Friday, June 24, 2005

AND THERE WAS MUCH REJOICING . . . The USPTO has been on a roll lately in terms of reexamination of patents percieved to be overbroad and obvious.

One such patent recently dinged at the USPTO was 6,442,574, which was acquired by SBC (from the late Ameritech) titled "Structured Document Browser." Back in 2003, there was a buzz in the software community regarding this patent after SBC tried enforcing the patent and there were calls to collect invalidating prior art.

The patent dealt with a structured document browser that includes a constant user interface for displaying and viewing sections of a document organized according to a pre-defined structure. The structured document browser displays documents that have been marked with embedded codes that specify the structure of the document. The tags are mapped to correspond to a set of icons. When the icon is selected while browsing a document, the browser will display the section of the structure corresponding to the icon selected, while preserving the constant user interface.

Claim 1 reads as follows:

1. A method for navigating a document comprising a plurality of sections, the method comprising:


(a) displaying a document with a browser comprising a user interface;


(b) displaying a plurality of selectors in the user interface of the browser and not in the document, the plurality of selectors automatically configured to correspond to a respective plurality of sections of the document regardless of what section of the document is being displayed;


(c) receiving a selection of one of the plurality of selectors;


(d) continuing to display the plurality of selectors after the selection is received in (c); and


(e) displaying a section of the document that corresponds to the selector selected in (c).


Well after 2 1/2 years, the USPTO - after a commissioner-ordered reexam - issued a final rejection on the remaining 6 of the original 20 claims recited in the patent. The folks at Slashdot are smiling and happy - there is however, a possibility of appeal, or that some magical amendmendment coud reopen prosecution. However, final rejections in reexam practice requires the blessing of a patentability review conference, so chances are this patent is toast . . .

STN OPENS RUSSIAN PATENT PRIOR ART DATABASE: FIZ Karlsruhe is offering access to Russian patent information in English language via STN International, the online service in science and technology.

The new online file RUSSIAPAT, produced by the Russian Agency for Patents and Trademarks (ROSPATENT), Federal Institute of Industrial Property (FIPS), Moscow, covers Russian patented inventions from 1994 to the present.

It currently contains about 300,000 records and about 245,000 images.

Titles and abstracts are in English, thus providing access to this valuable information also to those unfamiliar with Russian language and characters.

Besides titles and abstracts, RUSSIAPAT records contain the International Patent Classification (IPC) codes, and inventor, assignee and patent application information. Users can also access the drawings available from the full document ( i. e., the drawing from the first page, drawings from the drawing attachment, and embedded drawings from the complete text).

A special display field provides an indication of the number and size of all available drawings.
RUSSIAPAT is updated three times a month.

Automatic current-awareness alerts are also available: At each database update the system checks if any new answers have been added that match a user's saved search profile.
Where such matches are found, the answers are then forwarded to the user.

Thursday, June 23, 2005

LOOKING FOR MORE INFORMATION ON THE GOOGLE WEB-RANKING PATENT APPLICATION? David Utter from Webpronews.com provides an initial breakdown here. It could be important stuff for people that rely on Google rankings to generate business:

If you're a legitimate site owner, you'll want to register your domain for more than one year. Otherwise, the Google PageRank algorithm may rate your site lower than you may deserve.

Spammers tend to register domains for the minimum amount of time, one year, and Google's patent application seems to say that's a bad move.

Another lesson to be gleaned from the application appears to deal with links. Pages or sites with loads of links, and which gain a number of links in a very short span of time, may indicate a site that is attempting to fool the algorithm. Numerous claims within the application point to the behavior of links over time, their freshness, and the documents they reference all as factors
being considered by the algorithm.

The "freshness" of sites also figures in the equation. Google appears to be tweaking its algorithm so sites that update frequently, but not so much that they appear to be gaming the search engine, get a more prominent placement in the search results.

MICROSOFT STRENGTHENS IP PROTECTION FOR PC MAKERS: Microsoft has upped the intellectual property protections it offers to PC makers, which shields them from claims of patent infringement and other IP-related disputes. The move comes after a number of high-profile lawsuits targeting manufacturers using Microsoft software.

New protections will include no monetary limits on legal fees and idemnification from patent claims, copyright claims, as well as trade secret and trademark claims. Microsoft will also provide capped monetary protections for damages and settlements related to an IP case.

The coverage extends to current and future versions of Microsoft software, including Windows Server, SQL Server, Exchange Server, Microsoft Office System, and Windows client software.

Wednesday, June 22, 2005

PROTECTING END-USERS AGAINST PATENT INFRINGEMENT FROM THE MANUFACTURER'S PERSPECTIVE: In an interesting article from Managing Automation, a question was raised regarding the targeting of end-users for patent infringement. Consider the following:

Earlier this year the Gillette Company sued Energizer Holdings Inc., alleging Energizer's QUATTRO, a four-blade, wet-shave safety razor, infringes on Gillette's 777 patent (U.S. Patent Number 6,212,777 issued in April of 2001). The 777 patent outlines a disposable safety razor with a group of blades placed in a particular geometric position.

But what if Gillette decided it wanted to go after every person who uses the QUATTRO? If one ignores the public-relations nightmare from such an act, this scenario is certainly possible. Over the last decade, the manufacturing community has struggled with machine vision patents held by the late Jerome Lemelson, the named inventor of 12 patents pertaining to this specific area. More recently, Solaia Technology LLC has assumed Lemelson-like status by suing everyone under the sun under its 318 patent (US Patent No. 5,038,318), which it acquired from Schneider Automation Inc. in 2001 ("Device for Communicating Real-Time Data Between a Programmable Logic Controller and a Program Operating in a Central Controller.")

What's interesting is that in both of these instances the patent holders didn't go after the manufacturers that were selling a product each claimed infringed on their IP. Instead, they went after the end users. In fact, Lemelson can be credited with starting this trend (other companies like Solaia and Acacia have followed suit).

And now, as the volume of patent disputes among vendors escalates -- the latest public battle is between Intermec Technologies Corp. and Symbol Technologies over wireless data capture and laser scan engines -- customers are fearful of getting caught in the crossfire. Moreover, some of the patents at the center of these legal wranglings are part of emerging industry standards, which muddies the waters even more.

So what is a technology buyer to do?

There's no easy answer here, but, ultimately, the legal responsibility must lie with the vendor from which the product was purchased:

Get the Vendor to indemnify - Before entering into any contract with a technology vendor, make sure there is a well-defined indemnity clause included. Often times products have an implied UCC warranty that the purchased product does not infringe on anything. However, explicitly stating the terms of the warranty should help remove any potential ambiguities.

Consider Patent Infringement Insurance - A patent infringement insurance policy can include a range of coverage from just legal costs to full indemnification for damages. However, insurance can be pricey. A policy's cost can range from $7 to $12 per $1,000 of coverage, but it can be worth the extra expense, especially given the "chain of commerce" in which liability can shift from one company to the next. For instance, many large companies require that their suppliers have a defense policy in place prior to doing business.

Join a Working Group or Defense Group - plaintiffs love to target end-users that are perceived as being too weak to defend themselves. 99% of the time, these types of targets settle quickly (usually at a cost between $40-300k, depending on the circumstances) to avoid escalating legal costs. By teaming up with others, your ability to actually fight back becomes much greater.

Manufacturers will always need to formulate various types of defense mechanisms to protect their companies from IP litigation. Of course, it's always best to get legal counsel before doing anything, but the bottom line for manufacturers purchasing technology is that someone else's IP is not necessarily your responsibility. Remember that if you are an end user that bought a product and you are sued for infringement, the vendor has an obligation to defend you.

Tuesday, June 21, 2005

NTP PATENTS - 0 FOR 5: The case against Research In Motion, the Canadian manufacturer of the popular BlackBerry wireless device, brought by a Virginia-based company suffered another blow as the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office announced Friday that it had rejected the fifth of eight patents the challenger is claiming.

The patent in question was the fifth in a row rejected by the patent office. Only three remain to be reexamined. The patent office had initiated the review of four of the disputed patents in January 2003, while Research In Motion requested a review of others. The patents are owned by NTP, a holding company founded by Thomas Campagna, an inventor who died in June 2004.

EU PARLIMENT WATERS-DOWN ANTI SOFTWARE PATENT PROVISIONS: (Reuters) The Parliment's legal affairs committee agreed 16 to 10 to a 'patentability of computer-implemented inventions' bill, which goes to the full parliament in July.

But the bill's sponsor in the legislature, French socialist Michel Rocard, suffered a string of defeats as key changes were made to his text.

Rocard wanted a narrow definition of what sort of inventions could be patented, insisting that only a programmable piece of hardware could be covered, such as ABS brakes on a car or an insulin pump.

Data processing and other inventions that are more pure software based should be excluded.
"Software is nothing more than a collection of mathematical formulae," the former French prime minister told a packed committee room.

But changes won by center-right and liberal opponents pushed the bill closer to a version adopted by the EU's 25 member states, which chose a far wider scope for patenting.

"It was a mixed result but it's clear that Rocard did not have a majority, and he lost many important compromises," center-right member of the European Parliament, Piia-Noora Kauppi, said afterward.

Rocard, who declined to comment after the vote, also failed to change the name of the bill to 'patentability of computer controlled inventions', a bid to focus patenting on hardware and leave out allied software.

SUPREME COURT REVISITS PATENT TYING CASE: The court will hear the case of Illinois Tool Works v. Independent Ink late this year and could restrict anti-trust lawsuits against patent-holders.

The case involves claims of anti-trust "tying" - where the purchase of a popular product is linked to the purchase of a related item. Tying is illegal when a company has "market power" in selling the popular product and can use that power to piggy-back the less desirable product along with it. The particular case involves an Illinois company that makes patented print-heads, and requires printer manufacturers to buy their ink from the company too.

Intellectual property owners are keen to overturn a decades-old precedent that says a company with a patent is presumed to have market power. The view is that this precedent is "outdated" and should be overturned, because of its alleged interference with the market.

According to the Intellectual Property Owners Association (IPO), "plaintiffs in tying cases involving patents should be required, like all other tying cases, to prove that the seller has market power in the tying product." The IPO joined Pfizer in an amicus brief to discard that presumption. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Department of Justice do not use such a presumption in cases involving patents.

The Federal Circuit appeals court said when it ruled in the Illinois case: "The Supreme Court has held that there is a presumption of market power in patent tying cases, and we are obliged to follow the Supreme Court's direction in this respect. The time may have come to abandon the doctrine, but it is up to the Congress or the Supreme Court to make this judgment."

So let it be written . . . . so let it be done.

Friday, June 17, 2005

IT MUST BE FRIDAY: The Museum of Sex in New York is showcasing an exhibit on U.S. Patent Office Sex Inventions.

The entire patent exhibit, which you can explore in an interactive kiosk on the second floor of the museum, is also available online.

enjoy.

CHINESE STUDY CLAIMS UNIVERSITY PATENTS ARE LACKING: Just when you thought the U.S. was the only country flagellating itself over lack of technological competitiveness with respect to the rest of the world, Zhejiang University of Technology has just concluded a special survey and study that shows 75 percent of the colleges and universities in China file little to no patent applications.

The survey shows there are huge gap in patent application among all the domestic colleges and universities. Tsinghua University, Fudan University, Shanghai Jiaotong University, Zhejiang University and South China University of Technology have applied a total of 4,809 patents in the past five years, accounting for 26.5 percent of the nation's total. Zhejiang University and Zhejiang University of Technology have applied 91.7 percent of all 1,706 patents done by colleges and universities in the Zhejiang province over the past five years.

WORAROUND IT IS! Research In Motion has claimed to have come up with a "workaround" to skirt patents at the center of its legal battle with NTP. Supposedly, the technology could be presently used with all existing BlackBerry email devices.

"We've completed the workaround," RIM chairman and co-CEO Jim Balsillie told CNET's News.com. "We've tested it and we have a legal opinion on it. We have it as an option."
In a phone interview, Balsillie declined to give specifics on the technology, citing both companies' nondisclosure agreements and RIM's so-called quiet period prior to announcing its earnings.
Balsillie said he is prepared to win the long-running legal battle and was encouraged that the director of the U.S. Patent Trademark office asked that four of the five patents in dispute be reexamined--a process that could take years.

UPDATE: Also worth noting, RIM has fast-tracked a challenge to a UK patent to fend off a German lawsuit against T- Mobile International AG, the mobile-phone unit of Deutsche Telekom AG. It wants the High Court in London to invalidate the British version of the patent, in a bid to stall proceedings in Germany

Tuesday, June 14, 2005

BLACKBERRY/NTP PATENT DEAL BEGINS TO UNRAVEL: After two-and-a-half years battling over the patents covering aspects of BlackBerry handhelds, Toronto-based Research in Motion Ltd., which makes BlackBerries, agreed to a $450 settlement in March with NTP Inc.

Now, it appears the two companies can't agree that the settlement would cover all future payment obligations to NTP for Research in Motion. Last week, Research in Motion said NTP refused to honor its obligations and complete final documents for the settlement.

In response, NTP is now taking the position that the settlement is off. In a brief filed with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, NTP claimed that during talks to finalize the settlement, "It very quickly became evident that the parties had interpreted the vague term sheet in entirely different manners regarding virtually every significant provision."

The term sheet is confidential, but NTP said royalty payments were one sticking point.

If the two companies can't agree that Research in Motion's payment covers royalties, then wireless carriers could be on the hook for future payments to NTP.

In the meantime, the U.S. Patent Office continues to question the validity of two of NTP's five patents in the dispute. If the court grants RIM's request to stay pending the reexamination RIM can possibly skate free from the deal (maybe this was the plan all along?). If that is the case, this would be one of the most significant examples of reexamination saving the day for a defendant (let's not forget Eolas!).

Furthermore, Research in Motion said on a call with investors last week that it could modify the design of its products to work around NTP's patent. However, this could likely spark another series of lawsuits from NTP . . .

EU COMMISSION TO REEVALUATE TELECOM STANDARDS TO AVOID POTENTIAL "PATENT AMBUSHES" - The European Commission is investigating the EU's main telecommunications standards agency to determine whether companies are able to exploit the body's patent rules for financial gain, according to this article in the Financial Times.

Commission officials fear that, under existing European Telecommunications Standards Institute regulations, companies may have the ability to turn their patented technologies into universal industry standards without telling rival groups about their patent claims.

According to a spokesman for the Brussels regulator, 'The European Commission is examining ETSI's intellectual property rights rules with a view to ensuring that these rules are framed in such a way that patent ambush situations within ETSI are avoided, and that standards are agreed according to transparent criteria.' Conventional opinion is that current rules do not appear to be able to prevent a situation where a company can potentially acquire a dominant position via a 'patent ambush'.

Once again, a bit of strangeness from an EU commission. Not that I'm any expert in EU telecom regulation, but it would seem that if you're joining a standard group, there are provisions in place to set licensing provisions for members, or create sharing or pooling arrangements. The commission is obviously trying its best to avoid a Rambus-type situation here, but what about non-members? Certainly, it's not all that hard to determine the basic activities of a standards-group member, and if there's going to be any "ambushing," my money's on the upstart outsider that has little or nothing to do with the standards agency . . .

Monday, June 13, 2005

ET TU, ANTOR? With all the Acacia's, Forgents and what-nots out there, it appears another company, Antor Media, is looking to create a splash in the world of mobile phone media downloading, by simultaneously suing Nokia, UTStarcom, Audiovox, Kyocera, Sanyo, Sharp, NEC, RIM, Virgin Mobile, LG Electronics, Palm One and Panasonic. The case was filed last month in the now-predictable venue of the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division.

The complaint alleges that the companies infringed patent number 5,734,961 and catchily called "Method and apparatus for transmitting information recorded on information storage means from a central server to subscribers via a high data rate digital telecommunications network". Antor was apparently assigned this patent on the 31st of March, 1998.

Antor alleges that the defendants infringe its patent by making devices and offering sales for the downloading of media including video, music and ringtones. Antor has also previously sued Apple Computer on similar grounds. I have a hard time believing this patent will survive invalidity challenges. Claim 1 reads:

1. Method of receiving information from one of a plurality of information systems via a high data rate telecommunication network in response to a request from one of plural subscriber stations, said method comprising the steps of:

initiating a two-way transmission from subscriber computer means of said one of said plural subscriber stations to one of said information systems via said telecommunication network,

outputting on output means of said one of said plural subscriber stations data related to plural information stored at one of said information systems,

selecting at said one of said plural subscriber stations at least one of said information by means of input means of said one of said plural subscriber stations and transmitting a signal identifying said at least one selected information from said subscriber computer means to a selected information system via said telecommunication network,

receiving at said one of said plural subscriber stations from said selected information system digital signals via said telecommunication network, expanding by expansion means said transmitted signals, converting said expanded digital signals into analog
signals and delivering said analog signals to transducer means.



Very broad stuff. There is also an EU equivalent to this patent, but it has been abandoned for failing to pay the yearly maintenance fees.

Wednesday, June 08, 2005

PATENT REFORM ACT SCHEDULED TO BE INTRODUCED TODAY: As mentioned on Patently-O and Promote the Progress blogs, the Patent Act of 2005 is expected to be introduced in the House of Representatives later today by Congressman Lamar Smith of Texas. Interestingly, it was good to see that the provision limiting injunctive relief was taken off the table. As Dennis did such a good job highlighting the more important parts of the legislation, I'll simply repeat it here (:P)

The legislation includes:

  • Change to a first-to-file system (thus changing the definition of ‘prior art’);
    Changes to the duty of candor (violations will be adjudged by the PTO rather than in court);
  • Damages to be limited to the inventive contribution rather than calculated on the selling price of an entire product;
  • Limitations on damages for willfulness;
  • Automatic stay of injunctions for appeals;
  • Limits on scope of continuation applications (to be made by PTO);
  • Introduction of a post-grant opposition procedure and submission of prior art by third parties.

STORAGETEK LOSES HUGE CASE AGAINST CISCO - A federal jury in California decided on Tuesday that Storage Technology’s patent infringement claims against Cisco Systems were invalid, ending a six-year-old suit in which StorageTek had sought hundreds of millions of dollars in damages.

Louisville, Colorado-based StorageTek, whose acquisition by Sun Microsystems was announced late last week, had originally sought damages of $3 billion when it filed the lawsuit in 1999.

StorageTek lowered that figure to $322 million by Monday’s closing arguments. After a three-week trial in San Francisco, the jury ruled that Cisco’s networking technology for speeding data flow across firewalls did not infringe on StorageTek’s patent and that the patent claims were invalid.

- Getting non-infringement and invalidity on all claims is a pretty rare thing.

Brenda Sandburg of the Recorder provides a blow-by blow of the case here. I found some of the comments by StorageTek's attorney (the illustrious Ernie Brooks) to be somewhat puzzling, and wondered what the intended effect was. For example:


Dressed in a dark suit with a pale orange shirt and an orange striped tie, Brooks opened by telling the jury it was troublesome to hear himself called an ambulance chaser by opposing counsel.

Brooks also questioned why Cisco had put forth three invalidity defenses.

"Why so many?" he asked. "Tell me which is the winner. Have some confidence."

(Don't you love the couture play-by-play? Nice.)

Why so many defenses? Because they're available! (And apparently persuasive). What an odd thing to say. Any company in its right mind would throw everything they had at a patent infringement claim, especially when the plaintiff is seeking $3bil in damages. This would be even more true when a case is taken on contingency. Although Mr. Brooks has a penchant for taking such cases, I don't know if there was a contingency factor involved in this case. God, I hope not. Losing 6 years of billed time is a pretty big pill to swallow . . .


BTW, in case you're curious what Cisco's counsel (Matt Powers) was wearing:

Wearing a dark suit with a white shirt and blue tie, Powers said when StorageTek filed suit the CEO at the time was "under extreme pressure to do something about StorageTek's financial performance" and the company had wanted to be acquired by Cisco.

'WHEN THE CAT AND MOUSE AGREE, THE GROCER IS RUINED" - Heads up to chip manufacturers - Patriot Scientific and the TPL Group have decided to team-up and begin "commercialization" and licensing of a 10 patent portfolio. Previously, Patriot successfully extracted money from AMD, and both companies previously argued with each other for years who owned certain CPU patents. But no more - the prospect of obtaining millions in licensing revenue has apparently smoothed over much of the ill-will that previously existed.

One practitioner described the portfolio as a "patent litigator's dream," and will likely cause great headaches for CPU firms. Three of the 10 patents are "elemental to virtually every microprocessor design",according to the companies. They are 5,809,336; 6,598,148; and 5,784,584.

Tuesday, June 07, 2005

CHINA STARTS GETTING WISE ON 337 ACTIONS - In a bit of poetic license, an undeclared "patent war" has been brewing between the US and China. Specifically, the US International Trade Commission (ITC) is becoming increasingly deluged by complaints from US companies about alleged infringement of their intellectual property, mostly patents, by Chinese imports.

Under US trade law, Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930 allows parties to petition the ITC for an order to stop importation of infringing goods at customs. As you can guess, Section 337 proceedings can be a huge headache for Chinese exporters, more so than anti-dumping measures, which, at worst, result in fines.

Potentially, the impact of a Section 337 order can be felt throughout an entire industry. When the ITC issues one against one product, it automatically applies to similar products as well. According to one comment, section 337 cases filed in the United States against Chinese companies since 1999 account for almost 40 percent of all Section 337 cases filed. Last year firms or goods from China again received the largest number of investigation notices, 11.
So serious has the trade threat become that the Chinese government has begun briefing companies on how to fight Section 337 claims.

[Blogger note - do you suppose advising companies not to blatantly infringe patents is a good idea, and such action could feasibly eliminate these pesky 337 actions?]

One interesting countermeasure for Chinese companies involves filing more patents in the US.

Why?

Well, for one, companies may give pause shooting off an infringement action knowing that you have some arrows in your own patent quiver. Second, and more importantly, once you start obtaining US patents, you can start filing your own 337 actions against competing products being imported into the US.

THE NEXT BRAVE NEW WORLD - INSURANCE PATENTS: According to Risk & Insurance, patenting insurance policies and other financial vehicles is a growing trend. Insurers, investment bankers and money managers are patenting aspects of policies and their administration, pricing and underwriting, as well as innovative financial products and services.

The trend could change the insurance industry, which has traditionally been a follow-the-leader market.

Since 1976, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has issued 404 patents using the word "insurance" in a filing; using the same criteria, 1,149 patent applications have been published at the PTO Web site since 2001.

It would seem from this that the insurance world is starting to heat up to patents (welcome!). I've noticed the same thing, where institutional insurance companies have been asking lots of questions and are starting to stockpile patents in their portfolios. However, I have noticed that there is still a lot of confusion regarding the patent system, especially in terms of "OK, I have a patent - now what?" Well good people, get out there enforce it!

MICROSOFT NICKED WITH EXCEL PATENT CLAIM - The US District Court of Central California court ruled that Microsoft had infringed Guatamalan inventor Carlos Armando Amado's patent and was ordered to pay almost $9m in damages. This figure relates to software sold between March 1997 and July 2003.

In a sense, Microsoft can breathe a sigh of relief, as the $9m is a far cry from the $500m originally being asked for. The jury rejected nine out of ten claims made by Amado.

In 1990 Carlos Armando Amado filed a patent for software which helped transfer data between Excel spreadsheets and Microsoft's Access database using a single spreadsheet. He said he tried to sell this technology to Microsoft in 1992 but they turned him down. According to Amado, Microsoft started including his software in their releases between 1995 and 2002.

So for now, Microsoft can go back to defending the other 60-or-so patent infringement lawsuits being asserted against it, including claims over Longhorn (from networking company Alacritech), as well as the battle with Forgent Networks, which claims the software giant infringed its JPEG picture compression patent.

Monday, June 06, 2005

WHO INVENTED THE JOY-STICK? Labeled "one of the most overlooked achievements of the last 100 years," CNET provides a soup-to-nuts breakdown of the joy-stick and its origin.

WHY DOES CHINA STEAL IP? In an article in Time, Anne-Stevenson Yang explains that pirating IP in China is not so much the function of greedy street-copiers, but is rather an official policy of the Chinese government, based on taxing regulated businesses:

China's trading partners tell themselves that this blatant disregard for the intellectual property of others is natural for a former command economy at an early stage of free-market development. The problem, they say, will ease over time as legal institutions and Chinese entrepreneurs mature and the country begins to attach the same importance to property rights as do Europe and the U.S.


No business should be foolish enough to believe this hypothesis. In a country where government-controlled companies comprise the industrial base, piracy is not derived from commercial callowness—it appears to be official policy. Authorities may be quite willing to mop up small, unregulated businesses to curtail street sales of counterfeit brands, but protecting core foreign technology is another matter. That is why Beijing declares victory when street sales of pirated DVDs move into licensed stores that present the same product in better packaging with money-back guarantees and, of course, taxes duly paid. That is why a decades-long campaign to clean up Beijing's "Silk Alley," a national showcase of pirated foreign sportswear and wristwatches, ends with fanfare when the new "Silk Street" shopping center opens, selling the same products under city regulation. And that is why China's leaders can promote a national campaign to protect intellectual property and at the same time declare that foreign patents useful to Chinese technologies may be legally expropriated, as Beijing's bureaucrats proposed in draft regulations released last year.

Friday, June 03, 2005

FRIDAY FUNNY: Last month, the Federal Circuit issued an opinion in Hoffer v. Microsoft, holding that courts can correct typos in issued patent:

When a harmless error in a patent is not subject to reasonable debate, it can be corrected by the court, as for other legal documents. See Novo Indus., L.P. v. Micro Molds Corp., 350 F.3d 1348, 1356-57 (Fed. Cir. 2003). Here the error was apparent from the face of the patent, and that view is not contradicted by the prosecution history.
Once the rule was established, the court published the opinion here - and then promptly issued an errata sheet to correct typos here - only to find that additional errors needed correction and issued a second errata sheet here.

- I'm refraining from making a "practice what you preach" comment . . . really I am.

(courtesy of Greg Aharonian's news service)

Thursday, June 02, 2005

TIME TO CODIFY PATENT APPLICATION DRAFTING? Dennis from Patently-O brings up an interesting point, raised during a round-table discussion in Corporate Legal Times, in that one can write a patent application today that is almost indecipherable, and still come out of the patent office with a patent.

Foreign-filed applications, especially those with minimum edits, are often the fodder for first-year associate snickering (or groaning, depending on the case) over the convoluted sentence structure, and run-ons that pervade these applications. However, domestic filings are often messy as well, and the constantly changing law coming from the Federal Circuit gives attorneys conniptions when trying to draft applications to fit the law-du-jour. For example:


US 2005/0084103
Recognizer of content of digital signals

Abstract:
Described herein is a technology for facilitating the recognition of the content of digital signals. This abstract itself is not intended to limit the scope of this patent. The scope of the present invention is pointed out in the appending claims.

This is a reaction to Hill-Rom Co. v. Kinetic Concepts, Inc., 209 F.3d 1337, where the CAFC found nonbinding a PTO rule that abstracts were nonlimiting. Another favorite (which I will confess to using in applications) is:


Although the invention has been described in language specific to the structural features and/or methodological steps, it is to be understood that the invention defined in the appended claims is not necessarily limited to the specific features or steps described. Rather, the specific features and steps are disclosed as preferred
forms of implementing the claimed invention.

Do statements like this have legal significance? Probably not, but there is little in the caselaw that shows otherwise.

On top of this, embodiments in an application should described as generically as possible to establish a maximum scope of equivalents, and any definitive language needs to be tempered to maintain that scope.

Also keeping in mind that the application will be reviewed by and Examiner, and possibly (a) an administrative judge, (b) an Article III judge, and/or (c) a jury (possibly with less-than-a-high-school-diploma-education), and your application now serves a plurality of masters. As they say, when you try to please everyone, you end up pleasing no one.

Perhaps additional reform is in order - maybe the USPTO (or even Congress) should think about putting language into the C.F.R./U.S.C. to codify parts of specification drafting . . .

Wednesday, June 01, 2005

INTERESTING STATISTICS FROM CAFC: The Boston Patent Law Association Newsletter recently printed highlights of Judge Lourie's keynote speech to the group, where he updated some facts on the Federal Circuit:

  • More cases are coming to the CAFC via summary judgment instead of a full trial (no suprise - thank you Markman);
  • Since Festo, the number of equivalents cases have dropped (again, no real surprise there);
  • As of December 2004, there were no cases that were pending for longer than a year;
  • Appeals to the CAFC have increased 40% in the last eight years, and 83% in the last fourteen years;
  • Reversal rate for patent cases from the district courts is a relatively high 35%;
  • Decisions from the USPTO are reversed in only 5% of cases

UK PATENT OFFICE TESTING PUBLIC COMMENT VIA E-MAIL ON PENDING PATENT APPLICATIONS: The UK Patent Office is introducing an e-mail option to help the public make comments on pending patent applications. Accordingly, if someone has evidence which will help the Patent Office decide if an invention is worthy of a patent, then they are encouraged to submit it.

These comments are are referred to as "section 21 observations" (named after section 21 of the Patents Act 1977) and have always been accepted from members of the public who can help the Patent Office with their assessment of whether an invention is patentable. The Patent Office is now helping more people exploit this opportunity by explaining the simple procedures on its website, and launching an address for e-mail submissions.

Tuesday, May 31, 2005

THANKS TO EVERYONE for their well-wishes over the last week. Baby's doing fine, although I suspect my son detected a "disturbance in the force" last night (i.e., dad needs to go to work in the morning) and decided to grunt and complain until 3:30 AM. Couple this with the fact that I also installed close to 750 square feet of decking over the weekend, and you have a recipe for sheer and utter exhaustion (my wife said this morning that I sound like a highly-caffeinated cross between Ben Stein and Homer Simpson)

Oddly enough, with the fatigue and 3 hours of sleep, all these office actions and court documents seem to make more sense to me right now . . .

NOKIA ANNOUNCES IT'LL PLAY NICE WITH ITS LINUX PATENTS: Last year, IBM took a step forward in cooperation with the free software community, by offering blanket licences for 500 of its patents to all free software developers. In January it was Sun's turn, where the world was reminded that Solaris was still free software (although Sun made it look like it was authorizing free software developers to practice thousands of software patents).

This week it was Nokia's turn. Nokia announced it would not use its patents to attack the developers of one specific free software project: the kernel Linux, developed by Linus Torvalds and others, which is most prominently used as the kernel of the GNU/Linux operating system.

However, the Free Software Directory lists over 4000 free software packages. Nokia's announcement says nothing about them, so they still face the potential threat of being attacked by Nokia in the future.

Linux developers are not happy.

UKPTO TRIES TO FIGURE OUT "TECHNICAL CONTRIBUTION", TO NO AVAIL: The UKPTO recently held a number of workshops on software patenting in the EU, with a particular focus on defining "technical contribution" for patentable claims (the report may be found here).

Attendees were given the opportunity to suggest their own definitions of "Technical Contribution". This resulted in some 208 responses including a number which appeared to reflect general opinions about the Directive at large, rather than focussing on the question at issue. To keep the number of definitions to a manageable number, 11 were selected for testing in the workshops. These reflected the most popular and were representative of a wide range of views. The responses selected included a definition provided by the Foundation for a Free Information Infrastructure (FFII). The definitions included:

Definition A: "Technical Contribution" means a contribution to the state of the art in a field of technology which is new and not obvious to a person skilled in the art. The technical contribution shall be assessed by consideration of the difference between the state of the art and the scope of the patent claim considered as a whole, which must comprise technical features, irrespective of whether or not these are accompanied by non-technical features.

Definition B: "Technical Contribution" means a contribution made by a claimed invention, considered as a whole, to the state of the art in a field of technology. "Technical" means belonging to a field of technology. New teaching about the use of controllable forces of nature under the control of a computer program, beyond the implementation of the data processing procedure itself, is technical. The processing, handling, representation and presentation of information by a computer program is not technical, even where technical devices are employed for such purposes.


These were the two more popular definitions, and as you may have already guessed, the definitions confuse the issue more than they define. In fact, the conclusion from the 13 workshops, which were attended by more than 300 people, was that the definition of technical contribution in the directive is "ambiguous and too liberal", the UKPO said.

The attendees of the workshop discussed in groups a number of fictional patent claims and assessed whether various definitions of technical contribution would allow these patents to be passed. Of the nine fictitious case studies the UKPO said should not have been patentable, four were let through by the directive's definition and only two were disallowed, with the remaining three leaving the workshop attendees unsure, according to the results on the UKPO website.

Steve Probert, deputy director at UKPO, admitted that a better definition may be found by modifying the current definition but said the UKPO cannot change the UK's political policy on this.

Thursday, May 26, 2005

NO, BLOGGER ISN'T ACTING UP AGAIN - Apologies to all for not posting over the last few days, but I have a rather pressing matter that I am taking care of this week - namely, the birth of my son, who was born on May 21st. Mom and baby are healthy, all the grandparents are giddy, and yours truly is looking for a quiet corner to curl into and take a long-needed nap.

I'll try to get some posts in over the next few days, but the regular posts won't start again until after Memorial Day.

Friday, May 20, 2005

BIG WEEK FOR PATENT LITIGATION - quite a few high-profile litigations flamed up this week, including CSIRO's WLAN patent, Microsoft's Excel patent, and Broadcom's recent complaint of infringement filed against Qualcomm in the district court and in the ITC. Pretty heavyweight stuff. I don't know how true this is, but one individual I talk to about these things thinks that spring/summer is "prime suin' time" for many companies. He couldn't give me any specific reasons for this conclusion (one theory was that the middle of a fiscal year is a decent time to determine if you have the resources to pick fights like this), but it would be interesting to obtain empirical data to see what time of year invites the largest number of lawsuits.

UK PATENT OFFICE MULLS ARBITRATION PROGRAM AS ALTERNATIVE TO LITIGATION: The UK Patent Office yesterday launched a consultation on its proposals to implement new powers, granted under the recent Patents Act, which will allow it to give non-binding opinions on patent validity and infringement.

This new service is intended to help parties test the strength of their arguments at the Patent Office before (or instead of) resorting to expensive litigation. It is hoped that such a service will encourage parties to settle their dispute promptly.

“By giving non-binding opinions on validity and infringement, the Office will be able to play a new and helpful role in resolving disputes over patents,” said Ron Marchant, Chief Executive of the Patent Office.

“It’s important that we hear from users how they think the new service should operate in detail. This will help us ensure that it fully achieves its aims – and so provides a quick, accessible and balanced procedure for assessing the key issues in a dispute over validity or infringement," he added.

- This is a great idea, and is worth a second look. But aside from validity issues (i.e., reexamination) this type of arrangement may be impossible to set up in the USPTO for infringement. Do YOU want to pay for experts, fees, discovery (albeit limited), only to end up with a non-binding opinion? I don't know many people that would . . .

TT EXTRACTS SETTLEMENT FROM PATSYSTEMS: Electronic screen dealing firm Patsystems has agreed to settle a patent infringement lawsuit brought by Chicago rival Trading Technologies.

The suit was filed yesterday in the United States District Court by TT, alleging that Patsystems has infringed certain of TT's patents.

In a brief statement, Patsystems says the lawsuit will be disposed of once the settlement has been approved by the Court.

Patsystems is the sixth firm to be accused of patent infringement by TT. The Chicago firm has claims outstanding against UK hedge fund manager Man Group, futures commission merchant Refco and bond trading network eSpeed. Chicago brokers Kingstree Trading and Goldenberg Hehmeyer both agreed an out-of-court settlement with TT within days of being sued by the vendor last year.

Wednesday, May 18, 2005

THE EU CONTINUES ITS PATH TO THE STONE AGE: The European parliament has renewed it opposition to the software patents directive, by making substantial alterations to the draft.

A report on the amended directive, penned by the bill's rapporteur, Michel Rocard, discloses that software would only be patentable if it controlled a physical process, or a controllable force of nature (welcome to 1984!). Patents would not be allowed for software that handles "the treatment, the manipulation, the representation and the presentation of information".

In normal circumstances, parliament would be restricted to introducing changes it proposed during the first reading. However, because the readings have crossed two presidencies, this requirement has been waived.

Unsurprisingly, the representatives of big business are not happy. Mark MacGann, president of Eicta told the FT: "This proposal would eliminate much of the patent protection accessible today by the industry in Europe. It goes against the fundamentals of existing patent law in Europe. Patents based on data processing would no longer be enforceable."

To pass these changes at the plenary vote in July, Parliament must accept them by an absolute majority. Anti-patent campaigners are concerned that this will make it difficult for the amendments to move forward.

One can only hope . . .

TOUGH CROWD . . . Dan Crevier is one of the co-inventors on US Patent 6,895,426 , titled "Addresses as objects for email messages." He was pretty happy to announce that his patent issued yesterday, and posted it on his blog. Trouble is, he is currently one of the architects on Longhorn as part of the ConnectUX team for Microsoft.

Microsoft.

Publicly disclosing that you work for Microsoft is the equivalent of admitting that you are a child molester to the Slashdot crowd. Accordingly, his blog became swamped with snide comments and half-hearted "congratulations" on his otherwise notable accomplishment. Predictably, he had to shut down the thread.

There's just no pleasing some people . . .

BLAME AUSTRALIA! (A.K.A. ATTACK OF THE BIG 5): Apple has joined Microsoft, Dell, Hewlett Packard, Intel and Netgear in a fight to break the U.S. patents on wireless technology held by Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO), which is an arm of the Austrailian government. CSIRO received US Patent 5,487,069, which claimed wireless LAN technology in 1996. The application was filed in November 1993 and claims AU priority to 1992. It turns out that the features claimed in this patent have become standards on notebook computers and other devices. This means that any company creating and selling Wi-Fi devices, such as Apple's AirPort Extreme, must pay CSIRO royalties on the revenue.

In February, CSIRO initiated a court case against the Japanese company Buffalo Technology, which had stopped paying the licensing fees for the technology. Now Apple and the five other companies want a judge to rule that CSIRO's patent is invalid and that none of them are in violation of it.

Can YOU say "battle royale"? Get out your WWF masks for this one . . .

Tuesday, May 17, 2005

FIRST KRAFT, NOW RIM: Ah, the smell of hiring! Shortly after Kraft announced their mass hiring of patent attorneys, Research In Motion (RIM) has put the call out for patent lawyers and patent agents to work in its Canadian and U.S. offices. In fact, RIM wants seven of 'em. This comes after, though not, unfortunately, before the Waterloo, Ont.-based outfit capitulated and paid out a big chunk of change -- $450-million -- to settle a long and extremely tiresome patent infringement lawsuit in the United States last March. The dispute over patents associated with RIM wireless technology has had a deleterious effect on its expansion into the U.S. market and its stock price (proof: the day RIM announced it had solved one of the U.S. five patent fights it has going on, the stock price jumped 20 per cent). The RIM seven, when hired, will have to sort out the other four.

Monday, May 16, 2005

COURT ISSUES STAY IN EBAY PATENT LITIGATION: Two years ago, a jury declared eBay had willfully infringed MercExchange's consignment fixed-price and software search agent patents, and eBay appealed. In March of this year, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled on the appeal and readied to send the case back to the lower court, paving the way for the lower court to possibly grant an injunction against eBay. But the Appeals Court granted a stay on May 11 until the Supreme Court rules on eBay's request to hear the case.

eBay said in a press release it intends to ask the Supreme Court to review aspects of the decision regarding MercExchange's consignment patent. It did not get specific about the basis for a Supreme Court hearing.

TOSHIBA AND MICROSOFT COZY UP: Toshiba and Microsoft have signed a patent cross-licensing deal enabling the two companies to use each other's patents freely in the computer and audiovisual equipment sectors.

The patents include those related to software technology in the two areas, according to a Toshiba spokeswoman.

With growth in its traditional PC centric market slowing, Microsoft is boosting its efforts to gain a presence in the newer digital consumer electronics arena, which is led by Asian companies like Sony and Samsung.

Friday, May 13, 2005

TRADING TECHNOLOGY EU PATENTS: I received a question recently regarding TT's EU patent portfolio, and in particular the comments of Steve Borsand during an interview with "Futures & Options Week" magazine (UK). Of particular interest was Steve's repeated denial during the interview that TT's patents were "business method patents":


Q: Some claim that TT's patents will not hold up in Europe because business method patents are not permitted there and because of Espeed's argument that there was a prior use of the invention before the patents were filed. What are your views on that?

A: The patents are, in fact, not business method patents. Business method patents cover a way of carrying out a business process, such as a way of processing a loan or a particular trading strategy. TT’s patents cover a tool or device used for order entry, not a business process. The commercial embodiment of the device happens to be implemented in software. The fact that the patents do not relate to business methods is evidenced by the patents TT obtained in Europe, where business method patents are not permitted.

- - - - - - - - -

[responding to a question regarding USPTO examination]


The criticism has more merit for patent applications that truly relate to business methods. An example of that would be a patent directed to a business process. As I mentioned before, TT’s patents are not business method patents.


I got a good chuckle out of that. First and foremost, the interview was done in conjunction with litigation currently pending between TT and just about the entire trading community in the US. Also, it is no great secret that TT is casting askew glances overseas to establish new licensing opportunities, particularly in the EU. Steve's a smart guy (I've heard him speak at a conference here in Chicago) - this interview was nothing more than the equivalent of an "Entertainment Tonight" or "Access Hollywood" type interview, where hunks and starlets wax eloquent on how "great" their lives and careers are, and all the new and wonderful projects they will be undertaking in the future. Steve knows that every opposing counsel will be watching his every word to try and catch him in an admission to use against him in court. As such, he's putting as much spin as possible on the TT portfolio for the interview.

Now, regarding the "business method" comment - he's splitting hairs, and he knows it. It is absolutely true that business method patents per se are not allowable in the EU. However, 99.99% of patent applicants almost never claim a bald business method, since everyone conducts business via computers nowadays. Accordingly, disclosures will invariably recite an "interface" or "computing process" or "automated system" (you get the idea) that essentially performs the business method, and effectively cloaking the method in "technical" language (anyone that drafted patents prior to State Street knows that old trick). Fortunately for Steve, the US, while allowing "pure" business methods, has never actually defined what a business method actually is (even the congressional record for the 1999 AIPA is silent there), so technically he's correct. And the EU Patent Office is still in flux on determining what a "technical effect" is, so that provides him with lots of wiggle room to pitch his applications.

But I don't think Steve's comments are intended for a US audience, but rather for the EU community. He knows that the EU Patent Office will jump all over TT's European patent applications like a monkey on a cupcake if they conclude that the claims are indeed "business methods." Take, for instance, this claim in this UK application:

1. A method of displaying market information relating to a commodity being traded in a market on an electronic exchange having an inside market with a highest bid price and a lowest ask price using a graphical user interface, the method comprising:

dynamically displaying a first indicator in relation to a first price level on a common price axis, the first indicator being associated with the highest bid price available in the market;

dynamically displaying a second indicator in relation to a second price level on the common price axis, the second indicator being associated with the lowest ask price available in the market; and

displaying an order entry region comprising a plurality of locations, each location being associated with a different price level on the common price axis and each location being arranged to receive a command to send an order to the electronic exchange at the associated price level;

wherein at least one of the first and second indicators moves relative to
the common price axis when the inside market changes.


Not a business method, eh? If you really wanted to put him on the spot, I would have asked the following questions:

(1) "Why would one skilled in the art NOT consider this a business method? What is your reasoning for this?"

(2) "Should financial processes conducted via computers EVER be considered business methods? Why or why not?"

(3) "Could you give me specific examples of patents you would consider 'business methods'? How are they different from yours?"

I could go on and on. But all this aside, one very important thing to keep in mind is that, while the EU has slipped through business method patents over the years (prohibition notwithstanding), I am not aware of a SINGLE instance where these patents have been actually enforced in EU courts. I've spoken with a number of EU practitioners, and they are unaware of any cases as well. Now, maybe TT is planning to blaze a new litigation path in the EU (Lord knows they may soon have the money to do it). But it's going to be a while before the political climate is right to pull that kind of action.

LAW FIRM BILLING - THE ICEMAN COMETH: Citigroup Private Bank recently conducted a study of law firm finances. The study found that, while billing rate increases accounted for two-thirds of law firms' 2004 revenue gains, they increased at a slower pace than in the prior year, forcing private practice firms to rethink their future growth strategies. Though corporate clients are forever scrutinizing their legal bills and demanding write-offs, law firms by and large have routinely gotten away with 6 percent to 8 percent rate hikes, even in a tepid economy. According to Corporate Counsel however, those days may be finally coming to an end.

In private conversations, general counsel at Fortune 100 outfits readily admit such penny-pinching is quickly set aside in bet-the-company cases. It's the other 99 percent of private-practice lawyers that have tough choices to make, warned the Citigroup study, which was based on the financial performance of 143 law firms across the country and is considered a top indicator of the state of the legal business. For more-run-of-the-mill work like licensing, trademarks and insurance defense, where specialization and prestige play a lesser role in the outcome, cost-cutting pressures will exact the highest toll, according to the study's analysis.

Thursday, May 12, 2005

JUDGE DECLARES MISTRIAL IN FINDWHAT.COM PATENT LITIGATION: FindWhat.com, Inc. announced a California jury was unable to reach a verdict in its patent infringement dispute with Overture Services, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Yahoo, and the Court declared a mistrial. FindWhat.com noted the judge has yet to rule on the issue of whether the patent is unenforceable because of inequitable conduct committed by Overture. A hearing on the inequitable conduct issue and other motions that could impact the ultimate outcome of the case is currently scheduled for June 24, 2005.

EBAY PATENT UPDATE: Located the auctions - here and here

Wednesday, May 11, 2005

UPDATE ON EBAY PATENTS - Apparently, EBay (or the owners) have decided to pull the auctions off the site - no idea what's going on . . .

MOBILE PHONE PATENT PORTFOLIO AUCTION ON EBAY: (From EBay) This unencumbered portfolio of fifteen patents and four pending applications offers an exceptional opportunity for companies in the fields of telephony, dot com, and computers, as well as the financial and service fields. It will work as a defensive patent arsenal, cross licensing material or early protection for a multitude of mobile-related enterprises. The patents also offer numerous possibilities for business expansions into a variety of telephonic areas.

The portfolio was prosecuted by the same team that prosecuted the famous Katz patent telephone computer integration for interactive call processing, which has accounted for record royalties of over $700 million (see the book “JUICE The Creative Fuel That Drives World-Class Inventors”, Evan I. Schwartz, Harvard Business School Press, 2004, beginning at page 320).

The patents cover many functional aspects in the expanding mobile telephone field. There are hundreds of claims in the portfolio with different groups directed both to telephone instruments and to central systems. Individual features of the patents have many applications including: keyless cellular phones, prepaid cellular phones, voice activation, cell phone business locators, voice-data transmission systems, programmable cell phone systems, mobile transaction systems, disposable cell phones, central system cell memory, no-number cell phones, and no battery cell phones.

A listing of the patents, and bidding prices can be found here. Bidding starts at $1 mil, and the auction ends on May 21.

Interestingly enough, they accept PayPal . . .

OTHER EBAY AUCTION: Door Locking/unlocking Phone US. Patent #6,161,005 for Sale for $138 million. Will offer $5 million in commissions (secondary). Auction ends on May 16, and bidding begins at $98 mil.

I'm not familiar with this patent, although the owner seems to have shopped the patent around for a while. The patent also seems to have attracted the derision of the Motley Fool as well. This seems like an astronomical amount of money to me, and the 9% royalty is excessive. Also, if you're seeking $138 mil for ONE patent, you figure one would provide more thorough details on the EBay site. I can't imagine why someone would pay this kind of money for what is essentially unproven technology.

NEW STUDY ISSUED ON 3G CELLULAR STANDARDS: Similar to the study done on open source by OSRM, David Goodman (Polytechnic University, USA) and Robert Myers (Fairfield Resources International, USA), released a study called "Analysis Of Intellectual Property For Third Generation Cellular Technology". It was based on an analysis of 7,796 patents and patent applications declared essential to the practice of third generation cellular technology standardized by two third generation partnership projects: 3GPP and 3GPP2.

The patents are clustered in 887 families, where each family covers one invention. Three quarters of the declared patents are assigned to four companies. A preliminary evaluation of one patent from each family under the study suggests that approximately 21% of the declared patents are actually essential. The paper presents the distributions of patents declared essential and patents judged essential according to technical category and patent ownership.

The paper concludes that a company that creates equipment or services for third generation cellular systems still faces a formidable task obtaining rights to patented technology. Even with the narrow definition of essential and the low ratio of essential patents to declared patents it may be necessary to acquire rights to several dozens of patents.

A copy of the paper can be downloaded here.

KRAFT TO DOUBLE ITS NUMBER OF PATENT LAWYERS: (Chicago Tribune) Worried about the growing ability of private-label competitors to mimic its products, Kraft Foods Inc. is doubling the number of its patent lawyers in a bid to protect its innovations. Speaking at the company's annual investor meeting at its Northfield headquarters, Chief Executive Roger Deromedi said the company's staff of about a dozen patent lawyers would soon be doubled.

Private-label competitors have eaten into market share in core Kraft categories ranging from cheese to crackers to cold cuts. The company has 2,100 worldwide patent families, which relate to each innovation or product, including 1,100 in the U.S. Deromedi said his company, the maker of Oscar Mayer hot dogs, Miracle Whip and Oreo cookies, had looked in detail at how effectively it spent its research and development money. Rather than spend more on research and development, he first wanted to make sure Kraft was focusing on the ideas with the best potential.

MORE DOOM 'N GLOOM ON AMERICA'S TECHNOLOGICAL FUTURE: More bellyaching from BusinessWeek on the lack of "technological leadership" in U.S. culture. I completely agree that we should be placing a greater emphasis on math and science in the schools, but if there is one thing I learned in life, it's that people do what they want to do, and they won't necessarily change because someone else tells them to. Moreover, I am not buying the notion that India and China are going to be running roughshod over us in the next decade, simply because they are producing scientists and engineers en masse. Scientific knowledge is one thing, but practical business application is something else.

Regarding India, people love to focus on the hype surrounding technical outsourcing, but conveniently forget that India is also regarded as having one of the highest illiteracy rates in the world. Combine that with the odious caste system, and the statist economy, and it's hard to imagine how businesses can reasonably prosper. I will concede that India has made great strides in the last decade in progressing its society and economy, but there is a long way to go before India will become a viable force (other than providing cheap labor) in the world economy.

As for China, the communist system and lack of free markets is a huge obstacle. One of the biggest challenges for China is to develop the hard institutional infrastructure of a market economy. The centerpiece of that infrastructure is a rule of law that protects property rights and limits the power of government. Therein lies the difficulty, for the CCP is unlikely to give up its power and let freedom reign. However, forces calling for economic and political change are strong. And the further the market advances, the more costly it will become for the CCP to try to reverse it.

Tuesday, May 10, 2005

STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE TO GETTING A PATENT, ACCORDING TO WSJ: The Wall Street Journal recently published a short guide for individual inventors that may be contemplating getting a patent. While the article is a bit thin on the details, it provides a decent overview of patenting, and the expectations that go along with the examination process. One of the more interesting statistics contained in the article is a "Reality Check" section that addresses the commercialization of patented products. Two questions posed to inventors revealed some interesting responses:

(1) How many of your inventions generated sales?

None --------------- 42%
1-5 Inventions ------ 36%
> 5 Inventions ------ 3%
Didn't Answer ------- 19%

(2) How many of your inventions generated profits?

None ---------------- 55%
1-5 Inventions ------ 20%
> 5 Invention ------- 2%
Didn't Answer ------- 23%

It would be interesting to see how involved patent counsel were in the commercialization process. While commercialization has traditionally been viewed as a "business decision", I have found that being involved in business strategy for a patented product can greatly improve the chances of obtaining monetary benefit for a client. Patents are often promoted to companies as legal instruments (which they obviously are), but are often neglected as business tools. Patent attorneys are becoming more and more business-savvy every day - cut out your patent counsel from the commercialization process, and you may be cutting out significant chunks of revenue you could be receiving from your products or processes.

INTERMEC POOLS RFID PATENTS: Intermec Technologies Inc. is attempting to simplify licensing agreements for its more than 145 radio-frequency identification (RFID) patents. Using a limited-time-offer approach, between June 1 and Aug. 31 Intermec will sell groups of its patents through four "portfolio families" to makers of RFID tags, readers, and printers.

Intermec previously sold each patent individually. The new approach includes a membership fee and royalties of 2.5% to 7.5%. Specific prices weren't disclosed.

While it has been possible for vendors to design and manufacture previous generations of RFID tags without infringing on Intermec's intellectual property, this appears to be more difficult with the Gen 2 RFID tags. Intermec owns patents for data encryption and increased read capabilities, which are affiliated with the Gen 2 tags.

Gen 2 tags eventually will replace Class-0 and Class-1 protocols. Retailers that have deployed RFID, such as Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and Metro Group AG, have begun testing the Gen 2 technology.

Monday, May 09, 2005

FIRST GOOGLE, NOW AMAZON: Google has gotten quite a bit of press over the last few days over its patent application that ranks news stories according to quality.

Currently the company's search engine throws up thousands of "hits" in response to simple entries such as "Iraq", which lead to news websites. These are ranked either in order of relevance or by date, so that the most recent or most focused appear at the top of the huge list. However, articles that arguably carry more "authority" (e.g., CNN or the BBC) can be omitted from the first page of results, simply because they are not as recent or as relevant to the keyword entered in the search line.

As a result, Google is planning to build a database that will compare the track record and credibility of all news sources around the world, and adjust the ranking of any search results accordingly.

The database will be built by continually monitoring the number of stories from all news sources, along with average story length, number with bylines, and number of cites, along with how long they have been in business. Google's database will also keep track of the number of staff a news source employs, the volume of internet traffic to its website and the number of countries accessing the site. Once the parameters are received, they are weighted according to various formulae, and distilled down to create a single value. This number will then be used to rank the results of any news search.

For whatever reason (I suspect the "sexiness" of being Google is a main consideration), everyone's been buzzing about the application. Of course, the original claims are overly broad - but what elso is new. And there hasn't even been a first examination on the merits.

In the meantime, Amazon.com recently received a patent titled "Method and system for information exchange between users of different web pages." Claim 1 reads as follows:

1. A method in a computer system for exchanging information between users of web sites, the method comprising:


providing a mapping between a first web site and a second web site;

when a first user accesses the first web site, providing a web page of the first web site;


receiving information from the first user; and


storing the received information based on the provided mapping; and


when a second user accesses the second web site, providing a web page of the second web site;


retrieving the stored information based on the provided mapping; and


providing a display of the retrieved information so that the first and second users can exchange information.



Pretty broad stuff. This would seem to cover RSS News Readers, TrackBack, and (oop!) Google News. From the looks of it, this smells like a GIGO examination (garbage-in-garbage-out); there are only two patents cited as prior art, and NO publications cited. There was only one rejection asserted during prosecution before the Notice of Allowance was mailed.

A prime opposition candidate? You bet.

Friday, May 06, 2005

MICROSOFT HOLDS A SPRING CLEARANCE SALE: In an announcement to a gathering of venture capitalists and entrepreneurs, Microsoft Intellectual Property (IP) Ventures is opening its doors to research labs a little and is offering what it says are 'hundreds' of innovations that can be licenced by start ups and venture capitalists.

Unlike IBM however, this IP comes at a price. Microsoft is willing to discuss terms which can be a mixture of royalties or stock options, but says it is flexible enough not to deter the bankers. While IBM initially drew a lot of praise for the move as a sign of its commitment to the open source community, a closer look showed that many of the patents were of little value. Microsoft, by charging money for its IP at least has the incentive to make sure the technologies on offer are worth paying for.

A list of the available IP can be found here.

Thursday, May 05, 2005

SOFTWARE PATENTS STRIKE BACK (PART II): In an excellent article in yesterday's TechNewsWorld.com, Heather J. Meeker posted a riposte to the open-source community's bellyaching over software patents. Specifically, she points out that, to date, open-source has a pretty impressive record in avoiding infringement claims in every area of IP. In fact, during the last ten years, very few intellectual property lawsuits have actually been filed relating to open source. The scorecard roughly looks like this:

  • Trademark infringement suits: 1 (MySQL-NuSphere)
  • Copyright infringement suits: 1/2 (SCO, after modifying the complaint)
  • Trade secret infringement suits: 1/2 (SCO, original complaint)
  • Patent infringement suits: 0
Why so few cases? Well, there are a couple of reasons:

One, many open-source projects are not-for-profit or marginally profitable. Large distributors of open source, like Novell or Red Hat, would be more profitable targets. But they are also the most likely to defend their position to the hilt, and not capitulate to demand letters.

Second, If damages are not an economically rational objective, that leaves injunctions -- which are attractive only to plaintiffs with competing products. Many open source products essentially have no competition. Those who compete with open source have their own problems. Also, any company that makes such a move risks excommunication from the software community and potentially creates a public relations nightmare. And as for the patent "trolls", they are obviously in it only for the money. If damages are not economically rational to seek, they will not seek them.

Finally, The success of patent lawsuits is tempered by doctrines of patent law like non-obviousness. A patent can be invalidated if the teachings of prior art render the claimed invention obvious. Since all open-source code is publicly available, the more open-source code is published, the fewer valid software patents will issue. This does not necessarily discourage lawsuits, because invalid patents can and do issue. But it makes patent lawsuits less successful.

Heather then offers the following challenge:

So, let's use the lovely technology of the Web to investigate this: Please comment on this article and, instead of explaining in theory why patents stifle innovation, give me examples -- name names, at least to the extent you can. Obviously, an actual patent lawsuit accusing open source would be highly visible and create headlines. What would not create headlines would be the kind of infringement threat that is quietly settled and swept under the rug. That is what I want to hear about. If patents are an immediate danger, I would like to know. But I want to hear facts, not rhetoric. And I also want to hear about the reaction to patent threats. Has the accused code been re-engineered? How long was it off the "shelf"?

So, to both the IP litigators who advise their clients that open source is dangerous, and the open source proponents who say that software patents are dangerous: If you think there is a troll under the bridge, you had better name him. Otherwise, people will think you are telling fairy tales.

Bravo.

Wednesday, May 04, 2005

EVER WONDER WHAT A DEMAND LETTER FROM ACACIA LOOKS LIKE? Well, here it is in all of its glory. The demand letter (dated September 30, 2004) for the '677 patent, along with a service provider license agreement, was scanned in, so you have to page through the document to read it in its entirety.

It is available courtesy of the Personal Telco Project, which is a volunteer group in Portland, Oregon that believes that "802.11 (wireless networking, or 'Wi-Fi') technology is both cool and empowering." Apparently, Acacia felt that the Hotspots formed by one of its members wasn't "cool" . . .

I haven't analyzed the agreement yet, but I'll try and provide some comments in the days to come. Interestingly, I did notice that the licence has a confidentiality clause - it makes me wonder why they were so eager to post it on their website.

SOFTWARE PATENTS STRIKE BACK (PART I): In the March 2005 publication of the Texas Law Review, professor Ronald Mann, publishes a well-written and long-needed study of the effects of patenting on the software industry, entitled "Do Patents Facilitate Financing in the Software Industry?" The Article is the first part of a wide study of the role of intellectual property in the software industry. Unlike previous papers that focus primarily on software patents—which generally are held by firms that are not software firms—the Article provides a thorough and contextually grounded description of the role that patents play in the software industry itself.

The article reaches some significant conclusions that have been advocated before by this blog, the most significant being that software patents are more beneficial to smaller companies than to larger companies.


The Article emphasizes the difficulties that prerevenue startups face in obtaining any value from patents, since litigation to enforce patents is impractical for those companies. Efforts to obtain patents often divert the company’s focus from the central task of designing and deploying a product, and the benefits of excluding competitors are limited for businesses that cannot themselves exploit the relevant technology. However, once the company starts becoming larger, a number of potential benefits appear. First, despite concerns that patents are not effective to appropriate profits from innovation in the software industry, a substantial number of software startups do have patents of sufficient strength to exclude competitors. That important finding, taken with the fact that the principal targets of those patents are much larger comapnies, suggests patents are more beneficial to small companies than to large companies.

Another important finding in the article is that the concept of patent "thickets" is bunk. It has been advocated by scholars and businesspeople that the enforcement of software patents has hindered innovation in the software industry through creation of a patent “thicket.” These laims were rejected for two broad reasons. First, direct evidence of high R&D spending in the software industry undermines claims that software patents cause firms to reduce R&D spending. Second, the actual structure and practices of the industry belie any claim of a patent thicket. The article shows that the development of young firms in the software industry is not significantly constrained by large patent portfolios in the hands of incumbent firms.

It is a groundbreaking article that I strongly recommend for anyone interested in software patents. The article also provides reasons why copyright protection is an extremely poor substitute for patent protection, and even suggests that patent "trolls" are (gasp!) good for the patent system.

Tuesday, May 03, 2005

IP AN ELECTION ISSUE? IN THE UK IT IS . . . Two days before the UK's general election, UKIP (UK Independence Party - not UK Intellectual Property ;)) attacked rival political parties for failing to understand the software patent issue, and the damage it claims they could cause.

An emailed statement said: "Software patents stifle innovation, unfairly favour big business, and curtail the rights and freedoms of individual computer programmers. Software patents can be used a tool to restrict freedom of ideas and freedom of expression. As a strong supporter of civil liberties and freedom of speech, this party could never support the introduction of such measures."

Some other notable nuggets from the UKIP include:

"All three major UK political parties have yet to make a stand against the introduction of software patents. They're asleep on the job as our liberties trickle away."

"If the legislation is passed, the only way to prevent the introduction of software patents in the UK would be to leave the European Union — a course of action that only UKIP favours."

Just where do they find these nut jobs in the EU to speak on software patenting issues anyways? Well, at least they didn't feel the compulsion to mention the one-click-patent, like every other article on software patents does . . .

A GREAT IDEA: (Chicago Sun-Times) When businesses face problems, the big guys have their McKinseys, Bains, Kearneys and Booz Allens as their braintrust. But what do the little guys have? Whom can they lean on when there's no way they can pay fancy hourly consulting rates for bright ideas? A genie?

Well, it happens that there really is one.

He's in the form of more than 10,000 current and retired business executives and professionals who are public spirited enough to be the ultimate organ donors: They give away their brains to help struggling enterprises make it.

In Chicago, the chief genie is Larry Pelka, 62, chairman of the local chapter of SCORE, the Service Corps of Retired Executives. Along with his crew of more than 100 volunteer consultants here, he's providing highly experienced (and formerly high-priced) management counseling to more than 5,000 deserving businesses in Cook and Lake counties. His 12-office chapter here is fourth largest among 389 chapters nationwide, coordinated by the Washington D.C. headquarters of this 40-year-old pro bono organization whose partner and supporter is the U.S. Small Business Administration.

And yes - he's got patent attorneys . . .

Thursday, April 28, 2005

INTERVIEW WITH NATHAN MYHRVOLD: Nathan Myhrvold, founder of Microsoft Research and former chief technical officer, is also the the founder of Intellectual Ventures, a somewhat mysterious and controversial start-up.

Combining the disciplines of a venture capital firm, a think tank and an intellectual-property firm, the company gathers well-known inventors for "invention sessions," hoping the get-togethers will one day result in hugely profitable patents. Investors are said to include Microsoft, Google and Intel. Myhrvold sees the company as a forum where brilliant minds will have the room and luxury to simply create.

But critics take a dimmer view of the venture, claiming it will inevitably encourage patent litigation and, paradoxically, discourage innovation. Nevertheless, Intellectual Ventures is likely to become one of the central figures in the ongoing patent debate.

CNET News.com has an interesting interview with Myhrvold that discusses the decline in invention, his company, and why some people get bent out of shape when the conversation turns to intellectual property.

One interesting comment brought up by Myhrvold deals with the level of passion stirred up by patents:

One thing that intrigues me about the whole patent area is the emotion it engenders. If you bring up patents to some people, they really get wound up.

Myhrvold: Yeah, it's very funny to me, and it's a cultural thing in that it depends on what industry you're from. In the medical device industry nobody gets worked up.

Really?

Myhrvold: Try it. Call somebody in Medtronics or U.S. Surgical or anyone of a hundred little start-ups that do medical devices. People generally don't have any problem with the patent system [BLOGGER NOTE: I sure hope this comment was made prior to the case ivolving Gary Michelson and the $1Bil settlement]. They may argue about a specific patent being valid or not. The same runs true with biotech. Go talk to biotech guys and ask them if they want the patent system abolished. They say, "My God!"

The one exception--and frankly, if you look at the world overall, it's one tiny blip of an exception, although it's one where I set my career--is in the computer industry. In computing, there has been a strong sense that patents were not the fundamental secret of success of most of the big companies. Oracle is very up front about them, saying they copied the SQL idea from IBM. And certainly Apple and Microsoft both learned a lot from Xerox.


Another interesting comment deals with the increase in patent litigation:

What do you think of the complaints of how patent litigation is hurting companies? Some days it sounds like the trumped-up malpractice crisis of the '80s.

Myhrvold: Well, this is even stranger. We actually did a study on this. The overall number of lawsuits for patents is growing, but so is the overall number of patents. So explain that to me. If you then look at it and ask, what fraction of those lawsuits are due to companies that have no products, the IP-only companies--it's about 2 percent. If you look at it and say what fraction of lawsuits are due to large technology companies, it's about 2 percent.

Definitely worth a read.

FORECAST FOR IP ATTORNEY HIRING LOOKS SUNNY: A new survey indicates that law firms and corporate legal departments are optimistic about adding staff in the coming year. Fifty-three percent of attorneys surveyed said they would be increasing staff in the next 12 months. Specifically, practice areas such as intellectual property, corporate law, real estate and litigation were forecast as experiencing the most consistent growth.

The survey was developed by Robert Half Legal, a staffing service specializing in attorneys, paralegals and other highly skilled legal professionals. It was conducted by an independent research firm and includes responses from 200 attorneys among the 1,000 largest law firms and corporations in both the United States and Canada.

Attorneys were asked, "Do you expect the number of attorneys employed with your firm or corporate legal department to increase, stay the same or decrease in the next 12 months?"

Their responses:

Increase 55%
Stay the same 41%
Decrease 3%
Don't know 1%

Wednesday, April 27, 2005

REDUCING BACKLOG MAY TAKE YEARS, BUT CONGRESS LIKES THE IDEA OF POST-GRANT REVIEW: Reducing a backlog of hundreds of thousands of pending patent applications could take several years, despite a budget boost that has enabled the Patent and Trademark Office to hire a record number of examiners this year, PTO director Jon Dudas said Monday.

The current backlog at the USPTO is about 490,000 applications. Dudas said PTO has received a record number of patent applications every year for the past 20 years, but did not begin hiring in record numbers until this year.

PTO received $1.6 billion in FY05, $342 million more than it received in FY04. Dudas said PTO is using much of that increase to hire 860 new examiners this year, for a total of about 4,400.

Judiciary ranking member Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., said lawmakers should consider modifying the process to allow for patent challenges "before costly, highly technical litigation is required."

Judiciary Intellectual Property Subcommittee Chairman Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, said there is a "high degree of agreement" among stakeholders on the need for a post-grant review process.

Tuesday, April 26, 2005

COULD WE SEE THE CONFLICT BULLETIN AGAIN? (From Law.com) During its ongoing patent litigation action against XFire, Yahoo officials were rather surprised when they walked into a meeting to discuss the company's infringement suit, and found that Xfire had brought along its attorneys, who happen to be from DLA Piper Rudnick Gray Cary.

Why the surprise? Funny you should ask - DLA is also representing Yahoo subsidiary Overture Services Inc. in a separate matter. Predictably, Yahoo asserted a conflict of interest and asked DLA to withdraw as Xfire's counsel.

DLA refused to do so.

Yahoo's attorney, Michael Jacobs, a partner at Morrison & Foerster, was not available for comment. But in a recent court filing, he pointed out that Yahoo's associate general counsel is managing the litigation against Xfire as well as DLA's Overture case.

As the article explains:

The alleged conflict arose as a result of Piper Rudnick's merger with Gray Cary Ware & Freidenrich and then DLA. Piper Rudnick originally represented Overture, and Gray Cary was counsel to Xfire before Yahoo filed its suit against the online gaming company for infringement in January. DLA contends that Overture and Yahoo are separate entities, so there is no conflict in being adverse to one and counsel to the other.

got that?

Powered By Blogger

DISCLAIMER

This Blog/Web Site ("Blog") is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Use of the Blog does not create any attorney-client relationship between you and Peter Zura or his firm. Persons requiring legal advice should contact a licensed attorney in your state. Any comment posted on the Blog can be read by any Blog visitor; do not post confidential or sensitive information. Any links from another site to the Blog are beyond the control of Peter Zura and does not convey his, or his past or present employer(s) approval, support, endorsement or any relationship to any site or organization.

The 271 Patent Blog © 2008. Template by Dicas Blogger.

TOPO