then either ignores the letter or sends back the usual response that they aren't infringing, and they will consider the matter closed unless they hear back from the patentee. If the patentee then fails to follow up, the infringer - logically - considers the matter finished. As a consequence of estoppel, the plaintiff may be estopped, i.e. barred, from enforcing his patent against this particular defendant.

What's going on here?

IS THIS LACHES OR ESTOPPEL (OR BOTH)? I noticed an interesting fact in an article describing the current legal woes of FindWhat.com. The company is currently embroiled in a patent lawsuit filed by Overture, now a part of Yahoo Inc (they certainly seem more aggressive nowadays, don't they?). The case is expected to go to trial next month.

Overture filed suit against FindWhat.com in 2002 in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, contending FindWhat.com violated Overture's patent covering its pay-per-click bidding technology.

FindWhat.com, of course, is fighting back. It has filed its own suit, saying Overture's patent was obtained improperly and is invalid.

What was interesting is that the article mentioned that FindWhat.com first received a letter from Overture in 1989 about its patent. I wonder which patent they're referring to, since the information regarding the current suit lists only 1 patent that was filed in 1999 (typo perhaps?). Anyways, assuming there's another, earlier patent, that is over 15 years in delaying action according to my calculations. What was Overture doing during this time?

Under the doctrine of Laches (a French word meaning slackness or negligence - a "sin of omission"), a patent lawsuit may be seriously hampered if there is an unexcused failure of a patentee to take action in a timely manner against a patent infringer. The reason for this policy is that excessive delay may put the defendant at a disadvantage: key witnesses may be no longer available, documents disappear, and memories fade. When laches is found, the patentee is barred from collecting damages accruing prior to the filing of the suit, but is still able to obtain an injunction barring the defendant from further infringement of the patents-in-suit.

Once the laches defense has been raised by the defendant, the plaintiff may still offer evidence that the delay either was reasonable or not prejudicial to the defendant. Ultimately, the burden of proving laches rests with the defendant, who must prove that there was an unreasonable delay in bringing suit and that this delay prejudiced the defense. However, a rebuttable presumption of laches arises when the patentee waits more than six years from the time when he or she discovered (or reasonably should have discovered) the infringement to file a lawsuit.

Estoppel, on the other hand, arises when an action of a patentee causes an accused infringer to believe that the patentee has abandoned any claim against him or will not take action. It may result when the patentee threatens to take action and then fails to follow up.

Estoppel is based on the reasonable reliance of the accused on the patentee's action. For example, the infringer considers the case closed and makes further investments into the ongoing business.

Estoppel typically occurs when the patentee writes to the infringer, describing the alleged infringement and requesting that the infringer either "cease and desist" or take a license. The infringer then either ignores the letter or sends back the usual response that they aren't infringing, and they will consider the matter closed unless they hear back from the patentee. If the patentee then fails to follow up, the infringer - logically - considers the matter finished. As a consequence of estoppel, the plaintiff may be estopped, i.e. barred, from enforcing his patent against this particular defendant.

What's going on here?

Wednesday, March 16, 2005

REPORT FOR INVENTORS BEING PUBLISHED: HJ Ventures is publishing a report for inventors and entrepreneurs to help them protect their patents and intellectual property. The report is a useful glossary of terms used in the patenting industry, and has rather detailed descriptions of each of the terms. This would be a useful tool and reference for a GC or other similarly situated executive that is relatively new to patents, and would like to get up-to-speed quickly on the lingo. While I think the glossary is a tad bit cumbersome to use, the report uses "real-world" language to describe many of the terms and procedures that I think is helpful.

RIM SETTLES BLACKBERRY SUIT: I was particularly happy to see this news, as I have become, as of yesterday, a full-fleged member of the "CrackBerry" masses (thank you - thank you - it's nice to be here), and God knows I wouldn't want anything as insignificant as a hundreds-of-millions-of-dollars patent lawsuit to encroach on my happiness.

Anyways, Research In Motion has agreed to pay $450 million to NTP to settle a patent suit against the BlackBerry maker. The company said Wednesday that the settlement included $137 million already held in escrow, while the remaining $313 million would be expensed in the fourth quarter, which ended Feb. 26.

Unfortunatley, from the academic side of things, we will have to wait another time to see what the Federal Circuit will hold on damages for certain infringing activity occurring abroad. In the RIM case, it was held in the lower court that the plain language of section 271(a) does not preclude infringement where a system is used within the United States even though a component of that system is physically located outside the United States. According to the Court, the test is not whether the infringement took place within the United States, but whether "control and beneficial use" of the infringing system was within the United States. Thus, in RIM's case, control of the system and RIM headquarters were in Canada. End users, however, were located in the U.S. At a minimum, control and beneficial use of the BlackBerry system was located in both the U.S. and Canada.

- See Dennis Crouch's analysis here and here

Monday, March 14, 2005

USPTO BEGINS "THE BATTLE OF THE BACKLOG": The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has begun a hiring spree to reduce an expected backlog of 580,000 applications by the end of the year. The Office will hire close to 1,800 patent examiners over the next two years, increasing its current staff of 3,800 examiners by 47 percent.

The patent office processed 304,921 applications last year, 187,170 of which received approval for patent protection (that's 61%).

The hiring project is part of a five-year plan the patent office has implemented to cut down on the time businesses and inventors must wait for a patent. The average wait is about 2½ years from the time a request is filed. But patents for computer technology and biotechnology products are often more complicated and can take up to five years.

YAHOO VS. XFIRE LITIGATION UPDATE: Online gaming company Xfire has countersued Yahoo Inc. in a legal battle over instant-messaging patents.

Yahoo previously had sued Xfire, alleging that Xfire's online messenger service infringes a Yahoo patent on technology co-invented by Chris Kirmse, who subsequently went to work for Xfire.

Yahoo claimed that once at Xfire, Kirmse began to develop, test and offer an instant messenger product that violated the Yahoo patent. Among other things, Xfire's product lets a gamer see if other players identified as "friends" or "buddies" are playing an online game.

In its answer and countersuit filed in federal court in San Francisco, Xfire denied Yahoo's allegations and asked the court to dismiss Yahoo's complaint.

Xfire also filed its own charges, alleging that Yahoo's lawsuit was an attempt to drive Xfire out of business or to force Xfire to sell or license its technology to Yahoo for far less than fair market value to settle the litigation.

Xfire, which said that Yahoo never sent the company the customary "cease and desist" letter before filing its lawsuit, also is seeking unspecified damages resulting from Yahoo's alleged unfair business practices.

Xfire said it generated less than $750,000 in revenue in 2004.

Yahoo, one of the Web's marquee names, reported 2004 revenue of $2.6 billion, excluding fees paid to advertising partners.

YAHOO VS. XFIRE LITIGATION UPDATE: Online gaming company Xfire has countersued Yahoo Inc. in a legal battle over instant-messaging patents.

Yahoo previously had sued Xfire, alleging that Xfire's online messenger service infringes a Yahoo patent on technology co-invented by Chris Kirmse, who subsequently went to work for Xfire.

Yahoo claimed that once at Xfire, Kirmse began to develop, test and offer an instant messenger product that violated the Yahoo patent. Among other things, Xfire's product lets a gamer see if other players identified as "friends" or "buddies" are playing an online game.

In its answer and countersuit filed in federal court in San Francisco, Xfire denied Yahoo's allegations and asked the court to dismiss Yahoo's complaint.

Xfire also filed its own charges, alleging that Yahoo's lawsuit was an attempt to drive Xfire out of business or to force Xfire to sell or license its technology to Yahoo for far less than fair market value to settle the litigation.

Xfire, which said that Yahoo never sent the company the customary "cease and desist" letter before filing its lawsuit, also is seeking unspecified damages resulting from Yahoo's alleged unfair business practices.

Xfire said it generated less than $750,000 in revenue in 2004.

Yahoo, one of the Web's marquee names, reported 2004 revenue of $2.6 billion, excluding fees paid to advertising partners.

JAPAN TECH FIRMS REVAMPING INVENTION REWARD SYSTEMS: With scientists and engineers growing more assertive about receiving monetary compensation, Hitachi Ltd., Toshiba Corp. and other leading technology companies are moving to retool their remuneration systems for worker inventions.

Several high-profile court trials (most notably Nichia's Blue LED case) have placed a new urgency on firms to comply with the revised Patent Law taking effect in April, and to make their remuneration systems more transparent and more acceptable. Companies are looking to revamp their systems in an effort to hold on to researchers and create an environment that effectively promotes the development of excellent inventions.

Hitachi has already introduced several measures, including an arbitration committee to handle cases when workers are unhappy with their remuneration for inventions. To be more transparent, the firm discloses the basis for its calculations and announces which workers have received the most remuneration.

Toshiba is introducing similar measures. The company has put its invention reward calculation rules on its intranet, and starting next month it will introduce a system so that workers can protest if they believe that they have not received proper remuneration for inventions.

Asahi Glass Co. has also established a system to deal with inventors who are dissatisfied with their remuneration. It has revised its reward payment system as well. Starting with patents that generate license revenues this fiscal year, Asahi Glass will pay remuneration equal to 2.5% of the license revenues. Until now, the payout was only 0.25% to 1% of the license revenues. Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. and Sharp Corp. are also studying changes to their systems.

Saturday, March 12, 2005

BURSTING MICROSOFT'S BUBBLE: Software giant Microsoft on Friday agreed to pay $60 million to Burst.com Inc. to settle a patent-infringement suit alleging it had stolen Burst's technology for sending video and sound over the Internet, the two companies announced.

Burst had charged that Microsoft had met with it over a two-year period and negotiated unsuccessfully for the rights to use Burst’s innovative technology. Burst also said in 2002, that Microsoft’s newly announced “Corona” product used technologies and trade secrets misappropriated from Burst.com. These proprietary technologies were protected by numerous U.S. and International patents (and patents pending).

The patent infringement case against Microsoft was due to be heard in Baltimore, Maryland yesterday.

Burst.com and Microsoft on Friday announced that Microsoft has taken a non-exclusive license to Burst’s international patent portfolio, for a one-time license fee of $60 million dollars. The license is for use only by Microsoft in its own product and does not include sub-licensing rights. The patent license also settles the outstanding litigation between both companies.

Richard Lang, Burst CEO, said that Burst intends to use the net proceeds from the license to Microsoft, after attorneys fees, in primarily 3 areas:

  1. To payoff, or reserve for, its current and long term liabilities (approximately $2.8 million), which includes promissory notes (secured and unsecured), outstanding payables, debts to former employees of the company and all accrued salaries and bonuses.
  2. To Reserve a sufficient amount of operating capital to launch a vigorous ongoing enforcement of its patent rights against all infringing parties, as well as pursuing software licensing and other avenues available to the Company to maximize the return to Burst shareholders.
  3. Distribute a substantial portion of its funds through a cash dividend to its shareholders of record. The dividend per share and date of record will be announced at a subsequent date.

Burst said that when it is available, it will publish the settlement agreement and Microsoft patent license on its website, www.burst.com, except for any confidentiality provisions which may exist.

Get ready, because it looks like Burst is ready to spread out a whole lot of number two . . .

Friday, March 11, 2005

MICROSOFT REITERATES CALL FOR REFORM: Microsoft recently called for reform of the US patent system in a speech by Brad Smith to a speech to the American Enterprise Institute in Washington, DC. Ironically, Smith claimed that the long-term health of the system is threatened by a "flood of patent applications" as well as an "explosion of sometimes-abusive litigation." While Microsoft certainly has not been litigious on the plaintiff's side, being one of the top patent filers certainly throws water on the theory that filing gobs of patent applications presents a "problem" for Microsoft.

Nevertheless, Smith outlined proposals to reduce "abusive" patent litigation, create "more consistency among international patent systems [and] eliminate patent filing fees for individual inventors and small firms", and he also called for more consistent funding for the US Patent and Trademark Office leading to "more quality in the patent process".

Perhaps the most notorious patent dispute involving Redmond is its spat with Eolas regarding "a method of opening third party applications within a browser".

The case saw Microsoft slapped with a $565m penalty for allegedly infringing an Eolas patent. However, the US Court of Appeals last week sent the case back for a new trial. A delighted Redmond says it will "now be able to tell the jury the whole story of how this technology was developed and to present evidence that shows that Eolas did not invent this technology, and that it was developed by others"

Wednesday, March 09, 2005

CHINA'S INTERNATIONAL PATENT OUTPUT INCREASES: The number of patents filed under the PCT hit a new record last year with sharp increases from Japan, South Korea and China, a senior U.N. official said Wednesday.

Some 120,100 patents were filed last year under the Patent Cooperation Treaty, said Francis Gurry, deputy director general of the World Intellectual Property Organization.

Patent filings through WIPO have been rising steadily since the treaty system began in 1978, with a total 1 million applications since then. In 2003 there were 115,142 filings.

The most impressive growth, however, came from China, where patent filings rose 37.8 percent to 1,782. Although this represents just a tiny slice of total global applications - and of the 250,000 domestic patents filed in China last year - it is a clear sign that Chinese companies are going global, he said.

"The explanation is essentially that China's enterprises are now operating increasingly in export markets," said Gurry. "I'm sure that over the next five years the number will explode."

LET THE CLUCKING BEGIN! The press has been eagerly noting reactions from our EU friends since the EC adopted the software patent directive. And - surprise! - almost all of it is negative. And it's not your garden-variety negativity you'd get from a disgruntled advocate; it's more of a "get-out-the-tinfoil-hats-because-the-invasion-is-about-to-start" anger that has completely enveloped the more socialist elements in EU software circles:

"I do hope this is an error, and wishful thinking from the EC . . . If it is true then it is a very sad day for Europe and the World. The people responsible for this are criminals, the fact that it is white collar crime doesn't make it any better."

"With one hand they fine Microsoft £500m. With the other they give them the means to make £500bn," said Steve J, describing himself as a "soon to be poor software developer"

"Allowing software patents in Europe would basically allow the US to walk all over any European business." Chief technology officer Bill Franklin added: "OSS development is now going to be spearheaded in the third world."

"The sheer ignorance of using US patent protection and the word 'healthy' in the same sentence is repulsive," said Marcus Widerburg, "Seriously, I dont think anyone in the software industry with any insight would think [that the U.S. software industry is 'healthy']"

Horrors! But the most interesting thing I noted was a quote, highlighted by the staff at ZDNet.uk, analogizing algorithms to common tools used by skilled artisans:

Some readers explained their opposition so eloquently, it seems hard to believe the EU could ever support the directive: "Imagine a plumber not being able to use a clockwise turn with his spanner to tighten a leaky pipe due to the 'clockwise turn' being patented by a large international plumbing firm," said a systems engineer. "Or what about a carpenter not being able to hammer in a nail as 'hammering' had been patented by a large international carpentry firm. Make no mistake, when things as elementary as a progress bar can be patented, we ARE talking about this level of impact for small to medium business that are unable to afford to play the patent game. What's worse is that if this IS passed, any one piece of software may well cross over dozens of patented ideas."

Well, it's a valid concern in principle, but hardly a new sentiment that hasn't been addressed before, at least in the US courts. In Gottschalk v. Benson, Justice Dougles (hardly a cheerleader for software patents) rejected a BCD-to-binary conversion algorithm as patentable subject matter, stating that "[p]henomena of nature, though just discovered, mental processes, and abstract intellectual concepts are not patentable, as they are the basic tools of scientific and technological work." However, “[w]hile a scientific truth, or the mathematical expression of it, is not a patentable invention, a novel and useful structure created with the aid of knowledge of scientific truth may be.” Thus started the 30-year journey for US patent law to rationalize, and finally recognize, software patents as statutory subject matter.

Welcome to 1972, ladies and gentlemen . . .

Tuesday, March 08, 2005

USPTO UNVEILS 3 INITIATIVES TO IMPROVE PATENT PROCESS: The Director of the USPTO, Jonathan Dudas, announced a three-part initiative to improve the agency's processes for handling patent applications. The initiative was announced at a March 4 press briefing in Chicago.

(1) The first change to be implemented is a pre-appeal-brief conference to be held after an unsuccessful patent applicant has filed a notice of appeal, signaling their intent to challenge the examiner's rejection of the patent at the PTO's Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences. Before the applicant files a brief in the appeal, the PTO will convene a conference of three examiners--the examiner assigned to the application, that examiner's supervisor, and a senior examiner--who will review the file to decide whether to maintain the PTO position, or instead to allow the patent or reopen the application for further prosecution. Applicants will be required to request the conference in writing, identifying the rejections that they intend to challenge, and the reasons for those challenges. If the PTO decides not to contest the appeal, this intermediate reassessment of the case could spare the applicant the unnecessary expense of the appeal brief. For example, appeal briefs cost an average of $5,000 per case. The savings overall from the 9,000 appeals filed annually could amount to $30 million. Avoiding the need for briefing in complex appeals could produce even greater savings.

(2) The second component of the PTO's planned improvements is to "clean up" the backlog of pending ex parte patent reexamination cases. The agency will accomplish this goal by instituting a new panel review process, similar to the pre-appeal-brief conference, to consider each reexamination action on its merits. The panel, made up of senior and supervisory examiners as well as a reexamination specialist, will produce a "second office action" in each case that will be a final ruling on the merits.

(3) The third component is the search for prior art that is part of the patent reexamination process. To be an aide and improve the reliability of the patent search, the PTO will develop a "search template" for each of the more than 600 classes of patents in the PTO system. The references that comprise the search templates will be drawn from U.S. patents, foreign patents, and non-patent literature. The PTO hopes to produce the first templates for public comment by July. Such a search grid is already available in the business method patent Class 705. This augmented search tool will also assist the PTO in its hiring of contractors for the pilot outsourcing project underway for PTO searches, and it will let the other two trilateral patent office members--the European Patent Office and Japanese Patent Office--know what the PTO regards as relevant prior art.

Monday, March 07, 2005

ON TO THE EU PARLIMENT: (CNet) The EU Council has finally approved a proposal on software patents, despite opposition from numerous software developers and some European countries.

The European Council adopted the software patent directive on Monday, despite requests from Denmark, Poland and Portugal to reject the directive.

An EU Council representative said Monday morning that the Computer Implemented Inventions Directive had been adopted but was unable to give more details.

As it now stands, the directive would legalize software patents. Supporters say the directive would protect research and development investments by European companies. Opponents say it would stifle innovation.

Last week, it was reported that Denmark would attempt to have the directive listed as a B-item, rather than an A-item, allowing the text to be renegotiated.

The Luxembourg minister acknowledged that Denmark, Poland and Portugal would have preferred the directive to be listed as a B-item, according to Mueller. The directive now moves to the European Parliament, which can reject or amend the proposal, for a second reading.

Friday, March 04, 2005

NOT SO FAST! (ZDNet) The EU software patent directive was scheduled to be adopted next Monday, but a last-minute move by Denmark could now derail the process. Opponents of the Computer Implemented Inventions Directive are set to launch a last-minute intervention to try and prevent it being adopted by the European Council.

The directive, which many claim will allow the widespread software patenting in Europe, is scheduled to appear on the agenda of a meeting of competition ministers on Monday 7 March.
As an A-item, the directive had once again been expected to be approved without debate, but it emerged late on Friday that Denmark will attempt to have the directive listed as a B-item at a later meeting instead. This means the text of the directive could be renegotiated.

Denmark's representative at the meeting of ministers is compelled to ask for the change because of a vote by the Danish Parliament's EU committee that came out in favour of seeking to reopen discussions. Denmark's government is legally bound to adopt any parliamentary decisions regarding the EU.

Denmark's move could provoke a domino effect, encouraging other countries such as Poland and Spain -- who have concerns about the directive -- to also push for renegotiation.

THE AFTERMATH OF INDEPENDENT INK v. ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS: The decision in this case, decided last month in the Federal Circuit, increased the risk of antitrust tying claims against patent holders who condition the purchase of a patented product on the purchase of an unpatented product. As summarized in Dennis Crouch's Patently-O Blog, Trident, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Illinois Tool Works, manufactures printheads and owns U.S. Patent No. 5,343,226 covering the technology. The ‘226 patent discloses an ink jet device and a supply system with a hand actuated peristaltic pump. Trident also manufactures ink for use with the patented printheads. Although the ink is not protected by any of Trident’s patents, their standard license agreements grant the right to “manufacture, use and sell… ink jet printing devices…” to other printer manufacturers only “when used in combination with ink and ink supply systems supplied by Trident.”

The Federal Circuit held that Illinois Tool's patent covering its printheads "presumptively defines the relevant market as the nationwide market for the patented product itself" and "creates a presumption of power within this market." The court further held that Illinois Tool failed to rebut the presumption because it did not present sufficient evidence (e.g., expert testimony) that the boundaries of the relevant market extended beyond its patented printhead. In doing so, the court specifically rejected the notion that a patent creates an irrebuttable presumption of market power.

So what's a patentee to do? Danielle Fitzpatrick provides three considerations for businesses that are considering tying non-patented products to their patented products:

  1. The court indicated that the presumption arises "when the tying product is patented or copyrighted." Therefore, both patent holders and copyright holders should take stock of sales practices.
  2. The decision makes it easier to bring an antitrust tying claim where a patent or copyright holder links the sale of patented and unpatented goods. This may result in more tying claims under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, although the litigation of those claims will likely not change significantly.
  3. Presumption or not, all patent and copyright holders who condition the sale of a patented product on the sale of an unpatented product (or are considering doing so) should undertake at least a preliminary analysis of the relevant market. A decision to tie products or services to patent rights or patented products raises serious antitrust concerns and should always be carefully reviewed by antitrust counsel. Even if the patent holder does not enjoy market power, it must nevertheless weigh the risk of antitrust litigation (which is widely recognized as one of the most expensive and time-consuming types of litigation) against the benefits of the sales practice.

INFINEON - BACK IN THE SADDLE AGAIN: Shortly after disposing one of Rambus' infringement suits, Infineon now finds itself (along with Micron) defending a patent infringement suit brought by Tessera Technologies Inc., who is charging that the companies infringed upon Tessera's IP for packages used to house memory and other semiconductor devices.

The suit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, revolves around packages used for dynamic random access memory (DRAM) devices, confirmed Doug Norby, senior vice president and chief financial officer for Tessera.

Tessera settled a patent suit last November with Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. of Korea involving multi-chip packages. Tessera ended up licensing its packaging IP to major semiconductor suppliers.

In the past, Tessera has also tangled with Texas Instruments Inc. and Sharp Electronics Corp. of Japan in packaging IP disputes.

  • TiVo TRIES PLAYING THE PATENT CARD:
    In recent years, TiVo has been hounded by competitors, seeking to take a bite out of the innovative company's DVR technologies. The market has been speculating that TiVo is all but doomed to be sold to a media/electronics giant such as Sony and Time-Warner by year's end, due to the stiff competition.

    In response, TiVo has been rolling out some interesting new features for their services, and have been placing a greater emphasis on their patent portfolio as a possible precursor to becoming a licensing entity.

    However, as is often the case, convincing the market that your patent portfolio has significant value is a difficult and complicated process. Taking into consideration that TiVo's portfolio hasn't been seriously tested yet in the courts, many pundits have been left speculating just how powerful the patents really are. One research analyst commented:

    "It's hard for us as outsiders to look at how much value there is in the patents . . . everyone is thinking about this from the perspective of whether or not TiVo can license the patents or whether or not TiVo can effectively keep competitors at bay because of their intellectual property. We are all curious."

The PVRBlog took a quick look at one of TiVo's newest patents, and correctly noted that the patent bears an uncanny resemblance to a feature described in Microsoft's Windows Media Center. Is a showdown ahead? If so, it will be a doozie . . .

THE NEXT PUSH BEGINS - (Reuters) European Union President Luxembourg expects the bloc's ministers to approve a controversial draft law on patenting computer-based inventions on Monday, a Luxembourg official has said.

The decision would mark a victory for advocates of patenting some computer software, notably big firms such as Microsoft and Nokia, against many small companies, which fear the planned law would push them out of the market.

The ministers' approval of the draft law would send it to a second reading -- the phase in which it is more difficult for the sceptical EU Parliament to push through amendments.

Wednesday, March 02, 2005

FEDERAL CIRCUIT ORDERS NEW TRIAL IN EOLAS V. MICROSOFT CASE: Dennis Crouch of Patently-O gets the scoop on the decision by the Federal Circuit to order a new trial in the $500 million dollar blockbuster. The court found that the district court improperly granted judgment as a matter of law (JMOL) in Eolas’ favor on Microsoft’s anticipation and obviousness defenses and improperly rejected Microsoft’s inequitable conduct defense -- and thus vacated the district court’s decision and remanded for a new trial on these issues. The CAFC also affirmed the district court's claim construction and related jury instruction.

I'M NOT SURE WHAT TO SAY . . . (Use BugMeNot for subscription access) From constipation to cancer, diarrhea to diabetes, they offer to cure nearly everything -- with medicines made from cow urine. India's Hindu nationalists, who were ousted from power last May, have a new job: promoting cow products that many Indians believe have great therapeutic value.

A stall at the headquarters of the main opposition Bharatiya Janata Party showcases more than two dozen tonics, potions, pills and a line of cosmetics. The products are sold under the brand name Goratna, or "jewels of the cow."

The Goratna offerings use five key cow products -- butter, milk, curd, urine and dung. Purushottam Toshniwal, the general secretary of the cooperative that manufactures the cosmetics, said workers there followed a "solid scientific process" based on India's ancient herbal remedies, known as ayurveda.

The science and technology minister in the previous Hindu nationalist-led government pushed officials to file an application with the U.S. Patent Office for a patent on cow urine distillate. The patent was granted in 2002.

"Even in the United States, they now recognize the worth of cow urine," Toshniwal said.

umm, no they're not . . .

BLAMMO! JUDGE DISMISSES RAMBUS SUIT AGAINST INFINEON: In a case that was closely watched on this blog, Judge Robert Payne of the U.S. District Court in Richmond, Va., dismissed all of Rambus's remaining patent claims in the case, after it was found that Rambus' "misconduct" in handling documents and presenting evidence. The ruling came just before the claims were to be heard at trial.

Rambus, of course, vows appeal.

Monday, February 28, 2005

MICROSOFT PUTS THE PRESS ON OUTSIDE LITIGATION COUNSEL: Microsoft is in the middle of a global review of its law firms as it attempts to control spiralling legal costs caused mainly by its endless antitrust and patent litigation.

It's being reported that the world's largest software house has frozen hourly rates until the selection process is completed. Those firms chosen so far have had to conform to a whole new set of terms and conditions, which include demonstrating a commitment to diversity.

Moreover, with Microsoft's antitrust battles against the European Commission showing no sign of settling any time soon, the focus has also extended to Europe.

Money Quote: Microsoft's European general counsel Horacio Gutierrez declined to comment on the review "because it makes law firms nervous".

THIS IS GETTING TO BE COMICAL - THE EU COMMISSION REFUSES TO REWRITE PTENT DIRECTIVE: In another twist in the "will they or won't they" saga to computer-implemented inventions, the EU Commission has recently indicated that it will likely refuse to rewrite the Computer Implemented Inventions Directive that has been kicking around the EU for the last year. Predictably, the anti-software crowd is furious.

An EC spokesman confirmed on Monday that the Commission had declined requests from the European Parliament to go back to basics on the CIID, which opponents claim will allow the widespread patenting of software in Europe.

"We expect the European Council to formalize the common position. The Commission stands ready to review all aspects of the directive," said the EC spokesman, adding that this meant that changes could yet be made to the directive when it reaches the European Parliament.

Florian Mueller, who runs an anti-patent Web site (you have to read it to believe it), condemned the EC's decision, accusing those responsible of "negating democracy".

The CIID has sparked many months of argument, debate and confusion within Europe. It has yet to be formally adopted by the European Council, but if this does happen the directive will return to the Parliament. The EC spokesman said he understood that the Council is planning to put the CIID on the agenda of the 7 March meeting.

NOTABLE INVENTORS PASSING ON: Jef Raskin, a computer interface expert who conceived Apple Computer Inc.'s groundbreaking Macintosh computer but left the company before it came to market, has died. He was 61.

Raskin died Saturday night at his home in Pacifica, Calif., his family said in a statement. In December, he told friends he had been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer.

Raskin joined Apple in 1978 -- as its 31st employee -- to start the young company's publications department. At the time, computers were primarily text-based and users had to remember a series of arcane commands to perform the simplest tasks.

In 1979, Raskin had a different idea: A computer that's priced affordably, targeted at consumers and extremely easy to use. A small team, under his command, was put together at Apple to pursue his concept that would eventually become the Macintosh.

Also, Robert Kearns, the inventor of intermittent windshield wipers who won multimillion-dollar judgments against Ford and Chrysler for using his idea, has died. He was 77.

Kearns died of cancer Feb. 9 at his home in suburban Baltimore, his family said. Kearns, a onetime Wayne State University professor, received numerous patents in 1967 for his design for wipers that paused between swipes, making them useful in very light rain or mist. The invention allows the driver to set the interval at which the wiper sweeps the window.

Kearns sued Ford Motor Co. in 1978 and Chrysler in 1982, claiming patent infringement.

In 1990, a jury decided that Ford infringed on Kearns' patent, though it concluded the infringement was not deliberate. Ford had contended the patent was invalid because the windshield system contained no new concepts. But Kearns argued a new combination of parts made his invention unique.

That jury failed to reach agreement on how much he should be awarded, and another jury later ordered Ford to pay Kearns $6.3 million, trimmed by a judge to $5.2 million. To settle the case, the car giant later agreed to pay $10.2 million and to drop all appeals.

Chrysler ended up being ordered to pay Kearns $18.7 million plus interest. The Supreme Court rejected Chrysler's bid to overturn the award in 1995.

CHINA ENCOURAGES PATENTING FOR IT COMPANIES: As of this year, intellectual property rights (IPRs) will be a recognized criterion for evaluating technological achievements of companies, the Ministry of Information Industry has announced.

The move aims to stimulate domestic IT firms to develop more independently created technologies under IPR protection, according to the ministry's Electronic IPR Service Center.

With the progress of economic globalization, domestic companies, especially IT firms, are facing tough competition from their foreign counterparts, China Intellectual Property Rights News quoted the center's official Zhang Heteng as saying.

In order to deepen IPR awareness among domestic companies, the ministry set up the IPR threshold and list it as the first benchmark. Companies which fail to pass this threshold will be excluded from further technological evaluation.

Starting this year, companies must obtain patent or copyright registration before they take part in technological evaluation.

Thursday, February 24, 2005

CHINESE COMPANIES WADE INTO THE WORLD OF 專利訴訟 (PATENT LAWSUITS): China's new electronics companies, lured by riches in foreign markets, are feeling the bite of well-honed patent protection systems that have become effective weapons of business war for their competitors.

Such lawsuits filed in the United States would have been considered little more than a nuisance by Chinese firms just two years ago, carrying little or no clout in China.

Multinationals are reluctant to file patent lawsuits in China, where intellectual property (IP) laws are new and the courts lack experience handling such cases.

But with China's exports of machinery and high-tech goods reaching $490 billion last year, up 45 percent from 2003, the threat of being shut out of lucrative western markets has become a potent deterrent against IP theft by Chinese companies, experts say.

Attorneys said the number of IP lawsuits in the United States is relatively small, in the dozens each year.

But they added the number has been growing as companies try to nip new competition from China in the bud and avoid losing market share the way they did to aggressive competitors from Japan and later South Korea starting in the 1970s.

Also, a growing number of Chinese firms are also finding they can use the system to their advantage in a range of disputes with their overseas business partners.

Two Chinese companies sued a consortium of DVD patent holders, including Philips, Sony, Pioneer and LG Electronics, alleging cartel-like behavior.

China's top TV maker, Sichuan Changhong Electric Appliances, sued U.S. distributor Apex Digital in California in December to recover an alleged $484 million in unpaid bills.

LOYOLA (LA) FEATURES SYMPOSIUM ON OUTSOURCING PATENT WORK: the event is titled "Cost Effective Patents: Is Outsourcing the Answer?" and will take place at Loyola Law School - Los Angeles on March 4 from 8:30 a.m.-2:00 p.m. The program is the first in a series of Special Intellectual Property Focus Events that will be taking place in the near future (Link).

A NEW PATENT PORTFOLIO STRATEGY - INVEST IN PATENTEES SUING YOUR COMPETITORS: AMD has decided to invest in a small chip technology development company, called Patriot Scientific, that's suing Intel for alleged patent infringement.

Patriot Scientific this week confirmed that AMD has bought an undisclosed number of the company's restricted shares and licensed not only its ShBoom processor patent portfolio but also its Ignite 32-bit processor design.

In January 2004, Patriot sued Sony, Fujitsu, Toshiba, Matsushita and NEC for alleged infringement of patent number 5,809,336, which it owns. The company sued them because they had shipped product containing Intel processors that it also claimed violated its intellectual property rights. If the move was intended to force Intel to license the patent, it failed - Intel countersued, and was itself sued by Patriot in February 2004. Patriot is seeking monetary damages to the tune of "several million dollars" for the alleged infringement.

Since then, Patriot has notified 150 other companies that it believes their products infringe its patent, though as yet it has not initiated legal proceedings against them, undoubtedly while it awaits the outcome of its action against Intel.

AMD's interest in the Ignite technology is also interesting because Ignite is a Risc-like 32-bit processor core with a strong SIMD component. According to Patriot, multiple Ignites can work together within the company's InFlame architecture to create a multi-SIMD processor. It just so happens that this configuration shares similarities with the architecture Sony and IBM have been discussing as of late to power the PlayStation 3.

NOT FRIDAY YET, BUT CLOSE ENOUGH: In one of the more "interesting" stories, a Westchester County paralegal just pleaded guilty for running an identity theft scam, stealing over $1 million from two companies. The rub here is that she used a patent law firm as a front for stealing all the money.

While working as a paralegal for a large corporation on Long Island, the thief submitted seven fraudulent invoices totaling over $595,000 for legal work that had never been provided. The company issued checks for the counterfeit invoices to a "well known patent law firm" that had done work for the company before. Instead of mailing the checks, Nicholson insisted the checks be given to her for disbursement. Then, posing as an attorney, she secured a business certificate using a name nearly identical to the patent law firm’s, opened a bank account and deposited the checks into that account.

Tuesday, February 22, 2005

D'OH! SOFTWARE IS PATENTABLE IN INDIA, AND NOBODY NOTICED: The latest patent ordinance in India has already raised strong protests from the people for allegedly favoring global pharmaceutical corporations. What has gone relatively unnoticed is the fact that computer programs (read software) can now be patented. The new ordinance has supposedly been brought in to make the Indian Patent Act TRIPS compliant.

Kapil Sibal, the minister for science and technology, is reported to have said that patenting of software is due to the demand of the Indian software industry whom it will help.

The Indian Patent Act, as modified in 2002 had made non-patentable the following:

  • a mathematical method or a business method or a computer prgramme per se or algorithms.
The recent amendment states instead:

  • a computer programme per se other than its technical application to industry or a combination with hardware; a mathematical method or a business method or algorithms.

Are anti-software loonies going bannanas over this development? Natch! Just check out this article on TheAge.com (see BugMeNot to bypass registration). The sky is falling!

J'ACCUSE! RAMBUS ACCUSED OF DESTROYING EVIDENCE IN DRAM RE-TRIAL: John Desmarais, who represents German chipmaker Infineon Technologies AG in a retrial of a patent infringement case initiated by Rambus before U.S. District Court Judge Robert Payne in Richmond, Virginia, claimed that Rambus Inc. destroyed documents knowing that competitors would need them to defend against the company's patent infringement lawsuits. Desmarais presented video-taped witness testimony that he said supports Infineon's defense.

Earlier this month the judge said he would rule on Infineon's motion to dismiss Rambus's lawsuit only after he heard testimony from witnesses about Infineon's "serious charges'' that Rambus purposely destroyed documents and then made misrepresentations in court to ensure that chip companies couldn't challenge its patents.

In today's hearing, the first phase of the retrial, Desmarais showed what he said was conflicting testimony from Rambus executives. In court documents he has said the contradictions show how Rambus attempted to build a false record to thwart the defense of companies that it sued for patent infringement.

CANTOR'S BOND-TRADING PATENT RULED INVALID: (Bloomberg.com) Cantor Fitzgerald LP's patent for electronic bond trading, the subject of an infringement lawsuit with ICAP Plc, isn't valid, a jury ruled.

The federal court jury in Wilmington, Delaware, made the decision after 15 hours of deliberations following a two-week trial, saying that Cantor failed to provide adequate written description of the technology.

Cantor and its ESpeed Inc. electronic-trading unit sued ICAP units Garban LLC and BrokerTec USA units in 2003, contending they infringed a patent awarded to Cantor that same year. ICAP and Cantor are the biggest players in the $3.9 trillion market for government bonds. Cantor, headed by Howard Lutnick, 43, has been losing business to Britain's ICAP, headed by 49-year-old Michael Spencer, who claims a 61 percent share.

The jury also decided that Garban infringed the patent that was ruled invalid. U.S. District Judge Kent A. Jordan ruled before the trial that BrokerTec didn't infringe the patent, and that Cantor couldn't seek damages in the case.

ATOM FEED PROBLEMS: I've been informed that the blog is not being updated in the Atom Feed. I'll be looking to fix this problem, and will hopefully be up and running in this regard before the end of the week. Many thanks to those that brought this to my attention.

SOFTWARE PATENTS GETTING MORE PRESS: I've been noticing that over the last two years, many magazines and newspapers have been digging deeper into software patents and their impact on the marketplace. Take, for instance, this article where Real Software, the maker of the Realbasic application development tool, has raised concerns over Microsoft's IsNot operator patent application. The gist of the article is that Real Software is saying that no one should be able to patent fundamental programming operations.

Now, there is nothing inherently earth-shattering about the article (yet another company decrying a competitor's software patenting strategy, right?). Certainly Slashdot is full of programmers that have been howling for time immemorial about the "evil" intentions of companies trying to obtain software patents. But then, why would the news services reprint the article in so many publications? This is only a patent application after all, and not some issued patent that Microsoft is trying to enforce.

My theory is that the attitude towards software patents is becoming more tempered in the mainstream press, and this will have a tendency to affect the overall outlook by government officials and practitioners with respect to software patents. Most practitioners have known about the effects of software patents for a long time (see Paul Vick's blog entry on the Microsoft patent), and have essentially treated them as a necessary evil. However, I think that we may be turning a corner, where the voices of the naysayers are getting elevated over that of the software patent proponents. For those that are following the FTC patent reform efforts, there certainly seems to be a push to tame the lottery-type mentality that is so pervasive among holding companies. Now, I'm not saying that software patents are in jeopardy of falling outside the scope of 35 USC 101 again, but I would be very surprised if there aren't some significant reforms that will take place over the next year.

Friday, February 18, 2005

RUSSIA TAKING MOVES TO BOLSTER IP AND PATENTS: The Russian Federal Service for Intellectual Property, Patents and Trademarks (Rospatent) oversees the protection of intellectual property rights in the Russian Federation. Rospatent issues patents and certificates of recognition, and is a state executive body under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Education and Science.

It takes up to five to six months to register a patent in Russia. Rospatent officials believe this is a decent indicator by global standards, considering the current level of economic activity in the country. However, if we take into account the fact that Russian economy is growing rapidly and the number of applications for patents might increase by 250-350%, the existing resources are naturally insufficient. Accordingly, Rospatent is currently working on the introduction of new information technologies. At present, work is underway to establish an electronic system for patent applications. In the future, new IT-technologies will be used in the entire technological process.

Furthermore, intellectual property legislation has been overhauled in the last few years. The most important developments were the introduction of amendments and addenda to the law On Copyright andNeighboring Rights, and the Patent Law, and the adoption of the Law on Commercial Secrets. In general, Russian legislation in the intellectual property sphere corresponds to international standards. At present, Russia has joined 14 out of 24 international treaties related to this issue. Moreover, the Russian Criminal Code contains two articles specifically dedicated to this problem: Article 146, Violation of Copyright, and Article 147, Violation of Patent Rights. It is the Interior Ministry's responsibility to ensure compliance with these articles.

Thursday, February 17, 2005

(YET) ANOTHER WARNING ABOUT US TECH INNOVATION: The Task Force on the Future of American Innovation, created by leading US companies and scientific and business associations, sounded an alarm with a report indicating that the United States was gradually slipping as the world leader in scientific and technological research.

The signs of trouble outlined in the report range from a slowdown in the growth of technical research to stagnant government funding for fundamental sciences.

As the US share in global high-tech exports was dropping, China, South Korea and other emerging Asian economies boosted theirs from seven percent in 1980 to 25 percent in 2001, according to the study.

While technological article output over that 14-year period increased 13 percent in the United States, in Western Europe it went up by 59 percent, in Japan by 67 percent, while countries such as China, Singapore, Taiwan and South Korea it jumped a whopping 492 percent.

However, US patent applications from China, India, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan grew by 759 percent over the 1990s while similar applications in the United States increased only by 116 percent, the report said.

I don't really buy into these types of stories, as they have been legion since the 1970's (remember when the press was predicting that Japan would own most US businesses in the 1980's?). Also, some of the premises - such as government funding for research - is a red herring. Just because you're blowing large wads of cash on research doesn't mean that you are being productive or efficient. Many of the technological imports from overseas happen because of the cheap cost of manufacturing and labor. Finally, while the report cites percentages as a basis for their comparison, this ignores the actual output of a particular country o business.

For example, if my company filed 20 patents in 1995, and I filed 100 patents in 2004, this would reflect a 500% increase in my patent filings. This is certainly a great improvement, but you would be hard-pressed to argue that I am now poised to overtake IBM.

PATENT POOLING FOR NONPROFIT FUNDRAISING? (eWeek) Shabbir Safdar, CTO of Mindshare Interactive Campaigns, a Washington firm that runs many nonprofit and political fundraising efforts, has created a cross-licensing patent pool for nonprofits who do the kind of work he does.

Safdar's worried that nonprofits—whose resources are spent on fundraising—will not be able to protect themselves if they're accused of violating patents. There haven't been any suits yet, but Safdar worries that the fight over the patents used to register and protect the various processes involved in online fundraising—currently the focus of most online political activity—isn't far away.

So Safdar's created the Nonprofit Innovation Alliance. The group, which includes Beaconfire Consulting, CharityWeb, Convio, GetActive, Mindshare Interactive Campaigns, Itero, Public Interest Data Inc. and RightClick, hopes its no-cost cross-licensing agreements among patent holders will cut out the lawyers. The group is hoping to expand.

"No one may be refused," Safdar joked of the organization's motto. "Our goal is to make the nonprofit marketplace a business method patent-free zone,'' he said.

Unfortunately, Kintera, possibly the best-known nonprofit software company, isn't really interested in participating. Or if it is, its CEO, Harry Gruber, has a funny way of showing it. "I think it's naïve,'' he said.

Claiming that none of the Innovation Alliance members have patents to share with his company, Gruber said it makes little sense for Kintera to enter into any sharing agreements with them. "It's like saying, 'Let's go play marbles. You have marbles, I don't.'"

PATENT POOLING FOR NONPROFIT FUNDRAISING? (eWeek) Shabbir Safdar, CTO of Mindshare Interactive Campaigns, a Washington firm that runs many nonprofit and political fundraising efforts, has created a cross-licensing patent pool for nonprofits who do the kind of work he does.

Safdar's worried that nonprofits—whose resources are spent on fundraising—will not be able to protect themselves if they're accused of violating patents. There haven't been any suits yet, but Safdar worries that the fight over the patents used to register and protect the various processes involved in online fundraising—currently the focus of most online political activity—isn't far away.

So Safdar's created the Nonprofit Innovation Alliance. The group, which includes Beaconfire Consulting, CharityWeb, Convio, GetActive, Mindshare Interactive Campaigns, Itero, Public Interest Data Inc. and RightClick, hopes its no-cost cross-licensing agreements among patent holders will cut out the lawyers. The group is hoping to expand.

"No one may be refused," Safdar joked of the organization's motto. "Our goal is to make the nonprofit marketplace a business method patent-free zone,'' he said.

Unfortunately, Kintera, possibly the best-known nonprofit software company, isn't really interested in participating. Or if it is, its CEO, Harry Gruber, has a funny way of showing it. "I think it's naïve,'' he said.

Claiming that none of the Innovation Alliance members have patents to share with his company, Gruber said it makes little sense for Kintera to enter into any sharing agreements with them. "It's like saying, 'Let's go play marbles. You have marbles, I don't.'"

Wednesday, February 16, 2005

P & G's NEW LICENSING STRATEGY - COME ONE, COME ALL: A new corporate trend seems to be emerging in the land of IP licensing. IP Law & Business reports that Procter & Gamble, which was previously known as being extremely selective is granting licenses, has taken a more "open" approach to their IP, and it seems to be taking off.

Described as "open innovation," P&G's strategy is now taking hold at a number of leading companies. Few people thought of P&G as open in late 1996, when the company was forming a small intellectual asset management group. "At that time, we were totally focused on outlicensing stuff that P&G wasn't interested in," says Jeffrey Weedman, vice president for external business development and global licensing. "It's morphed an awful lot since then, thank goodness."

Weedman's first lesson in licensing: Most companies weren't interested in assets that P&G itself didn't want. On the other hand, there was plenty of interest in the rest of the patents in the portfolio. Weedman's group devised new rules: All patents at P&G can be licensed out either five years after they were awarded or three years after they were first used in a P&G product, whichever came first. Licensing royalties flow back to the business unit where the patent originated, instead of being claimed at the corporate level. Next, Weedman's group added in-licensing responsibilities, working with business units, R&D, and other organizations to find what they needed and to structure the deals to secure it. As of 2001, the business development group was on its way to being what Weedman says it is today: a "preferred portal" for anyone looking to work with P&G to create value.

P&G's competitors traditionally didn't bother developing new products to compete with P&G's. Instead, they now know that in three years--when P&G makes its patents available--they can piggyback on the company's technology. At the same time, P&G has three years to sell its new products without much competition.

HP TO OPEN-SOURCE: GET OVER IT - (ZDNet.com) Open source programmers might not like the idea of software patents, but those critics would be better off adapting to the fact that they're not going away, HP's top Linux executive said on Tuesday.

"At the end of the day, software patents are a way of life. To ignore them is a little bit naïve," Martin Fink, HP's vice-president of Linux, said in Boston at the LinuxWorld Conference and Expo. It's fine to object to software patents, but it's foolhardy not to try to acquire them, he said.
"Refusing to patent one's ideas is leaving oneself exposed for absolutely no good reason," Fink said. "For some, (getting patents) may seem like selling out. You can comfort yourself that it's what you do with the patent that matters, not the fact that you have one."

Intellectual-property issues are attracting more attention because of open source software, which by definition may be shared, changed and redistributed. Those freedoms stand in stark contrast to the secrecy and distribution constraints of traditional proprietary software.

Tuesday, February 15, 2005

STOCK-BUYING TIPS - FOLLOW THE LITIGATION: The gurus have started to give greater emphasis to "Litigation Profits," which bolster stock prices for companies that have little market penetration, but also happen to have strong litigation positions with respect to their competitors. Rambus has been getting lots of press in this regard, and has been labeled a "top guru buy" in Forbes:

Los Altos, Calif.-based chip design firm Rambus was another guru buy involved in litigation. In May 2004, the company sued competitors Infineon Technologies, Micron Technology and Siemens, among others, for price fixing. On Monday, Rambus won a preliminary battle, with the courts setting the venue for the trial as San Francisco, where Rambus had wanted it.

The litigation-happy company is also suing competitor Hynix for patent infringement, and Rambus has already received a handful of summary judgment victories in that suit. Nevertheless, Rambus is off 23% in 2005 to $18.71. Last week, the stock was, the top guru buy by a significant margin. The M100 are not fazed by the price-to-earnings ratio of nearly 61 and price-to-book ratio of more than six. Gurus like the momentum building in the court decisions favoring Rambus.

Monday, February 14, 2005

Phillips v. AWH Oral Arguments MP3 - Dennis Crouch, in classic form, has posted the oral arguments in downloadable and streaming MP3 format on his Patently Obvious blog. Haven't listened to the whole argument yet, but I will do it the next time I have a free moment.

ARIBA SETTLES WITH ePLUS: (From eWeek) software developer ePlus Inc., of Herndon, Va., on Monday announced that it has been awarded a $37 million settlement in a patent infringement suit against rival Ariba Inc.

The settlement, awarded by a Federal Court jury in Alexandria, Va., also awards ePlus the rights to cross-license Ariba's software patents—including pending patents—for the next three years.

The court determined Ariba "willfully infringed" three ePlus software patents relating to electronic procurement technology, according to a statement released by ePlus.

Ariba officials were not available for comment.

The technology in question, seemingly ubiquitous throughout any electronic procurement software, lets users perform a number of essential e-procurement functions including: electronic searches, selections and comparisons; viewing items in multiple supplier catalogs; finding equivalent items and replacements; generating purchase orders from multiple vendors; and electronically checking inventory.

Ariba, of Sunnyvale, Calif., is ordered to pay the $37 million in three installments, the balance of which is due by March 31, 2005. The deal does allow Ariba to continue selling its procurement software, enabled by the patented technology, under a license arrangement with ePlus. However, any late payments by Ariba would result in a revocation of the license agreement, according to ePlus.

ePlus initially filed a patent infringement suit against Ariba in spring 2004.
Ironically, Ariba's one-time archrival in the electronic procurement sector, Commerce One Inc., also had a recent patent skirmish of sorts. On Dec. 8, 2004, the company held a controversial fire sale in San Francisco where it auctioned off 39 Web services patents for $15.5 million.

The patents, acquired by JRG Acquisition Inc., were a hot-ticket item not only because of the XML Web services technology they encompassed, but because of what the new owners could potentially do with the patent rights. The fear of some major companies using Web services is that a new owner could essentially go door-to-door to "shake down" any companies that operate in Web services, demanding some sort of payment in lieu of a patent infringement suit

Friday, February 11, 2005

WANTED: PATENT ENGINEERS - NO PATENT EXPERIENCE NECESSARY: Microsoft is recruiting patent engineers - but actual knowledge of patent law is not considered an obstacle to being hired, according to the job ad.

Last year, Redmond began outsourcing the task of researching and analysing patents to a firm called Intellevate, and the team is based in New Delhi, India. The applicant must be a computer science or electrical engineering PhD, and will be involved in prior art searches, patentability research, "file wrapper analysis", "claim scope mapping" and technical analysis.

But "patent experience" itself "is helpful but not mandatory," for potential recruits. To emphasize the point, the ad stresses that "although advance knowledge of patent law is helpful, it is not required".

Andrew Orlowski of The Register takes Microsoft to task for some of their patenting attempts (and successes), including

To be fair, this is not so much a problem with Microsoft, as it is with the USPTO and some of the shoddy examinations being conducted by the examiners. Spotting bad patents has almost become a sport in this business, and it's high-time the USPTO start acting seriously about patent quality. Then again, I'm sure the readers of Greg Aharonian's newsletter have known about this for a looooooooong time . . .

...AND FROM THE ASHES ROSE IMMERSION: In the "one for the little guys" column is the great story of Immersion Corp. from San Jose which patented technologies in haptics, which combines software and motors to add a tactile interface to the digital world. Its surgical-training machines reproduce the sensation of inserting a catheter into a vein. BMW uses Immersion's haptics to help drivers fiddle with dozens of functions of their iDrive dash-board knob. Last month Samsung showed off Immersion-enabled mobiles that iden-tify callers by different vibrations and add customized pulsations to games and ring tones.

Founded in 1993 by a group of Stanford and MIT engineers, Immersion financed its early days partly by developing technology the Navy used to feel around the ocean floor for lost submarines. Dreams for haptics as a component in every PC never panned out.

But "vibrotactile" features were becoming common in PCgaming, and Immersion's lock on the technology earned it increasing license revenue on steering wheels and joysticks from the likes of Logitech, Microsoft and MadCatz. In late 2000 gamers started shifting their allegiance to the powerful PlayStation system from Sony, which promoted its vibrating "Dual Shock" controller prominently on the box. Immersion began calling Sony to negotiate a licensing deal. Sony repeatedly declined. Microsoft, openly planning its Xbox for release in late 2001, told Immersion it would not pay unless Sony started paying.

On Feb. 11, 2002 Immersion filed suit against both companies, a move meant to draw attention. That it did: Immersion's stock got savaged, falling 50% in a week, from $4.50 to $2.30. Then litigation began to drag on. Microsoft, which had a decent prior relationship with Immersion, settled in July 2003.

Sony chose to keep fighting. The case went to trial in August in the federal district court in Oakland. However, the jury came back with a verdict on Sept. 21, agreeing that Sony's controllers infringed two Immersion patents, one applied for in 1995 though not issued until 2001. The jury awarded Immersion $82 million in lost licensing revenue, and the judge later ordered Sony to pay Immersion 1.4% of ongoing revenue from its PlayStation 2 system and offending games, a rate that would double Immersion's revenue.

Read the whole story on Fobes.com

BICYCLES AND PATENTS - ALL YOU EVER WANTED TO KNOW: In this interesting article, Bob Mionske chronicles the business and legal history of bicycles through the early 20th century.

Starting in 1879, the infant bicycle industry was almost destroyed by a decade of protracted patent litigation. Col. Albert Pope, the great bicycle magnate, was the driving force behind most of these legal skirmishes. Many observers believed that the colonel's ultimate aim was to monopolize the bicycle industry. Pope and his lieutenants loudly dissented, arguing that their actions brought stability and prosperity to what otherwise would have been commercial anarchy. While he did rationalize much of the technology that went into the bicycle, there is no doubt that Pope's core intent was self-interest and his actions frequently stretched ethical and legal boundaries, even by the no-holds-barred business standards of the gilded age. Pope's men came very close to gaining a perpetual monopoly over the American bicycle industry, and were defeated only by the United States Supreme Court and a handful of adversaries who vowed to fight him to the finish.

GOLIATH VS. DAVID: (from GameShout) In a twist on the classic David-and-Goliath formula, Web giant Yahoo! is suing Menlo Park, CA, start-up Xfire for patent infringement. The basis of the complaint, filed last week in US District Court (Northern District of California) and served to Xfire representatives just two days ago, alleges that Xfire is willfully infringing on a patent controlled by Yahoo! Inc.

US Patent No. 6,699,125 was granted to two then-Yahoo! employees Brian Gottlieb and Chris Kirmse on March 2, 2004. As is typical, ownership of inventions by employees remains with the corporation the employees work for. Such ownership rights are usually sealed in hiring contracts signed by the employee when he or she is first brought on.

In the case of the '125 patent, Gottlieb and Kirmse were employed by Yahoo! when they developed certain technologies for a game-specific variation on Yahoo!'s popular Yahoo! Messenger. Yahoo! has been the sole assignee--or owner--of the '125 patent since it was granted.

The complaint describes the Yahoo! Messenger instant message service--in this case, the GameProwler instant messenger application--as one that "allows users to use a game server in connection with a messenger server to permit 'buddies' to know when other 'buddies' are playing games online, and easily join such games."

Xfire offers a client application that allows gamers to chat with other gamers online. It also serves to help quickly facilitate gameplay on remote servers.

Thursday, February 10, 2005

WHEN IN DOUBT, GO AFTER THE RETAILER: Athletic shoe maker Reebok claims in a federal lawsuit that retail giant Wal-Mart sold a line of basketball shoes that violated Reebok's patent for a three-layer cushioned sole.

Reebok asked that Wal-Mart stop selling its Starter Oxide shoes and notify customers who bought them that they are unauthorized copies of Reebok's DMX Reflex shoe, and should be returned. Reebok's lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court in Boston in December, also seeks unspecified damages and legal costs.

Wal-Mart denies the allegations. Spokeswoman Mary Heires said the company sold out of the Oxide shoes and no longer carries them. It does carry other basketball shoes under the Starter label.

Heires said Nike Inc. bought the rights to the bankrupt Starter brand last year, and indemnified Wal-Mart against any damages in the case. Nike is not named as a defendant in the lawsuit.

PRESS RELEASES FOR RCE? I can understand companies wanting to promote their own technologies, but Paid, Inc. is apparently publishing press releases over their decision to file an RCE.

"We've had several discussions with the USPTO Examiner assigned to the patent application since the USPTO's issuance of an Office Action on our patent application in November 2004," said Greg Rotman, CEO of Paid, Inc. "We're pleased that the patent office is continuing to review Paid's patent application for our online shipping calculator and related technology. Based upon our discussions with the USPTO Examiner, we've filed a request for continued examination with new claims focusing on some core aspects of our online shipping calculator technology."

Well, that's just super - I can hardly wait for the press release for the next Office Action.

DEVELOPING COUNTRIES SQUAWK AS U.S. "QUIETLY" PROMOTES PATENT HARMONIZATION : Trade analysts are concerned that a number of industrialized countries, led by the US, are trying to move negotiations on patent harmonization outside the ambit of the World Intellectual Property organization (WIPO), according to Intellectual Property (IP) Watch, a Geneva-based reporting service on IP issues. They believe that this would risk undermining the multilateral process for harmonizing patent law and procedures. The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) invited representatives from certain developed countries to a meeting in Alexandria, Virginia on 3-4 February 2005, to discuss patent law harmonization and other IP related issues.

A number of developed countries have been highly critical of the WIPO secretariat for being slow to move the patent harmonization process forward. IP Watch quotes developing country sources as being concerned that the US and other developed countries are "trying to show they can take the negotiations outside of WIPO if that organization cannot keep the talks on track by keeping developing countries in check." The 'exclusive' nature of the recent meeting has raised concerns about the forum in which patent harmonization might be determined. Another trade source suggested that the USPTO is trying to take negotiations on patent harmonization outside the multilateral track in order to achieve standards for patent harmonization that are closer to US objectives than any likely result of the WIPO process. These allegations were rejected, however, by a patent official from a participating country, who asserted that meeting was simply a dialogue and there were no specific ideas about its potential outcome prior to the event.

Wednesday, February 09, 2005

PHILLIPS V. AWH TRANSCRIPT: Dennis Crouch, of the "Patently-O" blog, has posted a transcript of the oral arguments. One notable exchange:


Linn: If we use the dictionary, then which one, and what meaning(s) from that
dictionary?

A: The parties should get deference. The patent owner might propose multiple
definitions, and the defendant would propose narrower definitions. Then the court should
narrow it down to two competing definitions. Then we can run those through the
specification. If they are both plausible, then OK.

Lourie: ---

A: Any dictionary for common terms, and a treatise for technical terms.

Newman: What if it s not in lit igat ion? Persons read patents for technical informat ion. We
can t impose an elaborate st ructure on these people? You read the specification as a
whole and figure out what was claimed? Don t you begin with the specificat ion? What
about priority of sources?

A: The invention is defined by the claims. If the claims are broader than the specification,
then it s OK unless there is an explicit narrowing.
Newman: What about enablement?

A: That s not at issue here. The specificat ion doesn t indicate breadth. That s the purpose
of the claims.

Lourie: Mustn't the specificat ion enable the full scope of the claims?

A: Yes.

Michel: If we agree with you about restricting implicit redefinitions, what about our prior
case law such as Bell Atlantic?

A: The reason this court went en banc was to set some guidelines. Maybe it can be
implicit if it is very clear.

PATENT GRABBER 3.3 OUT FOR MACS: Patent Grabber makes it easy to download U.S. patents and PCT published applications for free from public patent archives. Instead of going to the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office or European Patent Office web site and loading and printing patent or application pages one at a time with your web browser, you simply give Patent Grabber a list of patents or PCT applications and click "Get Patents." Patent Grabber then downloads every page of all the patents or applications to your Mac while you do something else. And once the patents are downloaded, they are yours to keep and print from Patent Grabber's special Library folder at any time.


Tuesday, February 08, 2005

FIRST REPORTS IN ON PHILLIPS V. AWG CORP.: The Federal Circuit Bar Association just completed a meeting with counsel for Phillips, AWG, and the USPTO immediately after their arguments at the Federal Circuit. The arguments were heavily attended at the Federal Circuit(250+ people), and it was standing-room-only. While nobody was ready to make any hard-and-fast predictions, there were a few interesting observations that were made about the oral proceedings:

(1) Of the "seven questions" presented in the en banc order (and the 50,000 sub-parts), the court was not able to address each of these questions individually. The perception was that the first three questions were the main focus of the court's attention.

(2) Everyone agreed that the Federal Circuit (uncharacteristically) focused on factual issues in the case. The court normally bemoans appellants that rehash factual issues instead of arguing the law, so everyone was surprised that they spent so much time on the facts.

(3) The court had virtually no discussion on prosecution history or expert witness testimony (question 6).

(4) The issue of deference to lower courts was only mentioned by Judges Rader and Mayer, and the other judges didn't address this issue at all. One commentator mentioned that this case was a poor one to resolve issues of deference, as the Markman hearing took place back in 2000, and was subsequently transferred before litigation resumed again.

Everyone seemed in agreement that this case had way too many issues that could be effectively decided on appeal. All together, there were approximately 35 amicus briefs filed, and the complexity of the issues presented were such that the court could not reasonably deal with them properly in the time allowed.

Nevertheless, one commentator predicted that he thought that the Federal Circuit would "quietly" conform the law more closely to Cybor, where lower courts could use extrinsic evidence to understand, but not to interpret, the claimed terms in a patent.

I will provide more details and links to other blog sites as they become available . . .

PROTECTING YOURSELF FROM PATENT INFRINGEMENT: In this two-part interview on SearchEnterpriseLinux.com, Bruce Sunstein discusses various mechanisms companies can use to protect against infringement lawsuits. Part One discusses issues of indemnification, and Part Two discusses issues such as insurance and patent opinions. Worth a quick read for anyone wanting to bone up on infringement protection.

Powered By Blogger

DISCLAIMER

This Blog/Web Site ("Blog") is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Use of the Blog does not create any attorney-client relationship between you and Peter Zura or his firm. Persons requiring legal advice should contact a licensed attorney in your state. Any comment posted on the Blog can be read by any Blog visitor; do not post confidential or sensitive information. Any links from another site to the Blog are beyond the control of Peter Zura and does not convey his, or his past or present employer(s) approval, support, endorsement or any relationship to any site or organization.

The 271 Patent Blog © 2008. Template by Dicas Blogger.

TOPO